FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT6E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-3: This Course's Position, Stated Honestly

The course holds exclusivism with reverent agnosticism about the hard cases at its edge.

Missiology: The Theology and Practice of Christian Mission

11 cards 12 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State this course's position and its textual basis, distinguishing it from both the "hard" exclusivism of 3-1 taken to its most confident edge and the inclusivism of 3-2.
  • Explain what Deuteronomy 29:29 contributes to this position and why it is not merely an evasion.
  • Articulate, in the voice of a reader who holds exclusivism's more confident form, or inclusivism, what they would say in response to this course's position - accurately enough that they would recognize the summary as fair.
  • State at least one pastoral implication that follows from holding this position rather than either alternative.
Saying where we stand

One option among those named

Every missiology course must say where it stands, not only what the options are. This lecture states the course's position as one considered option among those already named, held with reasons. It also gives an honest account of what a reader who lands elsewhere would say. If the lecture reads as though the debate is now closed, it has failed.

Key idea A position, not the end of the debate.
The position

Exclusivism with reverent agnosticism

The course holds that Christ's atoning work is the sole ground of salvation, and that Scripture describes salvation as received through conscious faith in him. It refuses to turn that God has not told us the mechanism for every hard case into a claimed answer it does not have. The lecture calls this exclusivism held with reverent agnosticism about the boundary.

Key idea Firm on what Scripture states, restrained beyond it.
The center

Leaning exclusivist

The course reads John 14:6, Acts 4:12, and 1 Timothy 2:5 as 1-3-1 argued. People are said to be saved through hearing, believing, and calling on Christ, not through devotion sincerely offered to something else. On whether conscious knowledge is the required means or only the ordinary means, it leans exclusivist for Carson's reason: the New Testament's missionary urgency is easiest to explain if the alternative was not available.

Key idea Conscious faith is the pattern Scripture describes.
The edge

What Deuteronomy 29:29 adds

The course parts from a more confident exclusivism only at the edge. Scripture says plainly that Christ is the way but does not say as plainly how God deals with the infant, the severely cognitively impaired, or someone whose contact with the gospel was too brief or too corrupted. Deuteronomy 29:29 separates the secret things that belong to God from the revealed things that belong to us. Holding a firm line on what is revealed while declining to manufacture certainty is not equivocation.

Key idea Do not manufacture certainty about what is not revealed.
In practice

What it changes for pastors

When someone asks about the person who never heard, the course counsels honesty about the limits of what Scripture states. It does not promise an outcome Scripture does not promise, and it does not pronounce a verdict Scripture does not pronounce. Against inclusivism it holds that proclamation is the means God has appointed, so the missionary task carries full weight.

Key idea Honest answers, and no lighter task.
Two replies

What others would say back

The fuller exclusivist

This agnosticism is a good pastoral instinct but unstable: either the pattern holds without exception, or inclusivism deserves a harder look. The course answers that a pattern stated for the adult who hears is not a pattern Scripture states for cases it never puts in view.

The inclusivist

Admitted uncertainty shows the sharp line is less secure, and wide mercy may reach a seeker as Pinnock argues. The course answers that Scripture's silence on a case is not a mechanism, since the same texts state Christ's necessity where they do speak.

Think about it

Answering honestly

The course counsels honesty about the limits of what Scripture states.

If someone asked you about a person who never heard the gospel, how would you answer without promising or pronouncing more than Scripture does?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The course holds that Christ is the only way and that Scripture's pattern is salvation through hearing and believing. It stays restrained about hard cases Scripture does not address. Nothing in later chapters depends on settling this question one way.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11