Lecture 6-4: Honest Review Without Counting People
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Youth, Marriage and Singleness
- Lecture 1-2: Who Is a Young Adult? Who Is Single?
- Lecture 1-3: How Churches Talk About Marriage and Singleness
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Go: Honest Motives
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The People Near Me and My Own Words
- Lecture 2-1: Work, Money, Home and the Unfinished Years
- Lecture 2-2: Belonging, Friendship and the Screen
- Lecture 2-3: Doubt, Questions and Leaving
- Lecture 2-4: Cultures of Young Adult Life
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Week in a Young Adult's Life
- Lecture 3-1: What Peer Ministry Is
- Lecture 3-2: Groups and Tables Anyone Can Join
- Lecture 3-3: Loneliness and Staying Beside
- Lecture 3-4: Across Ages: Mentors, Elders and One-to-One Safely
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Message and a Table
- Lecture 4-1: Scripture on Love and Marriage, and How Traditions Differ
- Lecture 4-2: Dating and Sexual Ethics Without Condemnation
- Lecture 4-3: When Things Go Wrong
- Lecture 4-4: Dating Online, Messaging and Digital Life
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Hearing a Hard Story
- Lecture 5-1: Called to Singleness, Waiting to Marry, Choosing Not To
- Lecture 5-2: Divorced, Widowed, and Alone Again
- Lecture 5-3: Mental Health, Addiction and Crisis: Warm Referral
- Lecture 5-4: Single Parents, Carers and the People We Overlook
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Warm Referral
Every group that cares about people needs to know whether it is doing them good. The easy way to find out is to count: how many came, how many joined, how many stayed. Counting is simple and it feels like honesty. But it can tell a group almost nothing about the question that matters, which is whether people felt met.
This lecture is about a different kind of review. It asks a small set of honest questions once a year, puts them to the people themselves, and uses the answers to change two or three things. It does not give a score. It treats young adults and single people as members whose view of the church matters, and not as numbers on a chart.
The course gives no statistics and no targets, and this lecture does not suggest any. It does not say that numbers are wicked. It says that numbers answer the wrong question when they are used as the measure of success.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Explain why counting attendance or joining tells a group little about whether people were met.
- Name the main questions of an honest yearly review.
- Describe three ways to ask members what they think, without making any one person speak for a whole group.
- Describe how to receive a hard answer without defending, and how to choose what to change.
- Explain why a person who declines or leaves is not simply a failure.
I planted. Apollos watered. But God gave the increase. So then neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase." — 1 Corinthians 3:6-7
World English Bible
When he comes home, he calls together his friends and his neighbors, saying to them, ‘Rejoice with me, for I have found my sheep which was lost!’" — Luke 15:6
WEB
Search me, God, and know my heart. Try me, and know my thoughts." — Psalm 139:23
WEB
Counsel in the heart of man is like deep water; but a man of understanding will draw it out." — Proverbs 20:5
WEB
Paul reminds a church that growth is not the planter's to produce, and that planter and waterer are both only servants. The shepherd of Luke 15 does count, but he counts in order to notice the one who is missing, and the joy at the end is about that one sheep that was found. The psalmist asks God to search him, which is an invitation to honest review and not a verdict. The proverb says that what a person really thinks lies deep, and a wise listener draws it out.
1. Two kinds of count
(an invented example) A congregation holds a monthly evening for young adults. At the end of the year, the leader, Kofi, reports to the church council: "We averaged forty-two. That is up from last year." The council is pleased.
Some weeks later, Kofi meets Mei, who used to come and has not been for five months. He asks why. "Nobody noticed I stopped," she says. "I was on night shifts, and the evening moved to a time I could not come. I thought somebody might message me. It's all right. The food was always good."
Kofi's number was true. Forty-two people came. It was also not an answer to anything that mattered. It did not tell him that the time shut out the people who work nights, or that the evening had a pleasant surface and little else, or that one person slipped away unseen. The number measured the evening. It did not measure whether people were met.
2. Why numbers mislead
Attendance is a poor measure of belonging for several reasons.
