Lecture 5-2: Online Worship and the Place of Gathering
Contents 41
- Lecture 1-1: Creation and Tools
- Lecture 1-2: What the Attention Economy Actually Is
- Lecture 1-3: Technology Is Not Neutral
- Lecture 1-4: My Digital Story
- Lecture 1-5: Digital Lab, Seeing Your Screen Time Honestly for the First Time
- Lecture 2-1: Habit Forms Spirituality, Not the Other Way Around
- Lecture 2-2: Notifications and Non-Resistance
- Lecture 2-3: Three Reasons You Keep Scrolling, Explained Plainly
- Lecture 2-4: When the Hand Moves First
- Lecture 2-5: Digital Lab, A Notification Audit
- Lecture 3-1: The Displayed Self and the Real Self
- Lecture 3-2: Comparison and Envy
- Lecture 3-3: Likes and the Addiction to Approval
- Lecture 3-4: What Am I Actually Boasting About
- Lecture 3-5: Digital Lab, Auditing My Own Feed
- Lecture 4-1: The Filter Bubble, Why Your Feed Always Seems to Agree With You
- Lecture 4-2: Telling Real News From Fake, A Practical Checklist
- Lecture 4-3: Christian Anger and Christian Speech Online
- Lecture 4-4: What to Ask Before You Share
- Lecture 4-5: Digital Lab, What I Shared This Week
- Lecture 5-1: What Online Friendship Can and Cannot Do
- Lecture 5-2: Online Worship and the Place of Gathering
- Lecture 5-3: Anonymity and Accountability
- Lecture 5-4: Who Gets Left Out Online
- Lecture 5-5: Digital Lab, Mapping My Online Relationships
- Lecture 6-1: Facing the Comments
- Lecture 6-2: Conflict, Callouts, and Cancel Culture
- Lecture 6-3: Witness That Does Not Coerce
- Lecture 6-4: When to Be Silent and When to Speak
- Lecture 6-5: Digital Lab, My Online Language This Week
- Lecture 7-1: The Digital-Native Generation
- Lecture 7-2: The Theological Case for Screen-Time Rules
- Lecture 7-3: Online Risk and When to Step In
- Lecture 7-4: Accompaniment, Not Surveillance
- Lecture 7-5: Digital Lab — Our Family's Digital Covenant
In the space of a few weeks in 2020, hundreds of millions of Christians who had never once considered the question found themselves asking it anyway: is a livestreamed service church, or is it something else wearing church's clothes? Congregations that had debated projector screens and drum kits for a decade were suddenly deciding, overnight, whether communion could be received in front of a laptop.
The pandemic did not invent this question. It sharpened a question that was already sitting quietly in Hebrews 10:25, waiting for a circumstance dramatic enough to force an answer. That circumstance has passed for most readers of this course, but the question it raised has not gone anywhere. A homebound believer, a persecuted house-church member who cannot risk a public building, a shift worker whose hours never once line up with a Sunday service — for each of them, the pandemic's emergency question is an ordinary weekly one.
This lecture will not settle it. It will state it as fairly as it can be stated, because both sides are held by serious, careful, praying Christians, and a course that pretends otherwise is not teaching — it is choosing a side and calling the choosing neutral.
What these 18 minutes give you
- State what Hebrews 10:25 actually says and does not say about the form gathering must take.
- Present, in a form its own holders would recognize as fair, the case that physical presence is essential to fulfilling Hebrews 10:25.
- Present, equally fairly, the case that a livestream can be a genuine form of gathering for those who have no other option.
- Explain how Matthew 18:20 and Acts 2:42 are used by both sides of this disagreement, and why that is possible.
- Describe what this course asks of you regarding this dispute, and what it does not ask.
Not forsaking our own assembling together, as the custom of some is, but exhorting one another; and so much the more, as you see the Day approaching." — Hebrews 10:25
World English Bible
For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there I am in their midst." — Matthew 18:20
WEB
They continued steadfastly in the apostles' teaching and fellowship, in the breaking of bread, and prayer." — Acts 2:42
WEB
Read together, these three verses give you the whole shape of the disagreement in miniature. Hebrews 10:25 commands a gathering and describes some people who were already skipping it. Matthew 18:20 promises Christ's presence at a gathering of "two or three" without specifying anything about the room they are in. Acts 2:42 describes what the earliest gathered church actually did together: teaching, fellowship, breaking of bread, prayer. Everything that follows in this lecture is an argument about what those four activities require.
