Lecture 5-3: Comparing Strategic Models
Contents 66
- Lecture 1-1: The Missio Dei — Mission as Something God Does
- Lecture 1-2: The Abrahamic Covenant — Blessed to Be a Blessing
- Lecture 1-3: The Missionary Trajectory Through the Old Testament
- Lecture 1-4: Jesus and the Mission of the Kingdom
- Lecture 1-5: The Great Commission — Grammar and Synthesis
- Lecture 2-1: The Apostolic Spread of the Early Church
- Lecture 2-2: Medieval and Monastic Mission
- Lecture 2-3: The Birth of the Modern Mission Movement
- Lecture 2-4: Twentieth-Century and Contemporary Mission Movements
- Lecture 2-5: Chapter Synthesis — Reading Mission History Whole
- Lecture 3-1: The Theology of Religions, Part 1 — Exclusivism
- Lecture 3-2: The Theology of Religions, Part 2 — Inclusivism and Pluralism
- Lecture 3-3: This Course's Position, Stated Honestly
- Lecture 3-4: The Contextualization Spectrum — C1 Through C6
- Lecture 3-5: Syncretism — Where Contextualization Crosses a Line
- Lecture 4-1: What Culture Is — From Surface to Deep Structure
- Lecture 4-2: Worldview and the Gospel
- Lecture 4-3: Culture Shock and the Missionary's Own Adjustment
- Lecture 4-4: Bible Translation and Contextualized Communication
- Lecture 4-5: Chapter Synthesis — Respect for Culture, Faithfulness to the Gospel
- Lecture 5-1: Church Planting and the Three-Self Principle
- Lecture 5-2: Holistic Mission — Word and Deed
- Lecture 5-3: Comparing Strategic Models
- Lecture 5-4: Partnership and Collaborative Mission
- Lecture 5-5: Designing Strategy for a Context
- Lecture 6-1: Discerning a Missionary Call
- Lecture 6-2: Spiritual and Character Preparation
- Lecture 6-3: Theological and Practical Training
- Lecture 6-4: The Missionary Family and Third-Culture Kids
- Lecture 6-5: Chapter Synthesis and Preparation for the Mid-Course Exam
- Lecture 7-1: Defining "Unreached People Group"
- Lecture 7-2: The 10/40 Window
- Lecture 7-3: Ministry in Restricted-Access Nations
- Lecture 7-4: Disciple-Making Movements Among Unreached Peoples
- Lecture 7-5: Chapter Synthesis — Responsibility Without Ranking
- Lecture 8-1: A Theology of the City
- Lecture 8-2: Strategy for an Urbanizing World
- Lecture 8-3: Diaspora Mission — The Nations Have Come to Us
- Lecture 8-4: Ministry to Refugees and Migrant Workers
- Lecture 8-5: Chapter Synthesis — Urban Poverty and Justice as Inseparable from Urban Mission
- Lecture 9-1: Acts 1:8 as a Concentric Pattern, Not a Sequence
- Lecture 9-2: Multicultural Ministry Within One's Own Country
- Lecture 9-3: Mission to the Next Generation Within One's Own Culture
- Lecture 9-4: Under-Resourced Churches and Under-Reached Regions at Home
- Lecture 9-5: Chapter Synthesis — The Mission Field Nearest Home
- Lecture 10-1: The Biblical Roots of Justice and Compassion in Mission
- Lecture 10-2: Creation Care as Missional Responsibility
- Lecture 10-3: Ministry Confronting Human Trafficking and Exploitation
- Lecture 10-4: How Justice Ministry and Evangelism Relate
- Lecture 10-5: Chapter Synthesis — Holistic Mission as the Course's Mid-Point Capstone
- Lecture 11-1: What a Sending Church Is
- Lecture 11-2: A Healthy Sending Process
- Lecture 11-3: Member Care
- Lecture 11-4: Communication Between Sending Church and Missionary
- Lecture 11-5: Chapter Synthesis — The Whole Church Builds a Missionary
- Lecture 12-1: What Short-Term Mission Is
- Lecture 12-2: A Fair Evaluation of Short-Term Mission
- Lecture 12-3: Principles of Responsible Short-Term Mission
- Lecture 12-4: Mobilizing the Next Generation
- Lecture 12-5: Chapter Synthesis — Going, Sending, Praying, Giving
Given the goal chapter 5 has assumed so far — a planted, reproducing, indigenous church, pursued through some combination of word and deed — how should that goal actually be organized into a working strategy? This lecture compares three broad strategic models that have each shaped substantial parts of the modern mission movement: strategy organized around specific people groups, church-planting-movement and disciple-making-movement approaches that pursue rapid multiplication through simple reproducible methods, and traditional institutional mission carried out through schools, hospitals, and other standing institutions. As with 5-2, the aim here is comparison, not a ranking; each model has real strengths and real, documented critiques, and each has produced both fruit and disappointment somewhere in the field.
What these 12 minutes give you
- Describe people-group-focused strategy and explain what problem it was designed to solve.
- Explain what a church-planting-movement or disciple-making-movement approach claims, citing David Garrison's research, and state at least one methodological critique that has been raised about how such movements are counted.
- Describe traditional institutional mission and name a real strength and a real limitation of the model.
- Explain why comparing these models fairly requires asking what each was built to accomplish, rather than judging all three by the same single metric.
He said to them, 'Go into all the world, and preach the Good News to the whole creation. He who believes and is baptized will be saved; but he who disbelieves will be condemned.'
