Lecture 3-4: Answering the Question She Actually Asked
Answering the question the child actually asked
Forming Faith at Home: A Course for Christian Parents
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Answering the question the child actually asked
Forming Faith at Home: A Course for Christian Parents
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
A child may ask "Why did God let my grandma die?" at bedtime, in the car, or weeks after the funeral. What a parent says in the next ten seconds matters a great deal. Parents most often go wrong in one of two opposite ways: they dismiss the question, or they bury it in too much theology.
The lecture reads this as a claim, not a flourish. Knowledge begins with reverence toward God, not with having every answer. So a parent does not need every answer to form a child's faith rightly in this moment.
The fear of Yahweh is the beginning of knowledge; but the foolish despise wisdom and instruction.
A parent needs to take the question seriously, stay honest about what is and is not known, and not treat the unanswered question as a threat to faith. A child who watches a parent hold a question with reverence, not panic or false confidence, is watching the beginning of knowledge modeled and not just stated.
"Don't worry, just trust God," with a change of subject. The child learns the question was unwelcome. She stops asking, but the wondering goes on without a trusted adult.
A full account of theodicy answers an adult-sized question. The child's real question is closer to "Is God still good, am I safe?" She concludes the question was too big to ask.
The lecture's modeled answer does not try to solve the problem of evil. The parent says honestly that they do not fully know, that sadness and anger are okay, and that God is close to hurting people. Then the parent invites a memory of Grandma. It is honest, it does not treat grief as a faith problem, and it stays story-shaped.
This question is more intellectual, and a child of nine to twelve deserves to hear that serious adults ask it too. The modeled answer says God wants trust, not forced belief, like the difference between being loved by choice and being loved with no other option. The parent also says plainly that this does not fully answer it.
Both answers avoid pretending to a settled answer and avoid changing the subject. Both stay concrete and relational, and both are short enough for a child to take in. An honest "I don't fully know, but here is what I do know" leaves a door open for the child to come back later.
The lecture asks you to think of one real question a child in your life has asked or is likely to ask, and to write an honest answer in your own words.
Does your draft change the subject, or answer an adult-sized version of the question?
A hard question is answered well by reverent honesty, not by a complete answer. Keep it concrete, story-shaped and short, and avoid both dismissal and over-explanation. Both send the same unintended message: that the question was not safe to ask.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.