FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM203E Forming Faith at Home: A Course for Christian Parents

Lecture 5-3: What Regret Is For

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 25
LM203E Forming Faith at Home: A Course for Christian Parents
Chapter 0 · Introduction: The First School of Faith
  1. Lecture 0: The First School of Faith
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: A Theology of Christian Parenting
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Home as a First School of Faith
  2. Lecture 1-2: What Belongs to the Parent, What Belongs to the Church
  3. Lecture 1-3: A Faith That Fits the Vessel
  4. Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab — Drafting Your Household's Faith Transmission Map
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Faith in Early Childhood (Ages 0-6)
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Soil Faith Grows In
  2. Lecture 2-2: Faith Through the Body Before Faith Through the Mind
  3. Lecture 2-3: Discipline and Love as One Act
  4. Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab — One Ordinary Day, Observed
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Faith in Middle Childhood (Ages 7-12)
  1. Lecture 3-1: Why Story Lands and Argument Doesn't Yet
  2. Lecture 3-2: Rhythm Outlasts the Memorable Lesson
  3. Lecture 3-3: What the Church Does That the Home Cannot, and the Reverse
  4. Lecture 3-4: Answering the Question She Actually Asked
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Faith in Adolescence (Ages 13-18)
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Work of Adolescence, Not the Collapse of Faith
  2. Lecture 4-2: Making Room for Doubt Without Losing the Conversation
  3. Lecture 4-3: From Controlling to Coaching
  4. Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab — Answering It in the Room
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: When It Doesn't Go as Planned
  1. Lecture 5-1: When a Child Walks Away
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Family You Actually Have
  3. Lecture 5-3: What Regret Is For
  4. Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab — One Concrete Step
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Parent's Own Formation and Legacy
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Wellspring
  2. Lecture 6-2: Leaving and Cleaving, Read the Other Direction
  3. Lecture 6-3: Lois, Eunice, and the Third Generation
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Letter

Jump to the key points ↓

14 min

Nearly every parent who takes their child's faith formation seriously enough to be reading a course like this one also carries a list, sometimes a long one, of specific failures: a season of anger handled badly, a promise not kept, a church left in a way that confused a child, years given to work or crisis that were not given to the child, a harsh word that is still remembered decades later by the person who said it or the person who heard it. This lecture is about what to do with that list — not to minimize it, and not to let it become the thing that governs the rest of a parent's life.

The distinction this lecture turns on is between two things that feel similar from the inside but function completely differently: repentance and repair on one hand, and a guilt that never resolves into anything on the other. The research psychologist and writer Brené Brown, working from a secular therapeutic framework rather than a theological one, has usefully distinguished guilt ("I did something bad") from shame ("I am bad") — the first, she argues, is generally adaptive, because it can motivate a specific change or repair; the second is generally corrosive, because there is no specific act to repair when the verdict has been rendered against the whole person rather than the deed. Brown's distinction is a helpful diagnostic tool, engaged here critically rather than adopted wholesale, because Scripture's account of what actually resolves guilt goes further than her framework does, and this lecture will say where.

What these 14 minutes give you

  • Distinguish repentance and repair (naming a specific failure and taking a concrete step to address it) from a guilt that repeats itself without ever resolving into action.
  • Describe what a concrete apology to a now-grown child can look like, and why specificity matters more than the size of the gesture.
  • State the theological ground Romans 8:1 gives for a parent moving forward, and explain why "no condemnation" is a legal and relational claim, not merely an emotional reassurance technique.
  • Explain what Joel 2:25's picture of restored years does and does not promise, and why overclaiming it (as guaranteeing that lost time will be literally undone) is a defect this lecture is naming on purpose.

I will restore to you the years that the swarming locust has eaten, the great locust, the grasshopper, and the caterpillar, my great army, which I sent among you.

There is therefore now no condemnation to those who are in Christ Jesus, who don't walk according to the flesh, but according to the Spirit.

Joel 2:25 (World English Bible):

Romans 8:1 (WEB):

1. Guilt that resolves, and guilt that repeats

Brown's distinction is worth using carefully rather than treating it as the final word. Applied to parenting regret specifically: a parent who thinks "I handled that badly, and I should say something to my daughter about it" is naming a specific failure and moving toward a specific repair. A parent stuck instead on "I was a bad father" or "I ruined my son's faith" has moved from an act to a verdict on the whole person — and a verdict on the whole person cannot be repaired by any single action, because it was never framed as being about an action in the first place. That second pattern does not resolve. It repeats, often for years, sometimes for a lifetime, precisely because there is nothing concrete it can be discharged by doing.

The test this lecture proposes is simple and practical: does the regret, as currently held, point toward a specific next action, or does it only point back at itself? "I regret how I handled his questions about doubt when he was sixteen, and I want to tell him that, specifically" is regret pointing toward action. "I failed as a parent" is regret pointing only at itself — and, notably, it is also the kind of claim a careful reader should distrust: an unqualified universal claim about an entire parenting relationship, stated as though it were established fact rather than a feeling that has hardened into one.

2. The concrete apology

Two ways to say sorry

Where genuine repair is possible — a now-grown or older child, a specific remembered incident, an ongoing relationship — this lecture recommends a concrete apology over a general one, and recommends it as the harder and more theologically serious option, not the easier one. "I'm sorry if I ever hurt you" names nothing and asks nothing of the parent; it can be said without remembering a single incident. "I remember the way I responded when you told me you weren't sure you believed anymore, when you were sixteen. I was afraid, and I made it about winning the argument instead of hearing you, and I am sorry" names a specific failure, in specific language, and gives the child something concrete to receive or respond to, rather than a vague gesture to accept out of politeness.