- It can rise for the wrong reason. A free meal, a famous speaker or a pleasant venue can fill a room. The same people may feel no more known than before.
- It can fall for the right reason. A group that has helped a number of people grow strong enough to move on, to marry, to move cities or to start leading elsewhere may look smaller.
- It cannot see who is not there. A room of forty-two says nothing about the fifty who never came because of the time, the cost, the language, the alcohol, the childcare or the unspoken rule that the group is for a certain kind of person.
- It tempts a group to aim at the number. A leader who must show growth begins to treat people as figures: the quiet ones as risks, the leaving ones as failures, the newcomers as a score. That is the opposite of walking beside.
- It tells nothing about harm. A group can be full and a leader can be crossing a line.
This does not mean that every number is useless. A group needs to know how many chairs and how much food to prepare. Numbers used only for planning are fine. The danger is to treat them as the measure of whether the ministry is good.
The shepherd in Luke 15 does count. But he counts to find the one who is missing, and what he does with the count is to go after that person. A review that notices who is absent is a different thing from a review that adds up who is present.
3. The questions of an honest review
Once a year, a group, its leaders and the responsible person can sit down together and ask these questions. Use some or all of them. Write short answers. Do not give marks.
- Did people feel met? Not "did they come," but "did they feel known by name, listened to, and welcome?"
- Who is missing? Who did we expect and have not seen? Who has never come? Who left? Think about members who are single, divorced, widowed, shift workers, students, migrants, parents, carers, people with little money, people who do not drink, people with a disability, people who are quiet. Do not make a list of names; make a list of kinds of people who may find the door shut.
- What words shut people out? Sayings, jokes, prayers, the way we introduce each other, assumptions about marriage, work or background.
- What times, places and costs shut people out? Evening hours, distance, transport, the price of a meal, a venue with stairs, a bar as the meeting point.
- What did people say they wanted? And what did we do with it?
- What did we do that hurt someone? Did anyone tell us, or did we only hear by chance?
- Who carries the work? Is it the same few? Is anyone close to burnout? (Lecture 6-2.)
- Are the boundaries being kept? One-to-one meetings in the open; private messaging; the written policy; the responsible person told. Is there a way for someone to raise a concern about a leader, and does the person they would tell know what to do?
- Is the help sheet current? (Lecture 6-3.)
- What do we hope will be different next year? Choose two, no more.
The questions are for a group's own honesty. They are not an inspection and they do not give a grade.
4. Ask the people
The strongest rule of this lecture is: ask the people, do not guess. Leaders usually believe they know how the group is doing, and they are often wrong, because people tell leaders what leaders hope to hear.
Three ways to ask, and a group may use more than one.
A conversation over a meal. A leader, or better a person who is not the main leader, invites a member for a coffee or a walk and asks two or three open questions: "What has this year been like for you in the church? What helped? What was hard?" The person who asks listens and does not argue.
A short written note, which can be anonymous. Five questions, on paper or a simple form, and a way to hand it in or send it without a name. Some people will be more honest this way. Keep it short and plain, and write in the languages your members use. Make sure no one can be identified from their answers in a small group.
A conversation with those who have stopped coming. This is delicate and should be done once, kindly, by someone who knew them and who is not the leader whose group they left. The message is not "why did you leave us" but "we would like to know how it was for you, and you owe us nothing." Accept a no. Do not chase. Lecture 2-3 spoke about leaving; the same gentleness applies.
Two cautions. First, do not ask one person to speak for everyone like them. A single member is not "the voice of the singles" or "the voice of the young." Ask many, and ask each as themselves. Second, keep what people say private. Report themes, not names, and never repeat a comment in a way that shows who said it.
5. Hearing a hard answer
(an invented example) A member writes: "I feel like the group is for people who are about to get engaged." The leader's first thoughts are likely to be defensive: That's not true. We have a couple of single people on the team. Pause there. The member did not say the group excludes single people; they said how it felt. A feeling is a fact about the person even if the group's intentions were different.
A few habits help.
- Thank before you answer. "Thank you for telling us." Nothing more at first.
- Do not defend. You may explain later; do not explain now.
