FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT701E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-1: Inerrancy and Pulpit Authority

A preacher's authority rises and falls with fidelity to the text

Advanced Expository Preaching

13 cards 17 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State what inerrancy actually claims, and distinguish it from at least two common caricatures of the doctrine.
  • Explain the specific way inerrancy grounds a preacher's authority to say "this text says" rather than "in my opinion."
  • State, in its strongest form, at least one serious objection to inerrancy — historically, the neo-orthodox account associated with Karl Barth — and explain why this course does not adopt it, without misrepresenting what Barth actually argued.
  • Distinguish preaching Scripture as God's own address from treating it merely as a valuable record of someone else's religious experience, and explain in concrete terms what changes in a sermon's posture between the two.
The claim

What "this text says" assumes

When a preacher says "this text says," a claim is already in force: the text is trustworthy enough to carry the preacher's authority, not merely borrow the preacher's personality. That claim is called inerrancy. Both its friends and its critics often state it imprecisely, so the lecture states it carefully.

Key idea A caricature of inerrancy is weaker than the actual doctrine.
Scripture

Why 2 Timothy 3:16?

The lecture uses this verse because it says Scripture itself, the text Timothy had been reading, is God-breathed. This is a claim about the text's own origin and character, not only about the sincerity of the human writers.

Every Scripture is God-breathed and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for instruction in righteousness,
Definition

What inerrancy claims

Inerrancy, as the course holds it, is the claim that Scripture, in what it actually intends to affirm, does not assert what is false. It is a claim about truthfulness within the text's own communicative intentions. It is not a wooden literalism the text never claims for itself. If God is the source and does not err in what he intends to say, then Scripture does not either.

Key idea The preacher reports what God has said, once exegesis has found what the passage affirms.
Authority

Fidelity, not confident delivery

The authority belongs to the text, and the sermon's authority is derivative. It holds exactly to the degree the sermon says what the text says. A poorly exegeted sermon delivered with total conviction borrows an authority it has not earned. A careful sermon delivered with visible uncertainty still says something true to the extent it is faithful.

Key idea Inerrancy locates confidence in the text, not in the preacher.
Limits

What inerrancy does not claim

The Chicago Statement (1978) builds in qualifications. Inerrancy does not require verbatim quotation of speech, modern-style precision in numbers, or technical scientific vocabulary for nature. "The sun rose" describes how the sky looks. It also does not require every parallel account to be forced into one seamless narrative. Two truthful accounts can differ in what they include.

Key idea Precision about the doctrine is the difference between a defensible position and a strawman.
Objection

Barth's view, stated fairly

Karl Barth held that Scripture is the witness to God's Word, and that it becomes the Word of God in the event of encounter, when God speaks through it. He worried that calling the text inerrant could turn revelation into propositions a reader controls. The lecture says Barth was not denying the deity of Christ and was not a liberal in disguise.

Key idea This is a serious view held by a serious theologian.
The answer

Why the course holds the text-centered view

The course gives three steps. First, 2 Timothy 3:16 says "every Scripture," a fixed fact about its origin. Second, Jesus in John 10:34-35 settles a dispute by what is written, since the Scripture cannot be broken. Third, on Barth's account a preacher cannot say in advance that a passage will be God's address this Sunday. The lecture still grants Barth's concern, which is why chapter 3 holds the text and the Spirit's illumination together.

Key idea Confidence is about what the text already is, not about how a hearer will respond.
At a glance

Two ways of preaching a text

God's own address

The final move is "believe and obey." A hearer who disagrees is told they have misunderstood something true.

A valuable human record

The final move is "consider." A hearer who disagrees is told they have a different, equally valid perspective.

Think about it

Consider, or believe and obey?

The lecture says the difference rarely shows in a sermon's method. It shows in the final appeal.

In the last minute of a recent sermon you gave or heard, was the closing move "consider" or "believe and obey"?

Recap

What to carry forward

Inerrancy means Scripture does not assert what is false in what it intends to affirm, and a sermon has authority only as far as it says what the text says. It does not claim modern precision or forced harmony. Barth is not a careless liberal, and his warning against controlling revelation still applies. Let your confidence rest on faithfulness to the text, not on how sure you sound.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13