Lecture 8-3: Accompanying the Sick
Two easy answers should be resisted: promised healing and hidden blame. Honest decay with inward renewal is a third way.
Pastoral Theology: The Shepherd's Calling and Work
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Two easy answers should be resisted: promised healing and hidden blame. Honest decay with inward renewal is a third way.
Pastoral Theology: The Shepherd's Calling and Work
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Illness raises the question of why suffering exists and what a pastor should say. The first easy answer promises healing if faith is enough, which Scripture does not warrant. The second treats illness as necessarily a punishment for sin. Job's friends insisted on this, and God rebuked them at the end of the book (Job 42:7).
If healing depends on faith, a person who is not healed must conclude that their faith was weak or that God's promises failed. Neither conclusion is fair to force on someone already suffering. Paul prayed three times about a thorn in the flesh and received the answer, "my grace is sufficient for you." He was not told that his faith was inadequate.
God's closing verdict in Job is on the friends' theology, not on Job's suffering. In John 9:1-3, Jesus is asked whether a blind man or his parents sinned, and he answers "neither." The word "necessarily" is the key. A pastor has no basis to assume or state that an illness carries that meaning, and the better default is to assign no cause at all.
Ties the outcome to the sick person's faith, and leaves them with guilt or doubt if they do not recover.
Ties the illness to the person's sin, and leaves them asking what they did to deserve it.
Paul does not soften physical decline: "our outward man is decaying." He describes his own real, ongoing hardship. Alongside it he says the inward man is "renewed day by day." This renewal does not wait for the body to recover. It runs alongside the decline as a separate reality, not as its cure.
A pastor can honestly say that physical decline does not decide a person's inward life before God. Comfort, hope and a deeper relationship with God remain possible whatever happens to the body. This is different from "you will get better if you believe." It is also different from "this means something is wrong between you and God."
Do not promise a medical outcome, because a broken promise adds to suffering. Do not offer explanations for why this illness happened, especially uninvited ones. Pray honestly for healing, and also for inward renewal and for God's presence whatever the outcome. Simple, sustained presence often matters more than any words, because a sick person needs not to be left alone with the illness.
Recall words you have heard offered to a sick or grieving person.
Were they false comfort or hidden blame, and what could have been said instead?
Do not promise a recovery or explain the illness; pray honestly and stay with the person. The lecture does not discourage praying for healing. It says outward decay and inward renewal in 2 Corinthians 4:16 can both be true.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.