FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT5E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-4: Formation Versus Information - A Live Debate

Should faith grow gradually through a community, or begin with a clear personal decision? Faithful Christians defend both.

Christian Education

11 cards 14 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Bushnell's central claim in Christian Nurture in his own terms, including his organic metaphor for how faith grows in a child.
  • State the decision-centered revivalist position Bushnell opposed in its strongest form, without caricature.
  • Explain how John Westerhoff's critique of the "schooling-instructional paradigm" and Thomas Groome's "shared praxis" model extend Bushnell's formation-side argument into the twentieth century.
  • Name this disagreement as a live, unresolved debate rather than a question this course has already settled.
Bushnell

Grow up a Christian

In 1847 Horace Bushnell published Christian Nurture. He argued that a child raised in a truly Christian household should grow up a Christian and never know himself as being otherwise. His image was a garden, not a factory. He did not deny original sin, and he did not describe passive absorption. The child's will is engaged throughout, but growth is gradual rather than marked by one decisive break.

Key idea Faith grows organically, nourished by the whole household.
The other side

The decision-centered view

The revivalist view Bushnell opposed has real biblical warrant. Scripture narrates dramatic conversions, such as Paul on the Damascus road and the Philippian jailer. Ephesians 2:1-5 speaks of a change from death to life. This view worries that organic nurture can assume grace where none is present and produce nominal Christians who were never asked to decide anything.

Key idea This position deserves a fair statement, not a caricature.
At a glance

Two positions

Formation (Bushnell)

Ongoing practice and belonging form faith over time, often without one moment the person can name.

Decision-centered

Clear teaching aimed at a conscious, owned response is indispensable and should not be diluted by gradual communal formation.

Westerhoff

Enculturation

John Westerhoff, in Will Our Children Have Faith?, opposed the "schooling-instructional paradigm," the idea that Christian education is mainly passing on content in a classroom. He proposed enculturation: faith is formed by taking part in the practices, rituals and relationships of a faith community. Worship, shared meals and ordinary care do more formational work than a curriculum.

Key idea A congregation's whole life may form more than its lessons.
Groome

Shared praxis

Thomas Groome, in Christian Religious Education, developed shared praxis. A group reflects on its present practice and experience. It brings that reflection into dialogue with the Christian story and vision, and moves toward a renewed practice. It is communal and two-way, not one-directional transmission from teacher to learner.

Key idea Groome gives the formation view a specific method.
No winner

A live debate

Content-centered and decision-oriented education did not disappear after 1847 or after Westerhoff's book in 1976. It remains the working assumption of a large share of the global evangelical and revivalist tradition. Both sides believe they are being biblical, and each can show real biblical warrant. A Christian educator is not choosing between the biblical view and a lesser one.

Key idea The lecture declares no winner.
Think about it

What formed you

Westerhoff argued that ordinary community life forms people more than a curriculum does.

Looking at your own faith history, what formed you more: a specific class or lesson, or the ordinary life of a community you belonged to?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Bushnell argued for gradual, communal growth in faith, and Westerhoff and Groome extended that view. The decision-centered view has real biblical and pastoral arguments too. Formation versus information is a live debate, and neither side is called the only biblical way.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11