Lecture 12-4: Visual Art and Worship — The Lessons of the Icon Controversy, and Chapter 12 in Review
Contents 67
- Lecture 1-1: What Worship Is — Definition and Essence
- Lecture 1-2: The Grammar of Worship — Revelation and Response
- Lecture 1-3: The Object of Worship — Worship Offered to the Triune God
- Lecture 1-4: Who May Worship — In Christ Alone
- Lecture 1-5: Worship and Life — The Living Sacrifice of Romans 12:1
- Lecture 1-6: The Purpose of Worship — God's Glory and the Church's Edification
- Lecture 2-1: Worship in Eden — the First Sanctuary
- Lecture 2-2: Worship of the Patriarchs — Altars and Calling on the Name
- Lecture 2-3: The Tabernacle — a Dwelling Place for God's Presence
- Lecture 2-4: Temple and Festival — Worship in Jerusalem
- Lecture 2-5: The Rise and Shape of Synagogue Worship
- Lecture 2-6: Worship in the New Testament — in Spirit and Truth
- Lecture 3-1: The Apostolic Pattern — How the First Christians Worshiped
- Lecture 3-2: Worship Takes Shape — The Ancient Church and the Rise of Liturgy
- Lecture 3-3: The Reformation and the Renewal of Worship
- Lecture 3-4: Puritan and Reformed Worship
- Lecture 3-5: The Modern Worship Movements — Renewal and the Song of the Nations
- Lecture 3-6: Worship Today — The Worship Wars and What Comes After
- Lecture 4-1: Where the Argument Comes From
- Lecture 4-2: The Regulative Principle
- Lecture 4-3: The Normative Principle
- Lecture 4-4: Pastoral Wisdom Between the Two Principles
- Lecture 4-5: Culture and Worship — Contextualization and Its Limits
- Lecture 5-1: To the Father — Worship's Source and Goal
- Lecture 5-2: Through the Son — Worship's Only Mediator
- Lecture 5-3: In the Spirit — Worship's Power and Participation
- Lecture 5-4: Putting the Trinitarian Structure to Work in the Order of Service
- Lecture 5-5: The Conversation Worship Is — Call and Response, Chapter Synthesis
- Lecture 6-1: The Call to Worship and the Salutation
- Lecture 6-2: Confession of Sin and the Assurance of Pardon
- Lecture 6-3: Praise and Thanksgiving
- Lecture 6-4: The Reading and Proclamation of the Word
- Lecture 6-5: The Offering
- Lecture 6-6: The Benediction, the Sending, and a Complete Order of Service
- Lecture 7-1: Why Music Belongs in Worship — The Biblical Case
- Lecture 7-2: The Tradition of Psalm Singing — From Metrical Psalters to Today
- Lecture 7-3: Hymns and Contemporary Worship Music: A Theological Evaluation
- Lecture 7-4: Principles for Choosing Worship Music
- Lecture 7-5: The Theology and Character of the Worship Leader — Chapter 7 Synthesis
- Lecture 8-1: Public Prayer — Speaking on the Congregation's Behalf
- Lecture 8-2: The Pastoral Prayer — Shape and Scope
- Lecture 8-3: The Lord's Prayer and Worship
- Lecture 8-4: Where Preaching Sits Inside Worship
- Lecture 8-5: Worship's Response — Commitment and Consecration, Chapter 8 in Review
- Lecture 9-1: What a Sacrament Is — Sign and Seal
- Lecture 9-2: The Theological Meaning of Baptism — Union and Washing
- Lecture 9-3: Infant Baptism and Believer's Baptism — Stating the Disagreement Fairly
- Lecture 9-4: The Practice of Baptism — Chapter 9 Synthesis
- Lecture 10-1: The Words of Institution — Text and Meaning
- Lecture 10-2: Four Historic Views of Christ's Presence in the Supper
- Lecture 10-3: Pastoral Practice — Frequency and Admission
- Lecture 10-4: The Rite Itself — Chapter 10 in Review
- Lecture 11-1: The Church Calendar — Redeeming Time
- Lecture 11-2: Advent and Christmas
- Lecture 11-3: Lent and Holy Week
- Lecture 11-4: Easter and Pentecost
- Lecture 11-5: Planning a Festal Year — Chapter Synthesis
- Lecture 12-1: The Theology of Worship Space — Architecture and Arrangement
- Lecture 12-2: The Use of Symbol and Color
- Lecture 12-3: The Body's Posture — Standing, Sitting, Kneeling, Raised Hands
- Lecture 12-4: Visual Art and Worship — The Lessons of the Icon Controversy, and Chapter 12 in Review
- Lecture 13-1: The Calling and Preparation of a Worship Leader
- Lecture 13-2: Planning Worship — The Practice of Building an Order of Service
- Lecture 13-3: Today's Challenge — Technology, Media, and Online Worship
- Lecture 13-4: Worship across Generations and Cultures
- Lecture 13-5: Sustainability in Worship Ministry and Lifelong Growth — A Synthesis of This Course
Closing Chapter 12, this lecture draws lessons for the relationship between visual art and worship from one of the fiercest theological controversies in church history — the fight over icons. Few disputes in Christian history generated more depositions, exiled bishops, and destroyed art than this one, and few disputes are more useful for testing what this whole chapter has been arguing.