Not every situation allows this — some incidents are too old to reconstruct accurately, some relationships are not in a place where the conversation would land as intended, and a parent should use real judgment, ideally with outside counsel, about timing and whether the apology serves the child or mainly serves the parent's own need to have said it. But where it is possible, specificity is not a nicety. It is the difference between an apology that can actually be received and one that only sounds like one.

3. What Romans 8:1 actually claims

It would be easy to use Romans 8:1 as a piece of emotional reassurance — a verse to recite when the guilt gets loud, functioning mainly as a mood-changer. That undersells what the verse is actually claiming. "No condemnation" is a legal and relational term, not a feeling; Paul is making a claim about a person's actual standing before God, not offering a technique for feeling better about it. The claim is that a parent who has genuinely repented — named the failure honestly, sought forgiveness where it can be sought, and taken whatever step of repair is available — stands, in Christ, under no verdict of condemnation for that failure, regardless of whether the guilty feeling has fully subsided. This matters because the feeling of guilt and the actual legal-relational status before God are not the same thing, and a parent who confuses them will keep looking to the feeling for a permission that the feeling was never designed to grant. The feeling may take time to catch up to what is theologically already true; Romans 8:1 states what is true regardless of the pace of the feeling.

4. What Joel 2:25 promises, and what it does not

Promise, not rewind

Joel 2:25 is often quoted in a way this lecture wants to name and correct. In its own context, the verse is God's promise to restore agricultural and covenantal fruitfulness to a nation after a locust plague and a period of judgment — a promise of future flourishing that outweighs the loss, not a claim that the specific years the locusts ate are given back unchanged, as though they had never happened. Applied to a parent's regret, the honest and defensible version of this promise is that God can bring real fruitfulness in a relationship going forward — including, sometimes, a closeness that would not have existed without the honest repair the failure eventually provoked — not that the damage of a specific bad year can be literally undone or that a grown child's difficult adolescence will be erased from both of their memories. Promising the second thing is the kind of overclaim to avoid: rhetorically satisfying, but not what the text actually says, and a parent who is told to expect the years themselves back, rather than fruitfulness going forward, has been set up for a second disappointment layered on the first.

5. Moving forward, not moving on

"Moving on" suggests the failure stops mattering. That is not what this lecture is recommending, and it is not what Romans 8:1 or Joel 2:25, read honestly, promise. "Moving forward" is closer: the failure is named, repaired where repair is possible, held under no condemnation theologically, and no longer given the authority to determine what the parent does next. A parent stuck in unresolved guilt over the parenting of a sixteen-year-old is often, ten years later, still parenting from that same guilt rather than from where the relationship actually stands now. Moving forward means letting the concrete repair — the conversation, the apology, the changed pattern — do the work guilt was never able to do on its own.

Two Directions Regret Can Take Repentance and Repair "I handled that badly — I should say something." Names a specific act Points toward one next step Can be discharged by doing it Romans 8:1 — no condemnation Guilt That Repeats "I was a bad father." "I ruined her faith." Names a verdict on the whole person, not an act Nothing concrete can discharge it, so it repeats not The test: does this regret point toward a next action, or only back at itself?

In short

  • Brown's distinction between guilt ("I did something bad") and shame ("I am bad") is a useful diagnostic, engaged critically: Scripture's account of resolution goes further than a therapeutic framework alone provides.
  • Regret that names a specific act and points toward a specific repair resolves; regret that renders a verdict on the whole person tends to repeat rather than resolve.
  • A specific apology to a now-grown child is theologically more serious, not merely more effective, than a general one — but real judgment about timing and whether it serves the child is required.
  • Romans 8:1's "no condemnation" is a legal and relational claim about actual standing before God, not a mood-management technique, and it does not depend on the guilty feeling having fully subsided.
  • Joel 2:25 promises future fruitfulness that outweighs the loss, not that the specific lost years are given back unchanged — claiming the second is an overclaim this lecture deliberately corrects.

One-sentence summary: Regret that names a specific failure and moves toward a specific repair resolves into action under the real ground of Romans 8:1's "no condemnation"; regret that renders a verdict on the whole person repeats instead, and Joel 2:25 promises fruitfulness going forward, not the literal return of what was lost.

Terms to remember: guilt versus shame, the concrete apology, no condemnation, restored years (not restored time).

Carry forward to 5-4: this chapter's three lectures named three situations — a departed child, a non-traditional household, unresolved regret. The Practice Lab asks you to identify which is closest to your own life and take one concrete step.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a specific parenting failure you regret. Using this lecture's test, does it currently point toward a specific next action, or does it mostly point back at itself? What would it take to reframe it as the first kind?
  • Brené Brown's guilt/shame distinction is a secular tool this lecture engaged critically. Where does it help, and where does Romans 8:1 go further than it does?
  • Why does this lecture argue that a specific apology ("I remember when I...") is theologically more serious than a general one ("I'm sorry if I ever hurt you"), not merely more effective?
  • Read Joel 2:25 in its own context (the surrounding verses in Joel 2, if you have time). What does this lecture argue the verse promises, and what does it argue the verse does not promise? Do you agree with where the line is drawn?
  • What is the difference, as this lecture uses the terms, between "moving on" from a parenting failure and "moving forward" from one?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.

Questions and answers

Questions asked here are answered within 7 days.

No questions on this lecture yet. Yours can be the first.

Sign in to ask a question or write an answer. Sign in