FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT5E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-2: Assessing Knowledge Without Reducing It to a Memory Test

Recall is a floor, not the finish line. Add questions that ask learners to apply what they know.

Christian Education

11 cards 13 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain, from Hebrews 5:12-14, the distinction between milk-level and solid-food-level grasp of the faith, and why it is not the same as the distinction between correct and incorrect answers.
  • Give an example of a quiz question that tests recall and a revised version of the same question that tests discernment or application instead.
  • Identify at least one practical limit on how much "solid food" assessment a given class or age group can actually support.
  • State why this lecture argues for supplementing, not eliminating, recall-based questions in an assessment.
The problem

Recall is easy to test

Recall questions are easy to write, easy to score and easy to defend. On their own, they are a thin measure. A student can say who wrote Romans without being able to explain anything Romans argues. A curriculum that tests only recall may teach students that recall is the finish line.

Key idea Easy to measure does not mean it measures understanding.
Milk and solid food

The picture from Hebrews 5

Hebrews 5:12-14 rebukes readers who should be teachers but still need milk and not solid food. The lecture says the difference is not between right and wrong answers. It is between a grasp that stopped at ingredients and a grasp that has matured into the ability to discern. Discerning means weighing a case that the milk-level teaching never covered.

Key idea The aim is discernment, not only correctness.
At a glance

Two kinds of question

Recall: "Can you state it?"

For example, in which book is the Great Commission found? It tests whether information was stored and can be retrieved.

Discernment: "Can you use it?"

It gives a scenario, such as a coworker who spread a rumor, and asks what a biblically shaped response would be and why.

The cost

Harder to write and to grade

A discernment question may have more than one defensible answer. Grading it well needs a marker who understands the material, not one holding an answer key with a single string. The lecture says this cost is real. For this reason, the chapter's suggested exam mixes multiple-choice items with short-answer and essay items for the discernment work.

Key idea Multiple choice cannot honestly capture discernment-level work.
A disagreement

How much is realistic

The lecture says readers will not agree on how much discernment testing is realistic. A seminary or an adult class with trained graders can make it normal practice. A children's class run by untrained volunteers, in forty-five minutes, cannot easily do so. Some writers say it is too early for young children, and others say a well-designed question can suit a young child.

Key idea Know which level you are assessing, and do not let convenience decide.
Not eliminated

Recall is a floor, not a failure

The lecture does not say recall questions should be phased out. Some content really is a matter of correct recall, such as a passage's location or a basic definition. The error is a culture in which recall is the only level ever reached. A teacher can also look for less formal evidence, such as a discussion question, a role-play or pastoral observation.

Key idea The lecture supplements recall and does not remove it.
Think about it

Your own quizzes

The lecture suggests pairing fact questions with a question about a new case.

What recall question could you pair with a scenario that asks learners to apply the teaching?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Hebrews 5 pictures mature learners as able to discern, not only to remember. Recall questions stay as a floor, and discernment questions are added where a setting can support them. Pair your fact questions with at least one question that asks learners to apply the teaching to a new case.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11