What these 13 minutes give you
- Explain the precise meaning of the second commandment (Exodus 20:4-5).
- Outline the central issues of the eighth- and ninth-century icon controversy.
- Present theological guidelines for the use of visual art in worship, and bring Chapter 12 to its conclusion.
You shall not make for yourselves an idol, nor any image of anything that is in the heavens above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth: you shall not bow yourself down to them, nor serve them, for I, Yahweh your God, am a jealous God." — Exodus 20:4-5
World English Bible
1. What the second commandment actually says
Common misreading
The second commandment is often misread as a blanket prohibition of all visual art. A careful reading of the text shows something more precise: what is forbidden is not the making of an image as such, but bowing down to it and serving it — that is, making an image the object of worship. This connects directly to the principle from Lecture 1-3 concerning worship's proper object: only the triune God may be worshipped, and no image may ever take that place.
Strikingly, within the very same instructions for building the tabernacle (Lecture 2-3), God commanded the making of cherubim — winged figures — in gold (Exodus 25:18-20). This confirms that the second commandment does not forbid image-making as such; it forbids worshipping an image.
2. The icon controversy (eighth and ninth centuries)
The Byzantine (Eastern Roman) church's Iconoclastic Controversy of the eighth and ninth centuries is church history's most intense engagement with this exact question.
The iconoclasts ("image-breakers") argued that the practice of bowing before icons — painted images of Christ and the saints — violated the second commandment as outright idolatry, and pressed for the destruction of icons across the empire.
The iconodules ("venerators of images"), a position led theologically by figures such as John of Damascus, argued that icons were not themselves worshipped; rather, honor paid to an icon passes through it to the person it represents — Christ or a saint. The iconodules went further, offering a theologically decisive argument of their own: the itself (Lecture 11-2) is the event in which the invisible God took on a visible form — Christ's own humanity — so that depicting Christ in an image affirms the reality of the incarnation rather than denying God's invisibility.
The controversy was formally settled — for the Byzantine church — at the Second in 787, which sided with the iconodules, through a distinction between "worship" (latria), due to God alone, and "veneration" (dulia), which could be given to an icon. That very distinction, however, was reopened with new intensity during the Reformation (Lecture 3-3).
3. The Reformation's answer — Calvin and images
As Lecture 3-3 discussed, Calvin actively removed images and icons from places of worship. This was rooted in a pastoral judgment: the iconodules' distinction between worship and veneration, Calvin believed, was extremely difficult for ordinary believers to maintain in actual practice, and would tend, in the end, to slide into a real, functional worship of the image itself — exactly the worship of a created thing Lecture 1-3 warns against.
Luther was comparatively more tolerant than Calvin. He did not remove religious paintings or sculpture from places of worship altogether, but took care that they never became objects of worship in themselves.
4. Applying this today — art depicting biblical narrative
Today, most Protestant traditions — holding either the regulative or the normative principle — stand firmly against making an icon an object of worship. But they take a range of positions on using visual art depicting biblical narrative or theological themes (stained glass, painting, sculpture) for educational or aesthetic purposes.
This is the point at which the principles for symbol-use covered in Lecture 12-2 apply again directly.
- It must not become an object of worship. No piece of visual art should ever be bowed to or prayed to.
- It must retain its pointing function. Good religious art, much like the principle of illustration covered in Lecture 12-3 of [PT1 ], should not draw attention to itself, but should direct attention more clearly toward the truth it represents.