Mark 16:15-16, World English Bible
1. People-group-focused strategy
Chapter 7 will define "unreached people group" precisely and examine the strategic framework built on it in full; this lecture introduces the underlying logic only as far as strategy requires. The core insight, associated with Ralph Winter's influential 1974 Lausanne address, is that evangelizing a nation is not the same task as evangelizing every distinct ethnolinguistic and social group living inside that nation's borders — a country can contain a large, well-established church among one people group while a neighboring group, separated by language, caste, or social boundary, has never had a sustained gospel witness at all, even though both groups share a passport. People-group strategy therefore organizes mission effort by identifying which specific groups have functionally no access to the gospel in a form they can understand and receive, and directing attention there rather than assuming a national statistic tells the whole story.
The strength of this model is precision: it corrects a real blind spot in strategy that counts only national-level statistics, and it has driven substantial, well-documented effort toward groups that would otherwise have been assumed "reached" because they share a country with a Christian majority. Its limitation, addressed more fully in chapter 7, is that the category itself requires careful, contestable judgment calls about where one people group ends and another begins, and a strategy built entirely around the category can undervalue mission within already-reached groups, where real, if different, needs (chapter 9's domestic mission, for instance) still exist.
2. Church-planting movements and disciple-making movements
A second model, associated most closely with David Garrison's research and writing (his 1999 study and later book Movements), describes and advocates for strategies built around rapid multiplication: simple, reproducible methods for evangelism, , and church formation that a new believer can immediately pass on to others without waiting for extensive external training, so that churches multiply through several generations of local reproduction rather than through a missionary or agency personally planting each new congregation. Garrison's research surveys documented cases, largely though not exclusively in Asia, in which this pattern produced remarkably rapid numerical growth compared to more traditional, missionary-dependent planting.
The model's appeal is clear: if reproduction is genuinely simple and local, the ceiling on growth is not the number of trained missionaries available but the willingness of believers already present to keep passing the process on, which in principle allows a movement to outrun any realistic missionary staffing level. The model's real, documented critique concerns measurement rather than the underlying strategy itself: researchers have raised methodological questions about how movement statistics are gathered and verified — self-reported numbers from local leaders eager to report success, inconsistent definitions of what counts as a "church" or a "generation" of reproduction, and the practical difficulty of independently confirming figures in restricted-access settings where outside verification is itself risky or impossible. Chapter 7 returns to this specific critique in the context of unreached peoples, where the stakes of overstated numbers are highest. None of this means the underlying strategic logic — favor methods a new believer can immediately reproduce, rather than methods that require years of specialized training before anyone else can be taught — is wrong; it means the numbers attached to any specific reported movement deserve the same scrutiny any other strategic claim would receive.
3. Traditional institutional mission
A third model, older than either of the first two in its modern form, works through standing institutions: mission schools, hospitals, orphanages, seminaries, agricultural or vocational training centers, and similar long-term structures that a mission society builds and staffs over years or decades. Its strength is durability and depth of relationship: an institution can serve a community's genuine needs consistently over a long period, train national leaders to a high level of competence (chapter 6's later discussion of theological training depends on institutions of exactly this kind existing somewhere), and build the kind of sustained trust that a short-term or rapidly reproducing approach may not have time to establish. Much of the historic missionary medical and educational work chapter 2 surveyed operated on this model, and a considerable share of the schools, hospitals, and seminaries now run by national churches worldwide trace their origin to it.
Its documented limitation is cost and pace: an institution is expensive to build and staff, ties mission resources to a single physical location for a long period, and can — without careful attention to the three-self principle from 5-1 — become exactly the kind of permanent foreign-run structure that never transitions to national ownership. An institutional strategy also grows more slowly by design than a reproducing-movement strategy; it was never built to multiply rapidly through simple local reproduction, and judging it a failure by that standard misapplies a metric built for a different model to a model with different goals.
4. Comparing fairly
The three models above are not mutually exclusive in practice — a single national church can include institutions, movement-style reproduction, and people-group-targeted teams operating at the same time, and many real mission fields do exactly that. The comparison this lecture has drawn matters less for picking a single winner than for a more basic discipline: asking what a given model was actually built to accomplish before judging it. A people-group strategy judged by how many hospitals it built, a movement strategy judged by how few of its converts hold seminary degrees, or an institutional strategy judged by how slowly it multiplies compared to a reproducing movement are all cases of measuring a strategy against a goal it was never designed to pursue. 5-5 returns to this point directly, with the questions a strategist should actually ask before choosing among these models for a specific context.
In short
- People-group strategy, tied to Ralph Winter's 1974 address, notes that a nation can be reached while a group inside it has no gospel witness. Its limit is hard judgments about where groups begin and end.
- Church-planting and disciple-making movements, researched by David Garrison, use simple methods that new believers can pass on at once, and some grew rapidly.
- A real critique concerns counting: self-reported numbers, unclear definitions of "church" or "generation," and hard verification. The logic is not shown to be wrong.
- Institutional mission (schools, hospitals, seminaries) is durable and builds trust, but it is costly, slow, and can stay foreign-run.
- Models should be judged by what each was built to do, and real fields often combine them.
Topic: The lecture compares three strategic models: people-group focus, movement approaches, and institutional mission.
Remember: Each model has real strengths and documented limits, and each should be judged against its own goal.
Caution: Movement statistics deserve the same scrutiny as any strategic claim, and the lecture does not rank the three models.
One line to carry into ministry: Before judging a method, ask what it was designed to accomplish.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why might a national government's or denomination's statistics on "percent Christian" mask the exact gap that people-group strategy is designed to find?
- Garrison's movement research has produced striking growth figures alongside real methodological critique. How should a strategist weigh a striking reported result against a documented difficulty in verifying it, without either dismissing the report or accepting it uncritically?
- Name one strength of institutional mission that neither a people-group strategy nor a rapid-multiplication movement is well positioned to provide, and explain why.
- If you were advising a small denomination with limited missionary personnel choosing among these three models for a specific field, what questions would you want answered before recommending one?