Lecture 7-3: When the Leader Is the Problem
Contents 41
- Lecture 1-1: Why a Team, Not Just You Alone
- Lecture 1-2: Biblical Teams
- Lecture 1-3: The Difference Between a Group and a Team
- Lecture 1-4: Where Is Our Team Right Now?
- Lecture 1-5: In My Own Seat, Mapping Our Team's Current State
- Lecture 2-1: The Weight of the Ask
- Lecture 2-2: An Eye for Gifting
- Lecture 2-3: Come and See
- Lecture 2-4: The Sad Walk Away
- Lecture 2-5: In My Own Seat, Needs List and Candidate List
- Lecture 3-1: Putting a Role in Writing
- Lecture 3-2: Who Decides What
- Lecture 3-3: The Structure of a Small Team
- Lecture 3-4: Preventing Double-Duty and Overload
- Lecture 3-5: In My Own Seat, Writing a Role Description
- Lecture 4-1: The First Ninety Days Decide Everything
- Lecture 4-2: What to Teach, and What to Let Them Experience
- Lecture 4-3: Pairing People Up — Mentoring and Accompaniment
- Lecture 4-4: The Risk of Responsibility Without Training
- Lecture 4-5: In My Own Seat, Building the First Ninety Days
- Lecture 5-1: Culture Is Not a Vibe, It Is a Set of Repeated Practices
- Lecture 5-2: A Meeting That Builds a Team, Not Just an Agenda
- Lecture 5-3: Naming Gratitude Specifically and Often
- Lecture 5-4: Deciding On Purpose How News Actually Travels
- Lecture 5-5: In My Own Seat, Redesigning Our Team's Meetings
- Lecture 6-1: A Different Kind of Conflict
- Lecture 6-2: When Contributions Differ
- Lecture 6-3: Naming What Isn't Working
- Lecture 6-4: When Someone Needs to Leave the Team
- Lecture 6-5: In My Own Seat, Preparing a Hard Conversation
- Lecture 7-1: When Burnout Spreads Through the Whole Team
- Lecture 7-2: Factions and Taking Sides
- Lecture 7-3: When the Leader Is the Problem
- Lecture 7-4: How to Recover After a Team Breaks
- Lecture 7-5: Boundary Rules and Crisis Response Procedure
Every lecture so far in this chapter has assumed the leader is trying, imperfectly, to serve the team well — exhausted, perhaps, or slow to notice a forming faction, but not the source of the actual harm. This lecture names a harder case directly: sometimes the leader is not merely struggling. Sometimes the leader has become the actual problem. Scripture does not leave this case theoretical or hypothetical. It names an actual person, by name, doing actual damage to an actual church — and this lecture will not soften that case into something more comfortable to read.
What these 13 minutes give you
- State plainly what 3 John 1:9-10 says Diotrephes actually did, without softening or generalizing the specific accusations.
- Explain why Diotrephes is significant as the New Testament's own clearest named case of a leader who had become the problem, rather than merely a difficult or flawed one.
- Apply Galatians 6:1's warning — "look to yourself, so that you also aren't tempted" — to your own confidence that you could never become a version of Diotrephes.
- Identify the difference between an imperfect leader and a leader whose pattern of conduct has crossed into the kind this lecture names.
I wrote to the assembly, but Diotrephes, who loves to be first among them, doesn't accept what we say. Therefore if I come, I will call attention to his deeds which he does, unjustly accusing us with wicked words. Not content with this, neither does he himself receive the brothers, and those who would, he forbids and throws out of the assembly." — 3 John 1:9-10
World English Bible
Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren't tempted." — Galatians 6:1
WEB
3 John is a short, personal letter, and this passage is one of the plainest character sketches in the New Testament. John does not soften what he names: Diotrephes "loves to be first," rejects the apostle's own authority ("doesn't accept what we say"), spreads false accusations ("unjustly accusing us with wicked words"), refuses hospitality to fellow believers, and actively expels from the church anyone who disagrees with him. This is not a portrait of an imperfect leader having a difficult season. It is a portrait of someone using real authority to serve his own position rather than the people under his care. Galatians 6:1 is placed alongside this passage deliberately: its warning to "look to yourself" is addressed to every reader of this lecture, including — especially — the reader confident that nothing in this passage could ever describe them.
1. What Diotrephes actually did — named without softening
It would be easy to read 3 John 1:9-10 quickly and file Diotrephes away as a vaguely "difficult" figure. The text is more specific than that, and the specifics matter:
He loved to be first. Not merely occupied a position of authority — actively "loves to be first among them," a description of motive, not merely of role. The problem John names is not that Diotrephes held influence in the church. It is what that influence was for, in Diotrephes' own apparent estimation: his own preeminence.
He rejected legitimate outside authority. "Doesn't accept what we say" — refusing to recognize the apostle John's own standing, the highest living spiritual authority available to that church at that time. A leader who has become the problem often begins here: rejecting any accountability that could actually check him, while still claiming legitimate authority over everyone beneath him.
He spread false accusations. "Unjustly accusing us with wicked words" — not disagreement, but deliberate misrepresentation aimed at discrediting the very authority he had already rejected, presumably to protect his own position from challenge.