- It can serve as a theological resource affirming the reality of the incarnation. The iconodules' insight — that the incarnation itself justifies depicting Christ — suggests that art dealing with Christ's humanity and earthly ministry has genuine theological grounding. This does not extend equally, however, to depicting God the Father or the Holy Spirit, which the tradition has, on the whole, treated with far greater caution.
5. This is a point where readers will not agree
Images in worship
Chapter 12 has now walked through four disputed areas of worship practice, and the fourth is the one that has drawn the sharpest lines in church history. State it plainly: Eastern Orthodox Christians venerate icons as a central and cherished part of their worship life, following the theology the Second Council of Nicaea affirmed in 787 — the honor given to an image passes to the person it represents, and depicting Christ affirms rather than denies the incarnation. Roman Catholic worship likewise makes extensive use of images and statuary, understood within the same worship/veneration distinction, alongside a rich devotional tradition around them. Reformed and Puritan traditions, by contrast, read the second commandment as ruling out representational images in the place of worship altogether, judging — as Calvin judged — that the worship/veneration distinction collapses in practice, however carefully it is stated in theory. Lutheran and Anglican practice sits between these positions, permitting devotional art while remaining watchful against its misuse.
This course does not ask you to resolve that disagreement. It asks you to be able to state each side in a form its own holders would recognize as fair — the Orthodox and Catholic instinct that visual beauty and image can carry real devotion without displacing God, and the Reformed instinct that the human heart reaches for an image to worship far more readily than it admits, so that caution here is not fussiness but self-knowledge. What every side actually agrees on, and what this course does require, is narrower than any one tradition's full practice: no image, however carefully venerated, may become worship's true object.
6. Chapter 12 in review
Reviewing the whole of Chapter 12:
- Worship space (Lecture 12-1) — its arrangement (pulpit-centered or table-centered) theologically reflects what each tradition understands as worship's center.
- Symbol and color (Lecture 12-2) — tools that give visual expression to worship's theological content, used with real disagreement across traditions.
- The body's posture (Lecture 12-3) — the whole-person response of worship given physical shape; Scripture legitimizes a range of postures.
- Visual art (Lecture 12-4) — can richly serve worship once the second commandment's actual distinction, between forbidden image-worship and permitted image-making, is correctly drawn.
The principle running through all four lectures is this: space, symbol, body, and art are never worship's object — they are always tools that serve worship. Chapter 13 will finally integrate all of this theological reflection into the actual practice of leading worship and pastoral ministry.
| Category | Content |
|---|---|
| Forbidden | Bowing to and serving an image — making it worship's object |
| Permitted (evidenced by Exodus 25:18-20) | Making an image as such — the cherubim, for example |
| Core principle | An image must remain a pointing tool; it must never become worship's object |
In short
- The second commandment (Exodus 20:4-5) forbids making an image the object of worship, not making an image as such — confirmed by the cherubim of Exodus 25:18-20.
- The eighth- and ninth-century icon controversy was resolved, for the Byzantine church, when iconodule theology (the veneration/worship distinction, and the incarnation argument) was formally accepted at the Second Council of Nicaea in 787.
- During the Reformation, Calvin actively removed icons on pastoral grounds concerning the real danger of idolatry, while Luther was comparatively more tolerant.
- Today, visual art can serve worship usefully as a tool pointing toward theological truth, so long as it never becomes worship's object.
- Chapter 12 as a whole converges on one principle: worship space, symbol, the body's posture, and visual art are all tools that serve worship, never objects of worship themselves.
Topic: What the second commandment forbids, how the icon controversy was fought, and how visual art may serve worship.
Remember: The commandment forbids bowing to an image and serving it; making images is not itself forbidden, as the gold cherubim show.
Caution: The lecture does not settle the dispute: Orthodox, Catholic, Reformed, Lutheran and Anglican practice all differ, and all agree only that no image may become worship's object.
One line to carry into ministry: Use art only to point people to the truth, and never let anyone bow or pray to it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Reading Exodus 20:4-5 together with Exodus 25:18-20, explain precisely what the second commandment forbids.
- Explain the iconodule argument ("the incarnation justifies depicting Christ") in your own words, and offer your own assessment of it.
- Do you find Calvin's pastoral reasoning for removing icons — that the worship/veneration distinction is hard to maintain in practice — persuasive?
- Looking back over the whole of Chapter 12 (Lectures 12-1 through 12-4), what new insight has the principle "worship space, symbol, body, and art are tools, not objects, of worship" given you?