Lecture 4-3: Honest, Not Impressive
Keep it true, keep it about God
Evangelism Through Friendship
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Keep it true, keep it about God
Evangelism Through Friendship
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Nobody sets out to tell a dishonest testimony. The distortions come in through good intentions. You want the story to land, so a detail gets sharpened or a timeline gets tightened. By the fourth telling the story is better than the thing that happened. This lecture names three ways it goes wrong, and then a fourth problem that runs the other way: the person who is sure they have nothing to tell.
The lecture notes that Paul's list begins with the word true, and everything after depends on it. A story that is lovely and untrue fails the first test on the list. It is the verse behind the call for honesty in a testimony.
Finally, brothers, whatever things are true, whatever things are honorable, whatever things are just, whatever things are pure, whatever things are lovely, whatever things are of good report..." Philippians 4:8 · World English Bible
This verse speaks of being in Christ as a new creation. It is the kind of claim a testimony reports, and the lecture quotes it alongside Paul's list of what is true. A testimony should say what actually changed, no more and no less.
Therefore if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation. The old things have passed away. Behold, all things have become new." 2 Corinthians 5:17 · WEB
The commonest fault is making the story more dramatic than it was. It rarely starts as a lie. It starts as rounding, when ordinary drifting becomes 'I had walked away from God completely.' The cost is your credibility, because a listener who notices one enlarged detail begins to re-examine everything else. There is a deeper cost too: inflating the story implies that what happened was not enough.
Comparison lifts you by lowering someone else, and its cost is the listener's safety. They learn what you do to people who are not in the room. Quiet self-praise hides inside the best material, such as a hardship survived that becomes a story about your endurance. A witness testifies about someone else, so a story that is really about you is no longer testimony. The checking question is whether people will think God is great, or that you are.
This objection stops more people than the three faults together. The dramatic conversion narrative, with a dark past and a crisis, is a real and honourable form, but it is largely the product of one stream of Christianity, the revivals of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. It is a genre, not a doctrine, and it is not how most Christians in most centuries have come to faith. The lecture says this is not a fault but a misunderstanding.
He is knocked to the ground on a road. His story has a clear moment.
Paul says he has known the holy Scriptures from infancy and traces his faith through his grandmother and mother. There is no conversion scene for him in the New Testament.
It holds both shapes without ranking them. Traditions differ on where conversion ends and Christian nurture begins, but on either account you have something to report.
Run four questions over your draft. On inflation, ask whether each strong sentence happened that way or is just the version you have told before. On comparison, search for the shape 'I was, but they are' and delete it. On self-praise, count the sentences where you are the subject of the verb and where God is. On shame about being ordinary, ask whether you dramatised a slow process because you thought it was not enough.
Pick one story you have told many times. Read it through the four questions, looking for any sentence that has grown over the years.
Which detail in the story has become bigger than what actually happened?
A testimony goes wrong through inflation, comparison and quiet self-praise, and each costs something: credibility, the listener's safety, and the point of the story. A fourth problem runs the other way, when someone with no crisis moment thinks they have nothing to tell. A faith that grew slowly is a full testimony, and the more common kind. A story that is lovely and untrue fails the first word on Paul's list.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.