- Ask what would help. "What would have made it feel different?"
- Separate "that hurt" from "that was wrong." Both may be true, or only one. You need not agree with every criticism to take it seriously.
- Look for the pattern. One comment is one person's view; the same comment from five people is a pattern.
- Choose two things to change, write them down, and do them. A review that produces ten resolutions produces none.
- Tell people what changed. If people ask and nothing comes back, they stop answering. A short note at the end, "you said, we did," builds trust.
If a concern about a leader's conduct appears in a review, it is not for the group to weigh alone. Tell the responsible person at once, and follow the policy. If the concern is about the responsible person, go to the next level.
6. A person who declines is not a failure
A group can drift into counting people as results: "we reached eight new people," "we lost three." That language treats a person as a unit of success or failure. Some people come for a season, get what they need, and go. Some decline an invitation because they are content. Some are in a different tradition and are in your group for friendship. Some leave because the thing they needed, the chance to talk about a hard time, was given, and now they are well and busy. Some leave because of hurt, which a review can find out.
A team that makes fewer contacts, and makes them well, may be doing right. A group that has twelve people who are known by name may be doing more than a group with sixty who are not. Paul's lesson in 1 Corinthians 3:6-7 is that those who plant and water are servants, and that God gives the growth. That is not a reason to be careless; it is a reason not to treat our own numbers as the proof of our worth.
7. The review in different churches
In a parish with several services, the review can be a meeting of the people who lead the groups, the priest or a lay minister, and a few members of the age group, with a short written note sent out in the weeks before. In an assembly or free church, it may be a morning after a service with tea. In a house church of fifteen, it may be a single evening in which everyone, including the person who hosts, answers three questions. The size changes the means. The method is the same: ask, listen, choose two, change, tell.
Diagram 1. The yearly review
Diagram 2. The questions at a glance
| Question | What it looks for |
|---|---|
| Did people feel met? | Being known by name, listened to, welcome |
| Who is missing? | Kinds of people for whom the door may be shut |
| What shuts people out? | Words, times, places, costs |
| What did people ask for? | What we heard and what we did |
| What hurt? | A concern raised, or a harm found |
| Who carries the work? | Burnout, fairness |
| Are the lines kept? | Boundaries, the written policy, a way to raise a concern |
| What two things will we change? | A short, written, dated list |
In short
- Attendance can rise for the wrong reason, fall for the right one, and cannot see who is not there; it measures the evening, not whether people were met.
- An honest yearly review asks who felt met, who is missing, what words, times and costs shut people out, what hurt, who carries the work and whether the lines are kept.
- Ask the people rather than guessing, in a conversation, a short anonymous note or a kind approach to those who stopped coming; never ask one person to speak for a group.
- Receive a hard answer by thanking, not defending, looking for patterns, and choosing only two changes that are written down and done.
- Report themes, not names, and tell people what changed.
- A person who declines or moves on is not simply a failure; a group that makes fewer contacts, and makes them well, may be doing right.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why a head count misleads | It can rise for the wrong reason, fall for the right one, cannot see who is missing, and tempts a group to treat people as figures. |
| The main questions of a yearly review | Did people feel met? Who is missing? What shuts people out? What hurt? Who carries the work? Are the lines kept? |
| Three ways to ask | A conversation over a meal, a short note that can be anonymous, and a kind, one-time approach to those who stopped coming. |
| Receiving a hard answer | Thank first, do not defend, look for patterns, choose two changes, and tell people what changed. |
One sentence to remember A group measures its care by asking whether people were met, and the shepherd counts only to find the one who is missing.
This week's action Write three questions you would ask a member of your community about how it has been for them this year, and ask one person this month.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Kofi's number was true and still told him little. What does your community count, and what does it not know?
- Think of a time you stopped coming to a group. Did anyone ask why? What would you have wanted to be asked?
- Which of the three ways of asking would work best in your setting, and which would be hardest?
- When you hear a criticism of something you care about, what is your first reaction? What helps you pause?
- The shepherd counts to find the missing one. Who might be missing from your group, and how could you find out without chasing them?