He controlled who could belong. "Neither does he himself receive the brothers, and those who would, he forbids and throws out of the assembly." This is the most concrete and the most damaging item: Diotrephes did not merely disagree with visiting believers. He actively barred them from fellowship, and expelled members of his own church for the offense of welcoming them. Belonging to the church, under Diotrephes, had become conditional on loyalty to Diotrephes specifically.
Taken together, this is not a sketch of someone difficult to work with. It is a sketch of someone who had turned a position meant to serve the church into a position that served himself, using real institutional power — the power to admit and expel — to enforce it.
2. Why this case is named, not left general
Scripture could have addressed the danger of controlling leadership only in general moral terms — "beware of pride," "do not seek your own glory." Instead, in 3 John, it names an actual person, doing actual identifiable things, in an actual church. This matters for the same reason Paul's naming the Corinthian factions specifically mattered in the previous lecture: a general warning about pride lets every reader assume it describes someone worse than them. A specific, concrete case — rejecting outside accountability, spreading false accusations, controlling who belongs — gives a reader something they can actually check their own conduct against, rather than a comfortable abstraction they can always conclude does not apply.
3. Galatians 6:1 — written for the reader who is sure this isn't about them
It would be natural to read the Diotrephes passage and mentally place yourself firmly outside its description — you have never expelled anyone from a church, never accused a fellow leader of "wicked words," never obviously "loved to be first" in Diotrephes' dramatic sense. Galatians 6:1 exists specifically to interrupt that comfortable distance. Paul's instruction about restoring someone caught in a fault comes with an immediate caution to the one doing the restoring: "looking to yourself, so that you also aren't tempted." The very confidence that you could never become what you are reading about is, Paul suggests, itself one of the conditions under which a person drifts toward exactly that.
This does not mean every leader is secretly a Diotrephes waiting to emerge. It means the honest question this lecture asks is not "am I as bad as Diotrephes" — almost no reader will honestly answer yes to that — but "is there any small, early, more forgivable version of any one of his four patterns already present in how I lead." Rejecting a correction because the person offering it "doesn't really understand the situation." Describing a critic's motives uncharitably rather than engaging their actual concern. Making it subtly harder for someone to remain welcome on the team once they have disagreed with you. None of these, in small form, makes a leader a Diotrephes. All four, in their small forms, are the same family of pattern his story names at full scale.
4. The difference between an imperfect leader and a leader who is the problem
This lecture is not describing every leader who makes mistakes, has a bad week, or handles one conflict poorly. Every leader in this course will do all three. The distinction this lecture actually names is pattern and direction: does correction, when it comes, get received and acted on, or reflexively rejected? Does authority over who belongs get used to protect the mission, or to protect the leader's own position? Is disagreement engaged honestly, or discredited? An imperfect leader who receives correction, however reluctantly, is still functioning inside healthy accountability. A leader whose settled pattern is to reject outside authority, discredit critics, and control belonging around personal loyalty has crossed into what this lecture — and 3 John — is actually naming.
Diagram 1. What 3 John 1:9-10 names, without softening
In short
- 3 John 1:9-10 names Diotrephes specifically: he loved to be first, rejected the apostle's outside authority, spread false accusations, and controlled who could belong to the church, expelling those who disagreed.
- Naming an actual person and actual deeds, rather than a general warning against pride, gives a reader something concrete to check their own conduct against.
- Galatians 6:1's "look to yourself, so that you also aren't tempted" is addressed to every reader, including — especially — the reader confident this passage could never describe them.
- The distinction between an imperfect leader and a leader who has become the problem is pattern and direction: whether correction is received or reflexively rejected, whether belonging is tied to the mission or to personal loyalty.
- This lecture does not claim every leader is secretly a Diotrephes; it asks whether any small, early version of his four patterns is already present in a real leader's real conduct.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The four named patterns | Loved to be first -- rejected outside authority -- spread false accusations -- controlled who could belong (3 John 1:9-10). |
| Why named specifically | A concrete case gives something to check your own conduct against; a general warning lets everyone assume it means someone else. |
| Galatians 6:1 | "Looking to yourself" -- written for the reader confident this could never describe them. |
| The real distinction | Not one bad week, but a settled pattern: is correction received or rejected? Is belonging tied to the mission or to personal loyalty? |
★ One sentence to remember Diotrephes is named specifically so no reader can file this lecture away as being about someone else.
✓ This week's action Ask honestly: is there any small, early version of one of Diotrephes' four patterns currently present in your own leadership -- and if so, who is the outside authority you would actually take that recognition to?
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Of the four patterns named in Diotrephes (loving to be first, rejecting outside authority, spreading false accusations, controlling belonging), which do you think is hardest for a leader to notice happening in their own conduct, and why?
- Galatians 6:1 warns that confidence you would never become what a passage describes is itself a risk. Did reading this lecture produce any honest, even small, recognition in your own leadership?
- This lecture distinguishes an imperfect leader from a leader who has become the problem by pattern and direction, not by a single mistake. How would you know, honestly, which one describes your own current leadership?
- Diotrephes rejected the apostle John's own authority. Who is the equivalent outside authority in your own ministry structure, and how would you actually respond if they raised a hard correction with you?
- Why do you think Scripture names an actual person and actual specific deeds here, rather than warning against controlling leadership only in general terms?