FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT5E · Chapter 4

Lecture 4-4: Curriculum as an Expression of Theological Identity

No curriculum is neutral. Every one carries a tradition's assumptions, so check before you adopt.

Christian Education

11 cards 12 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain why "biblical curriculum" is not a neutral category, and give a concrete example of an assumption a curriculum can smuggle in without stating it.
  • Contrast a sacramental catechetical model with a decision-oriented evangelical model at the level of curricular assumptions, not merely doctrine.
  • Describe at least three specific things a church should check before adopting outside curriculum material.
  • Explain why this check matters even when the material in view seems doctrinally sound at a surface read.
The claim

"Biblical curriculum" is not one thing

A curriculum can look like it is simply "biblical," as if any church could adopt it without friction. The lecture argues that every curriculum is written from within a tradition's assumptions. These cover what matters most, how a person comes to faith, and how sacraments and membership relate to a child. A church that adopts outside material without checking may teach positions its own tradition does not hold.

Key idea A claim of neutrality is itself a choice.
At a glance

Two starting points

Sacramental, catechetical

Catholic or Orthodox practice is the clearest example. It assumes the baptized child already belongs, and it teaches to deepen that life.

Decision-oriented evangelical

It assumes the child is not yet "in," and it builds toward a personal decision, often followed by believer's baptism.

A disagreement

Each tradition can question the other

The lecture says readers will not agree here. A sacramental tradition can ask whether a decision-oriented curriculum teaches a baptized child that their baptism did not count until they decided. An evangelical tradition can ask whether a purely sacramental curriculum risks a child thinking membership guarantees saving faith. Each has serious theological reasons for its structure.

Key idea Neither model is the neutral shape of Christian education.
Checks one and two

Status and success

First, ask what the material assumes about a child's spiritual status before any lesson begins. Does it assume the child is already in, already out, or avoid the question? Second, ask what it treats as the marker of success. A prayer prayed once, growth over years, preparation for a sacrament and memorized content each reflect a different idea of how faith forms.

Key idea Each marker of success carries a theology.
Checks three and four

Vocabulary and silence

Third, ask what the vocabulary assumes the learner believes. Words like "accepting Christ," "getting saved," "confirmation" and "chrismation" are not labels for the same event. Fourth, ask what the material's silence says. Material built for one tradition may say nothing about practices that are central to another, and the church has to fill that gap on purpose.

Key idea Applying the null curriculum idea from lecture 4-1 helps here.
Practical

Check before adopting

The lecture does not say a church must write all its own curriculum. That is impractical for nearly any congregation. It says the checking must happen before adoption. Someone should read the material against the church's own convictions, and not rely on a publisher's marketing or a friend's recommendation from a different tradition.

Key idea This matters even when the material looks sound at first reading.
Think about it

Your own context

The lecture lists four checks: spiritual status, marker of success, vocabulary and silence.

If your church can only do one of these checks, which would you do first, and why?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Every curriculum expresses a theological tradition, even one labeled "Bible-based." Material built on another tradition's assumptions can contradict what your church teaches about baptism and how faith forms. Have someone read any new curriculum against your church's own teaching before you buy it.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11