Lecture 2-3: The Art of the Question
Open questions invite a story; closed questions invite a word
Listening Well: Foundations of Lay Pastoral Care
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Open questions invite a story; closed questions invite a word
Listening Well: Foundations of Lay Pastoral Care
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
A closed question can be fully answered in one word, a yes or no, or a short fact. Closed questions are not bad, and sometimes a listener needs a quick fact. But they hand the speaker a narrow lane, and most people stay in it. Even someone who is plainly not okay will usually say they are fine.
An open question cannot be answered in one word. "What has this week actually been like for you?" cannot be answered "fine" without sounding evasive. Its shape pulls for a fuller sentence, a story, a piece of the real texture of someone's life. A listener who wants more than a one-word report must ask a question a one-word report cannot satisfy.
Advice feels active, and a question can feel like handing the work back. But advice needs the listener to already understand the situation, which is rarely true early on. It also ends the exploration, because the other person now responds to the advice. An open question needs no answer from the listener and invites the person to keep going.
The lecture notes that Jesus already knew what Bartimaeus needed and could have healed him without a word. Instead he asked an about-as-open-as-possible question. Bartimaeus named his own need in his own voice. A lay listener rarely has certain knowledge of what someone needs, so asking matters even more.
Jesus asked him, "What do you want me to do for you?" The blind man said to him, "Rabboni, that I may see again.
"What has that actually been like for you?" and "What's been the hardest part of this?"
"What would be helpful right now: do you want me to just listen, or are you looking for ideas?"
"What do you make of it, looking back?" and "What would you want to be different, if you could change one thing?"
"Have you thought about maybe just talking to him directly?" is grammatically a question, but its content is advice in a softer form. The speaker usually senses the disguise, and the conversation ends the same way: they respond to the suggestion instead of exploring the situation. A check is whether the question could honestly be answered with something the listener did not already have in mind.
Think of a closed question you often ask, such as "Did you sleep last night?" or "Is work still stressful?"
How could you turn it into an open question that does not hide advice inside it?
A closed question gets a word, and an open question gets a story. An open question usually does more than well-meant advice, because it needs no answer from the listener and invites the person to keep talking. Jesus' question in Mark 10:51 is the model, and a question that hides advice is not open.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.