FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT2E · Chapter 10

Lecture 10-2: Four Historic Views of Christ's Presence in the Supper

This lecture states four historic views of Christ's presence in the Supper, each in a form its own holders would accept.

Worship: Theology, History and Practice

13 cards 22 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State transubstantiation, sacramental union, spiritual real presence, and memorialism each in a form its own defenders would recognize as fair.
  • Give the central biblical and theological ground each view offers for its position.
  • Explain the shared concern underneath this disagreement — the reality of Christ's presence — that all four views are trying to protect.
The question

Sharing in what sense?

Paul calls the Supper a sharing, a koinonia, of the body of Christ. That leaves the most consequential question of the chapter open: sharing in what sense? Four congregations in four cities can sing the same hymn and quote the same words of institution, yet understand Christ's presence in four different ways. This lecture states each historic position in a form its convinced defenders would recognize as fair.

Key idea Same words, four understandings.
Scripture

Why Matthew 26:26?

The lecture uses this verse because everything in the lecture traces back to the words "This is my body."

Take, eat; this is my body." Matthew 26:26 · World English Bible
Two things

Two things held together

Every position is an attempt to hold together two things. One is Christ's promise that this meal gives access to him. The other is the plain biblical testimony that his body ascended into heaven and is not presently walking the earth. No view denies either half. They differ in how they relate the two.

Key idea Promise of presence, and an ascended body.
Two views

Changed substance, or present with the bread

Transubstantiation

Roman Catholic, and with variation Eastern Orthodox. After consecration the substance of the bread and wine changes into Christ's body and blood, while the appearance, taste and texture remain.

Sacramental union

Lutheran. Christ's body and blood are truly present "in, with, and under" the bread and wine, which remain bread and wine.

Two views

Spiritual presence, or memorial

Spiritual real presence

Reformed, following Calvin. Christ's body remains in heaven, and through the Holy Spirit believers are truly joined to the whole Christ and feed on him by faith.

Memorialism

Zwinglian, and most Baptist and independent evangelical churches. "Is" means "signifies," and the Supper proclaims Christ's finished sacrifice.

Scripture

Why John 6:63?

The lecture uses this verse because memorialist theologians read it as Jesus ruling out a physical or metaphysical eating of his literal flesh.

It is the spirit who gives life. The flesh profits nothing. The words that I speak to you are spirit, and are life." John 6:63 · WEB
Not empty

Memorial does not mean merely symbolic

It would be a serious misreading to hear "memorial" as "empty." Zwingli himself, and the tradition that followed him, treated the Supper as a genuine means of grace, Spirit-attended and covenantally serious. It is a public, binding act of faith rather than a private feeling. No serious defender of any of the four views believes the Supper is a minor or empty ceremony.

Key idea All four take the Supper seriously.
What each protects

What all four are protecting

Transubstantiation and sacramental union refuse to let "this is my body" be softened into a mere figure of speech. Spiritual real presence protects the reality of Christ's genuine humanity. Memorialism protects the finished, completed nature of Christ's one sacrifice on the cross. Each takes seriously both his promise to be present and the New Testament's testimony about where his body now is.

Key idea Words, humanity, sufficiency of the cross.
Think about it

Stating another view fairly

The lecture asks for fairness more than agreement.

Which of the four views is closest to the tradition you belong to? Can you now state the position of a different tradition in a way its own members would recognize as fair?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Each of the four views protects something serious: the force of Christ's words, his true humanity, or the sufficiency of his sacrifice. This is a point where readers will not agree. No view treats the Supper as empty, and "memorial" does not mean "merely symbolic."

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13