FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

LM402E · Chapter 4

Lecture 4-1: The Art of Asking Questions

The more important question is not what will I say, but what will I ask.

How to Teach

12 cards 15 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Distinguish a closed factual question from an open question, and explain what each is actually testing for.
  • Describe what Mark 8:29's "who do you say that I am" was doing that "who do people say that I am" (verse 27) was not.
  • Explain how Luke 10:36 redirects a lawyer's question back onto himself, and why that redirection matters more than a direct answer would have.
  • Write one open question for a passage you might actually teach, and explain what work it requires the hearer to do.
The problem

Say or ask?

A new teacher usually spends most preparation time on one question: what am I going to say? This lecture argues that the more important question is what am I going to ask. A teacher's explanation hands a learner a finished thought. A well-built question hands a learner a piece of work to do, and the truth that arrives belongs to the learner.

Key idea A good question gives the learner work to do.
At a glance

Closed and open questions

Closed question

It has one correct answer that can be retrieved from memory. It checks whether information was received.

Open question

It requires the hearer to reason, weigh, apply or commit. Different honest hearers may give different first answers.

Mark 8

From reporting to committing

In Mark 8:27 the question is safe, because it asks the disciples to report other people's opinions. The question in verse 29 is a different kind. The word "but" marks a pivot from reporting to committing, from secondhand information to a personal claim. Jesus does not lecture first and then ask for the correct title.

Key idea The question made Peter say what he had come to believe.
Scripture

Why Mark 8:29?

The lecture says this question moves the disciples from reporting what people say to owning a personal claim. Peter's answer is not information he looked up, but a conclusion he had to reach out loud.

He said to them, "But who do you say that I am?" Peter answered, "You are the Christ."" Mark 8:29 · World English Bible
Luke 10

The redirect

The lawyer asked "who is my neighbor?" in order to draw a boundary around his obligation. Jesus told a story and then asked which of the three seemed to be a neighbor. That question forces the lawyer to identify with the one who acted, not to categorize the one acted upon. He cannot answer it without indicting his own evasion.

Key idea The redirection is the whole point.
Scripture

Why Luke 10:36?

The lecture says Jesus does not ask who the injured man's neighbor was. He asks which of the three seemed to be a neighbor, and so the lawyer's own answer commits him to a conclusion his question was designed to avoid.

Now which of these three do you think seemed to be a neighbor to him who fell among the robbers?"" Luke 10:36 · WEB
Craft

Three habits of a working question

First, ask about the hearer, not only about the text. Second, do not embed the answer in the question: "Don't you think the Samaritan was being kind?" is a closed question wearing an open question's grammar. Third, be willing to ask a question you do not already have the exact answer to. A good question is also not a trick built to embarrass a learner.

Key idea Pointed, but generous.
Think about it

Write one

Choose a passage you might actually teach.

What is one open question for it, and what work does it ask the hearer to do?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

A closed question retrieves a fact, and an open question asks the hearer to reason, weigh, apply or commit. Mark 8:29 moves the disciples from reporting to owning a claim, and Luke 10:36 turns the lawyer's boundary question back on him. The best teaching tool is not a better answer. It is a better question.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12