1. What Hebrews 10:25 actually says
Read the verse slowly. It commands believers not to abandon "our own assembling together." It names a real problem in its first readers: some had made a habit of skipping it. And it gives urgency, not detail: do this "so much the more" as a day of judgment approaches.
What the verse does not do is define "assembling" with any precision. It does not say the assembling must happen inside a building, at a set time, with bodies occupying the same physical space, as opposed to some other form of togetherness the first century did not yet have the technology to imagine. The writer of Hebrews was addressing believers with exactly one option for gathering — the physical kind — and so had no occasion to rule any other kind either in or out. Everything that follows in this lecture is downstream of that one honest observation: the text answers a question its first readers were actually facing, and it is being asked, today, a question it never had to consider.
That observation alone does not settle anything. It simply means both sides in what follows have some real work to do, and neither side can simply quote the verse and stop.
2. This is a point where readers will not agree.
The case for physical presence as essential.
Many pastors and theologians, across a wide range of traditions — a great number of Baptist, Reformed, Pentecostal, Catholic, and Orthodox voices among them — hold that "assembling together" in Hebrews 10:25 means bodies gathered in one place, and that a livestream, however good the video quality, does not fulfill the command. Their argument runs, at its strongest, something like this:
The New Testament church did not merely receive information together; it touched, ate, and was touched. The kiss of peace (Romans 16:16), the laying on of hands (1 Timothy 4:14), the shared cup and bread eaten from a common table (1 Corinthians 11:23-26) — these are physical acts, not merely symbolic ones, and a received alone in front of a screen is, on this view, either not received at all or received in a diminished and unintended form. The church is described as a body (1 Corinthians 12:12), and a body's members do not merely coordinate remotely; they are joined. On this view, a livestream can inform, comfort, and even move a viewer — but it is closer to reading a very good letter from the church than to being in the church, and it "assembling" stretches the word past what it was ever meant to hold. Some who hold this position add a pastoral warning: online worship, if treated as equivalent to in-person worship rather than as an emergency accommodation, quietly trains a congregation to think gathering is optional whenever convenience says so — the very drift Hebrews 10:25 was written to stop.
The case for a livestream as a genuine, if not ideal, form of gathering.
Other pastors and theologians, including many evangelicals who take Hebrews 10:25 with equal seriousness, hold that the command is about the reality of gathered, mutual encouragement — not about a specific physical technology for producing it — and that a livestream, for someone who has no other option, can be a real if imperfect fulfillment of that reality. Their argument, at its strongest, runs like this:
Matthew 18:20 promises Christ's presence to "two or three gathered in my name" without specifying a shared room; the promise is not made contingent on physical proximity anywhere in the text. A believer who is homebound with a long-term illness, a persecuted believer in a country where a public gathering would mean prison or worse, an elderly member with no transportation and no family nearby — none of these people chose to be absent from assembling. Hebrews 10:25's warning is aimed at people who could gather and simply would not be bothered; it is a very different thing to apply the same warning to someone locked out of gathering by illness, danger, or distance through no fault of their own, and for whom a livestream is not a lesser preference but the only door left open. On this view, watching a livestream with real attention, singing along, praying with the congregation in real time, and receiving the sermon as spoken to oneself is genuinely "exhorting one another" in the terms Hebrews 10:25 actually names — even if it is not the fullest or most preferable form that exhortation can take. Advocates of this position often add: the same pandemic that forced this question also showed churches, often for the first time, how many members had quietly been excluded from full participation for years before anyone thought to ask why.
Where the disagreement actually sits.
Where the sides meet
Notice that both positions can quote Matthew 18:20 and Acts 2:42 in their support. The first side reads "two or three gathered" as still requiring physical gathering, since that is what "gathered" meant to everyone who ever used the word before livestreaming existed; the promise applies to a physical assembly, however small. The second side reads the same phrase as defining gathering by relationship and shared purpose rather than by shared geography, since the verse itself supplies no geographic requirement. Acts 2:42's four activities — teaching, fellowship, the breaking of bread, prayer — are read by the first side as inherently physical acts that a screen interrupts; they are read by the second side as spiritual realities that a screen can carry, imperfectly but really, when nothing better is available.
