FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT1E · Chapter 13

Lecture 13-5: Seeking Evaluation and Feedback

A growing preacher welcomes honest evaluation, from self and from trusted others, and receives it with humility.

Homiletics: From Text to Pulpit

11 cards 9 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain the theological basis for sermon evaluation: humility and growth.
  • Use practical tools for self-evaluation and for receiving feedback from others.
  • Practice receiving criticism without defensiveness, treating it instead as material for growth.
Scripture

Why Proverbs 27:17?

The lecture uses this verse to picture growth happening through contact, not in isolation. One piece of iron sharpens another only by friction against it.

Iron sharpens iron; so a man sharpens his friend's countenance." Proverbs 27:17 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why Proverbs 13:18?

The lecture pairs this verse with the first as part of the scripture for evaluation. It speaks of refusing discipline and of heeding correction.

Poverty and shame come to him who refuses discipline, but he who heeds correction shall be honored." Proverbs 13:18 · WEB
Self-evaluation

A post-sermon checklist

Check yourself right after preaching on six areas. Was the sermon theologically accurate to what the text says? Was its structure healthy, with unity, order and movement? Did it stay Christ-centered rather than drifting into moralism? Was the application concrete, did delivery serve the content, and did it finish within its planned length?

Key idea Six questions after every sermon.
Feedback from others

Three practical ways

Ask a small number of trusted people for regular feedback, such as a fellow minister, an elder or a well-formed church member. Ask specific questions, because "How was it?" produces a vague answer. For example, ask "What did you understand the sermon's central message to be?" Consider a regular sermon-review gathering of fellow ministers.

Key idea Few trusted people, specific questions, regular rhythm.
Receiving criticism

Two reactions to avoid

Defensive rebuttal

Explaining away every criticism. It can show an identity fused to performance, where criticism of the sermon feels like a threat to one's worth.

Excessive self-deprecation

Absorbing every criticism until it becomes "I have no gift for preaching at all." This too signals an identity tied to performance.

Healthy response

About the work, not your identity

The healthy response treats feedback as being about this particular sermon rather than about your identity. Grounded in the identity already established in Christ, you listen without needing to defend yourself, accept what is valid, and apply it to the next sermon. Keeping a brief record after each sermon lets patterns of strength and weakness emerge over time.

Key idea Accept what is valid and apply it next time.
Think about it

One specific question

Readers disagree about lay evaluation, but the lecture says feedback received in humility strengthens fidelity to the text.

Which trusted person could you ask, after your next sermon, what they understood the main message to be?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Preachers grow through honest evaluation, both of themselves and from trusted others, received with humility. Check yourself on six areas after each sermon and ask a few people specific questions. Treat criticism as being about this sermon, not about your worth.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11