FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT5E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-4: Formative and Summative Assessment

Check in often and lightly while teaching, and take stock formally only at a real endpoint.

Christian Education

11 cards 12 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Define formative and summative assessment and give one clear church-based example of each.
  • Explain why Philippians 1:6's picture of ongoing, incomplete work fits formative assessment's purpose more naturally than it fits summative assessment's purpose.
  • Identify at least one harm that results from treating a formative check-in as if it carried summative weight, and one harm from relying only on summative assessment with no formative check-ins along the way.
  • Design a simple formative check-in for a specific lesson or unit you are familiar with.
Two jobs

A final exam and a quick check-in

A final exam and a teacher's quick question in the middle of a lesson are both assessment. They do very different jobs. A teaching plan that has only one of them is missing something the other was built to supply. This lecture names the difference as formative and summative assessment.

Key idea They are not rivals. They answer different questions at different times.
At a glance

Formative and summative

Formative

How is this learner doing now, and what should change while there is still time? Examples are a show of hands, an exit slip, or a leader noticing that a group went quiet.

Summative

Taking stock at a defined endpoint. Examples are a chapter quiz, a final exam, or a certificate awarded when a course ends.

Philippians 1:6

An unfinished work

Paul is confident that the one who began a good work will complete it until the day of Jesus Christ. The work is still going on, and its completion lies beyond what any teacher will see. The lecture says this fits formative assessment. A check-in that finds a student has not yet grasped a concept is not reporting failure, only an unfinished work at an earlier stage.

Key idea No endpoint is the end of the good work God began.
Summative risk

A grade is not a verdict

Summative assessment is not forbidden, because a course does end and something honest can be said about where a student stands. The risk is treating the result as more final than it is. A single grade can feel like a verdict on a student's spiritual condition or worth, especially if a church's culture treats it that way.

Key idea A result at the end of a unit is not a final verdict.
Confused

When the two get mixed up

If a mid-lesson check-in lowers a grade or corrects a student in front of peers, students learn to hide their confusion. Black and Wiliam's research favors frequent, low-stakes feedback, but only if students experience it as low-stakes. The other failure is having only summative tests. A misunderstanding can grow for weeks and surface at the final exam, when there is no time left to correct it.

Key idea A check-in that secretly counts toward a grade is not formative.
A rule of thumb

Mostly formative

Most assessment moments should be formative. They should be quick, low-stakes and aimed at adjusting the next lesson. Summative assessment should be kept for genuine endpoints, such as a chapter's close or a course's completion. The lecture says nothing suggests every class session before a quiz should be tested with the same weight.

Key idea Check often and lightly, and take stock formally at the end.
Think about it

Design a check-in

The lecture asks you to design a simple formative check-in for a lesson you know.

What one ungraded question could you ask in the middle of your next lesson to learn whether it is landing?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Formative checks adjust the next lesson, and summative checks mark progress at an endpoint. A plan needs both. Do not let a check-in count as a grade, and ask quick ungraded questions during lessons while keeping formal tests for the end of a unit.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11