FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT5E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-3: Assessing Character and Practice

Character cannot be measured on paper, and no human can read a heart, so any judgment must stay humble.

Christian Education

11 cards 13 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain both directions of 1 Samuel 16:7's warning as applied to assessing character: against mistaking outward performance for real character, and about the limits of any human being's capacity to assess a heart.
  • Identify at least one method (beyond a written test) that can gather some real evidence of character or practice over time, and name its own limitation.
  • State why this lecture treats character assessment as necessarily provisional rather than as something a well-designed instrument could someday make reliable.
  • Give an example of how a church could hold a claim about a student's character with appropriate humility rather than false confidence in either direction.
The hardest case

Not what a student knows, but who they are becoming

A written test can check a recalled fact or a reasoned case. Character is different. No multiple-choice question reliably measures patience, humility or love of neighbor. Character shows itself in unscripted moments, and a student who knows they are watched can perform virtue without having it.

Key idea This is the most important and the hardest kind of assessment.
Warning one

Do not mistake polish for character

The lecture reads 1 Samuel 16:7 as warning in two directions. First, do not equate outward performance with real character. Samuel nearly chose Eliab because of his stature, although he had the outward qualifications. A student who speaks well in discussion has not thereby shown more growth than a quiet student who is wrestling with the material.

Key idea Favoring the easier-to-notice student repeats Samuel's near-mistake.
Warning two

Only God sees the heart

The second half of the verse is about who is looking. A teacher cannot see a heart as God does. A teacher can see behavior, speech and relationship over time. From that limited evidence, any conclusion about character stays provisional and open to revision.

Key idea The contrast is a limit, not an instruction to try harder.
A disagreement

How far the caution reaches

The lecture says readers will not agree here. Catholic and Orthodox catechesis make real judgments of readiness before confirmation or chrismation, framed as the church's provisional discernment. Traditions wary of spiritual gatekeeping fear that formal checks suggest standing is earned. Both can accept the warning of 1 Samuel 16:7, and they differ on how much weight a provisional human judgment may carry.

Key idea The lecture does not decide between them.
At a glance

Where evidence can come from

A teacher over time

Many ordinary, unscripted moments, such as how a student treats an excluded peer, and whether private and group answers match. No single observation is decisive.

A group's shared reflection

Thomas Groome's shared praxis reads growth from a community's own reflection. It spreads observation across more eyes, but a group's self-report can also be a performance.

A posture

Neither silence nor false confidence

A teacher can notice a pattern and name it to a student as encouragement or concern. The teacher can use it to shape teaching and prayer. The judgment should stay revisable and leave room for the student to be more than the pattern suggests. A note such as "growing in patience with younger children this year" should not be filed like a quiz grade.

Key idea Never convert a character note into a permanent institutional record.
Think about it

Your own teaching

The lecture warns against treating the most talkative student as the one who has grown most.

Which quieter learner might you be overlooking because their growth is harder to notice?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Gather evidence of character over time from ordinary moments, and treat any conclusion as provisional. The lecture rejects both silence about character and false confidence. Notice patterns in a student's life, name them kindly, and never record them as a permanent verdict.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11