FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT4E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-1: The History of Pastoral Care, from the Desert to the Reformation

Pastoral care has a long history, from the desert to the Puritans. It shows which convictions are Scripture and which are inheritance.

Christian Counseling

12 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Describe at least three historical stages of pastoral care - patristic/desert, medieval, and Puritan - and name a representative figure and text from each.
  • Explain what Gregory the Great's Pastoral Rule and the desert fathers' practice of spiritual direction each contributed to the discipline of caring for souls, and how they differ from one another in method.
  • Explain what Richard Baxter meant by describing pastors as "physicians of the soul," and why that metaphor carries both an insight and a risk.
  • Use Matthew 7:3 to explain why pastoral judgmentalism is a recurring historical temptation rather than a modern invention, and identify at least one place in the history surveyed where that temptation is visible.
Why history

A long line before psychology

Every counselor stands in a long line of people who cared for souls before psychology existed. A counselor who does not know that line may mistake their own tradition's instincts for the Bible's plain teaching. History shows which convictions are Scripture and which are inheritance.

Key idea History is part of the theological work.
Scripture

Why Matthew 7:3?

The lecture uses the speck and the beam to name a temptation this history keeps producing: turning pastoral care into pastoral judgment.

Why do you see the speck that is in your brother's eye, but don't consider the beam that is in your own eye?" Matthew 7:3 · World English Bible
The desert

Spiritual direction

In the third and fourth centuries, elders in the Egyptian and Syrian deserts guided disciples through confession of thoughts, correction and slow trust. The elder rarely diagnosed quickly. The first move was usually careful listening, then specific counsel rather than a general moral lecture.

Key idea Discernment came before technique.
Gregory the Great

The Pastoral Rule

Gregory wrote a manual around the year 590. Part III sets out more than thirty paired kinds of people who need to be addressed differently. His principle is that one medicine does not heal every wound. He also warned that pastoral authority is dangerous because souls cannot be seen directly.

Key idea Different souls need different remedies.
The medieval confessional

A double legacy

Private confession produced real skill in telling degrees of sin and asking searching questions. But the priest's authority could make his own judgment seem like God's verdict. The sale of indulgences is the clearest case of care corrupted by the danger Matthew 7:3 names.

Key idea Real skill and real danger together.
The Reformation

Puritan physicians of the soul

Bucer and Baxter held that pastoral care belongs to every minister's ordinary work, through preaching and personal visits. Baxter personally examined and instructed every family in his parish across a year. A sermon addresses everyone in general, while a conversation can address one soul.

Key idea Care moved into ordinary ministry.
At a glance

The physician metaphor

The insight

Pastoral care needs diagnosis before treatment, and different conditions call for different remedies.

The risk

A pastor may trust his own diagnosis so much that he stops checking it against Matthew 7:3.

Think about it

Encouraging or unsettling?

Gregory compared pastoral care to medicine and said the soul cannot be directly examined.

Do you find that comparison encouraging, because it dignifies the work, or unsettling, because it raises the stakes?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Pastoral care runs from the desert fathers to the Puritans. Different souls need different remedies, and a pastor's power to judge others can hide his own faults. Test your own judgment against Matthew 7:3 before you name another person's sin.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12