FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT5E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-1: Why Assess at All

A church assesses to find out whether anyone grew, not only to fill in a report.

Christian Education

11 cards 16 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State, from Romans 14:12, the theological claim this lecture uses to ground Christian assessment in accountability before God rather than in classroom convention alone.
  • Distinguish assessment aimed at a teacher's stewardship and a student's growth from assessment reduced to institutional record-keeping, and give an example of each from ordinary church life.
  • Explain why "a church needs some record-keeping" and "record-keeping should not be the only reason a church assesses" are compatible claims, not contradictory ones.
  • Identify at least one assessment practice from your own context and evaluate which of these purposes it is actually serving.
The claim

More than a school habit

Many people remember church assessment as a quiz for moving up a grade or a chart of stars. Those can make assessment sound like a small thing borrowed from school. This lecture argues the opposite. Assessment in Christian education answers to the fact that Christians live under real accountability to God, and that a church that teaches has taken on a real stewardship.

Key idea Assessment finds out whether a learner has grown in the direction the teaching aimed at.
At a glance

Two masters of assessment

Serving the learner and teacher

An honest mirror that shows where growth has and has not happened, so teaching can be adjusted and encouragement can be specific.

Serving the institution

A record for a denominational requirement, a database field, or a committee asking whether a program is working.

Accountability

Answering to God

Paul writes in Romans 14:12 that each person will give account of himself to God. His immediate point is not to judge one another, so the lecture treats this only as a general ground. If a whole life is under account, the parts a church's teaching touches are too. The lecture adds that no teacher's quiz grade shows anyone's standing before God.

Key idea A church's assessment never replaces God's own account.
Stewardship

A second ground

A church commits volunteers, budgets and its students' attention to a teaching ministry. The lecture says stewardship without a way of checking results is only activity. It points to the parable of the talents, where the servant who buried his talent offered no account. This argument stands apart from the accountability argument, so a reader unsure of one can still accept the other.

Key idea A ministry should ask whether its teaching produces growth.
A disagreement

How far to push it

The lecture says readers will not agree about how far the analogy should go. Traditions with a strong emphasis on grace keep it on a short leash and do not want spiritual standing to look earned by scores. Traditions with a catechetical or examination-based practice accept a demonstrated grasp as a real gate before baptism, confirmation or membership. The lecture does not decide between them.

Key idea Some honest assessment is defensible on theological grounds.
A danger

When record-keeping is all that is left

A church needs some records, for example of who has been taught what. The danger is when record-keeping becomes the only reason to assess. Pressure to report can lead to easy quizzes or to every student passing something. Assessment then becomes theater that reports reassuring numbers without asking whether anyone grew.

Key idea Ask which purpose each assessment practice is really serving.
Think about it

Your own context

The lecture asks you to evaluate one assessment practice you know.

Is that practice mostly serving the learner, the teacher's stewardship, or the institution's records?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

A church can ground assessment in accountability to God and in stewardship of its teaching ministry. It needs some records, but they should not be the only reason to assess. Do not teach for years without some honest way of knowing whether the teaching landed.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11