FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

LM205E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-2: Hearing One Side Without Ruling on It

Take one side seriously without ruling on the whole case

Listening Well: Foundations of Lay Pastoral Care

13 cards 13 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State what Proverbs 18:17 teaches about one-sided accounts and explain why it applies even when the speaker is being completely honest.
  • Explain Ken Sande's caution against "playing judge" and give a concrete example of what silently ruling on a conflict sounds like in a listener's response.
  • Describe the difference between validating a person's feelings and validating their account of a conflict as the full, neutral truth.
  • Name at least two things a lay listener should not attempt to do when only one party to a conflict is present, and why.
The discipline

Two things held at once

A friend telling you about a fight is not handing you a transcript. They are handing you their side, sincerely believed and shaped by what makes their account make sense to them. The discipline is to hold two things together: take what is said fully seriously, and refuse to render a verdict when only one witness has spoken.

Key idea Serious listening, no verdict.
Scripture

Why Proverbs 18:17?

The lecture says this verse is not about liars. It describes something structural about any one-sided account, true or false. A coherent, emotionally convincing account is not the same thing as a complete one.

He who pleads his cause first seems right; until another comes and questions him.
The trap

What gets affirmed

A listener's instinct is to affirm, and support is part of the job. Affirming that a person's hurt is real is almost always right. Affirming their account as an accurate, neutral record of what the other person did and why is a different act. That is the one Proverbs 18:17 warns against, because that record has been heard from one side only.

Key idea Validate the feelings, not the account as the full truth.
Ken Sande

Playing judge

Sande, founder of Peacemaker Ministries, names the temptation of stepping into the role of deciding who is right in someone else's conflict. A listener who hears one compelling account forms a settled opinion and starts communicating it, perhaps with a raised eyebrow. Most people who bring a conflict to a listener want to be heard, not to have their case decided.

Key idea You were never appointed judge.
At a glance

How the language gives it away

A verdict dressed as sympathy

"I can't believe he would do that." This has already closed the door on a fuller picture.

Keeps the door open

"That sounds like it hurt a lot." This stays with the speaker's experience.

At a glance

Three things to avoid with one party present

Do not decide who is at fault

An instinct formed from half the evidence can be held privately as tentative, never delivered as a conclusion.

Do not coach accusatory language

Helping someone raise a concern calmly is fine. Supplying words for an argument you heard one side of risks arming a case built on incomplete information.

Do not promise to back one party up

You have only heard one side, so you can only testify to what you were told.

Safety

Not neutral about real wrong

None of this means staying neutral about right and wrong in general. Real wrong such as abuse, betrayal, or ongoing cruelty is still wrong. A pattern that sounds like a real safety concern moves the conversation into Chapter 5's territory. The caution here is about a single account of an ordinary marital or family disagreement.

Key idea A safety concern goes to Chapter 5.
In practice

What listening well looks like

Reflect content and feeling: "it sounds like you felt dismissed when he said that." Ask open questions: "has this come up before?" And name the limit gently and early: "I'm only hearing your side, and that's okay, I just want to be honest that I can't know the whole picture."

Key idea Naming the limit protects both of you.
Think about it

Catching the verdict

The lecture says a verdict often shows up in the language before it is a conscious decision.

What sentence would you catch yourself saying that sounds like sympathy but is really a ruling? What would you say instead?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Hear one side of a conflict by taking the account fully seriously while refusing the verdict the format cannot support. Proverbs 18:17 and Ken Sande's caution against playing judge name the same trap from two directions.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13