Both readings are careful, both are argued from the same texts, and both are held by people who are trying, seriously, to obey Hebrews 10:25 rather than evade it. That is what it means for this to be a genuinely disputed question rather than a case of one side simply not having read the Bible.
3. What this course asks of you, and what it does not
This course does not ask you to resolve this disagreement, and it does not tell you which side your own church should take. What it asks is narrower and, in a way, harder: that you be able to state the other side's position in a form its own holders would recognize as fair, before you decide which one you hold.
If your instinct on reading this lecture was to think "obviously the first position is right" or "obviously the second position is right," go back and reread whichever paragraph you skimmed. A student who can only restate their own side has not yet understood the disagreement; they have only rehearsed their answer to it.
There is, however, one thing this course will say plainly, and it is not a resolution of the dispute: whichever position your church holds, it should hold it as a position about what fulfills the command, and not use it to excuse either extreme — a congregation that livestreams everything and never expects anyone who is physically able to show up in person, or a congregation that refuses to livestream at all and thereby cuts off members who have no other way to receive teaching, prayer, and the encouragement of belonging to a body that has not forgotten them. Both errors are available on both sides of this dispute, and neither error is what either side, at its best, is actually arguing for.
4. A question this lecture leaves open on purpose
One further question sits underneath all of this and this lecture will not answer it either: can the Lord's Supper itself be received in a form that does not involve a physically shared table? Traditions differ sharply here, sometimes more sharply than they differ on the general question of livestreamed worship, and some traditions that are open to livestreamed preaching are firmly closed to a livestreamed communion. If your own church has a settled teaching on this, learn it and follow it. If it does not, this is a conversation to have with your pastor rather than a conclusion to draw alone from one lecture in a course.
Diagram 1. The same three verses, read two ways
In short
- Hebrews 10:25 commands not forsaking "our own assembling together" but does not define what physical form assembling must take — its first readers had exactly one option and so the question was never put to them.
- This is a point where readers will not agree. One position: physical presence is essential, because gathering has always meant bodies in one place and the sacraments are physical acts a screen cannot carry. The other: a livestream can genuinely fulfill "gathering" for those who have no other option, since Matthew 18:20 attaches no geography to Christ's promised presence.
- Both positions read Matthew 18:20 and Acts 2:42 in their own favor, and both are held by serious, careful believers — this is not a case of one side ignoring Scripture.
- The course does not ask you to resolve the dispute. It asks you to be able to state the other position fairly before stating your own.
- Two pastoral errors are available on both sides: treating livestream as fully sufficient for the physically able, and refusing it in a way that excludes those with no other door.
- Whether the Lord's Supper specifically can be received via livestream is a further, often more sharply contested question this lecture leaves to your own church's teaching.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Hebrews 10:25 | Commands not forsaking assembling; does not define the physical form assembling must take. |
| Position one | Physical presence is essential — the body touches, eats, is touched; a screen informs but does not gather. |
| Position two | A livestream can genuinely gather those with no other option — Matthew 18:20 attaches no geography to Christ's presence. |
| What the course asks | State the other side fairly before holding your own. Not a resolution — a discipline. |
One sentence to remember The internet can carry real worship further than distance used to allow, and it cannot replace what only bodies in one room can do.
This week's action Ask someone in your church who holds the opposite position from yours to explain it in their own words, and listen without correcting them until they finish.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Before this lecture, which position did you already hold, and can you now state the other one fairly in two or three sentences?
- Does your own church livestream its services? If so, for whom does it exist — the homebound, those traveling, anyone who prefers it? Has your church ever discussed the difference?
- Hebrews 10:25 warns believers who "make a habit" of skipping gathering. Is there a difference between someone who could attend and does not, and someone who genuinely cannot? Does that difference change how you would counsel each one?
- If your church holds a settled teaching on whether the Lord's Supper can be received via livestream, what is it, and what reasoning stands behind it?
- What would it look like for a church to make the two pastoral errors named in section 3 — treating livestream as fully sufficient for everyone, or refusing it and thereby excluding those with no other option? Have you seen either one?