FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT701E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-2: The False Dichotomy of Spirit and Preparation

Preparation and dependence are one discipline

Advanced Expository Preaching

12 cards 13 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the "Spirit vs. preparation" false dichotomy in a way that a holder of either extreme position would recognize as fairly described.
  • Give a real historical example of over-reliance on unprepared spontaneity, and a real example of treating exegesis as a purely academic exercise, without treating either as a caricature of an entire tradition.
  • Explain the argument, associated with D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones among others, for holding rigorous preparation and Spirit-dependence together as one discipline rather than two competing ones.
  • Identify, in your own preparation habits, which pole you are more likely to drift toward under pressure, and name one concrete practice that would counteract that drift.
The problem

"Both" in theory, one pole in practice

Ask preachers whether a sermon should be prepared carefully or delivered in dependence on the Spirit, and nearly everyone says "both." Under pressure, the same preachers drift toward one pole long before they would state it as a considered position. The lecture names both poles with a real historical example of each. It then argues that the tension is a discipline to maintain, not a problem solved by choosing a side.

Key idea The drift happens in a demanding week or a dry season, not by decision.
Scripture

Why 1 Corinthians 3:6-7?

The lecture uses this passage because Paul refuses both the overestimation of human method and the trivializing of human labor. He does not say planting and watering do nothing. He says the increase belongs to God alone. The lecture applies this to holding preparation and dependence together.

I planted. Apollos watered. But God gave the increase. So then neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase.
Pole one

Spontaneity as a mark of the Spirit

One extreme treats spontaneity as a sign of the Spirit's presence, so careful preparation begins to look like a lack of faith. Grant Wacker's study of early Pentecostalism documents a widespread suspicion that too much study quenched the Spirit. He also shows this was neither universal nor without internal critics. At its worst, preachers had done little to establish what a text says before proclaiming it.

Key idea The lecture does not treat this as defining Pentecostalism as a whole.
Pole two

Preparation as a purely academic exercise

The other extreme treats preparation as disciplined method with no acknowledged need for prayer, in the study or the pulpit. Karl Barth's retrospective critique of the liberal Protestant preaching he was trained in names it from the inside. His turn away from that tradition is a historical example of a preacher rejecting this extreme in his own training.

Key idea A pulpit can become reliably accurate and reliably lifeless.
The cost

What each extreme risks

Neither extreme is mainly about bad intentions. The spontaneity extreme risks a pulpit unaccountable to the text, shaped by whatever moves the preacher or congregation in the moment. The purely academic extreme risks sound information delivered by a preacher who has stopped expecting God to do anything through the sermon. A preacher warned against only one of these is not yet safe from the other.

Key idea Both failures are real and documented.
Together

Unction comes upon preparation

Lloyd-Jones, in Preaching and Preachers, treats preparation and dependence as two aspects of one act. His unction, a felt sense of God's power in delivery, comes upon preparation and not instead of it. J. I. Packer argues in Keep in Step with the Spirit that the Spirit's ordinary way is to work through diligence, not to bypass it.

Key idea They are not two items competing for the same time.
At a glance

A checkable test

Unhurried exegetical labor

Specific hours in the preceding week spent in careful study of the text.

Unhurried prayer, apart from study

Time not itself sermon preparation: reading Scripture devotionally, interceding for the congregation by name, confessing sin.

Think about it

Which pole do you drift toward?

The lecture says a preacher who can produce one list but not the other has already chosen a side.

Looking at last week, which list is shorter for you, and what one practice would counteract the drift?

Recap

What to carry forward

Rigorous study is real labor, and it still cannot produce what only God gives. The lecture does not say early Pentecostalism as a whole despised study. Check last week honestly: if you cannot list both study hours and separate prayer hours, you have already chosen a side.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12