FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT701E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-4: The Analogy of Faith — Legitimate Use and Real Danger

Use clearer Scripture to hear a hard text, not to silence it

Advanced Expository Preaching

12 cards 17 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the analogy of faith accurately, including both what it claims and what it does not claim.
  • Explain why some form of this principle is unavoidable for any preacher who believes Scripture does not contradict itself, using an example other than the one this lecture works in detail.
  • Narrate Luther's treatment of James 2 as a specific historical case where the analogy of faith was used to diminish, rather than genuinely harmonize with, a text's plain sense — stating his reasoning fairly before stating the problem with it.
  • Distinguish, in your own preparation, between letting Scripture's clearer teaching help you read a harder text and letting your prior theological conclusion silence a text that actually says something different.
The principle

The analogy of faith

The analogy of faith holds that Scripture comes from one God who does not contradict himself. So a text that is genuinely unclear should be read in harmony with what Scripture states plainly elsewhere on the same subject. Some version of this is unavoidable for a preacher who treats Scripture as a coherent whole. Stated carelessly, the same principle becomes a license to make a text say what the interpreter's prior system requires.

Key idea It is sound when used carefully and dangerous when used carelessly.
Limits

What it does not claim

The principle does not let a preacher set aside what a clear text plainly says because it is inconvenient for a system. It does not make "Scripture elsewhere" something a preacher names alone, without deriving it carefully. And it does not claim that every tension between two texts is only apparent. Some tensions are real enough that faithful readers continue to disagree about how to hold both texts together.

Key idea The "does not claim" half matters as much as the claim.
Scripture

Why James 2:14, 17-24?

The lecture uses this passage as its clearest documented case of the principle being used to diminish a text. James says "by works, a man is justified, and not only by faith." That seems to be close to the opposite of Paul, and it troubled Martin Luther.

What good is it, my brothers, if a man says he has faith, but has no works? Can faith save him? ... Even so faith, if it has no works, is dead in itself. Yes, a man will say, "You have faith, and I have works." Show me your faith without works, and I by my works will show you my faith. You believe that God is one. You do well. The demons also believe, and shudder. But do you want to know, vain man, that faith apart from works is dead? Wasn't Abraham our father justified by works, in that he offered up Isaac his son on the altar? You see that faith worked with his works, and by works faith was perfected; and the Scripture was fulfilled which says, "Abraham believed God, and it was accounted to him as righteousness"; and he was called the friend of God. You see then that by works, a man is justified, and not only by faith.
The tension

Paul and James on justification

Paul says a person is justified by faith and not by works, in Romans 3:28 and Galatians 2:16. James appears to say close to the opposite in James 2:24. James uses the same Greek verb for "justified" and the same patriarch, Abraham, whom Paul uses in Romans 4. Luther concluded that James could not be reconciled with the plain teaching of the rest of the New Testament. In 1522 he called it "an epistle of straw."

Key idea Luther responded to a real exegetical tension, inside a controversy against a system of merit.
Where it went wrong

The principle inverted

Bringing Paul to bear on James was the analogy of faith doing legitimate work. The problem is what followed. Luther treated the tension as evidence that James's plain statement must be wrong or marginal. Clearer teaching was used to discount the difficult text's plain claim instead of to understand it. The lecture says this does not excuse the conclusion, but it explains how a serious, faithful reader arrived at it.

Key idea The problem was the use of the comparison, not the comparison.
Another way

Engaging both texts on their own terms

James answers someone who claims faith while showing no works. The faith he calls dead is bare assent: "the demons also believe, and shudder." On this reading James denies that a merely notional assent is the kind of faith that saves, which Paul would not obviously reject. The lecture does not claim to have settled every question, and serious interpreters propose other ways of relating James and Paul. Its narrower point is that the tension can be engaged without demoting either writer.

Key idea Paul and James may be answering two different questions.
At a glance

Two uses of the principle

Used rightly

Ask what each writer means by "faith" and "justified" on the text's own terms. Coherence is found without silencing either writer.

Used wrongly

Treat the clearer text as a reason to doubt the harder text's plain claim. The text's own argument is set aside, not engaged.

Think about it

The honest question

The lecture says a preacher can ask honestly in the study whether clearer teaching is being used to understand a harder text or to decide in advance what it cannot mean.

Think of a theological question where you have seen a clearer text used to discount a harder one. What would engaging the harder text on its own terms have required?

Recap

What to carry forward

Use Scripture's clearer teaching to help hear a harder text on its own terms, not to override what the text plainly says. The test is whether you are trying to understand the text or deciding in advance that it cannot mean what it says. When a hard text clashes with your system, let the tension cost you real work, and hear both texts on their own terms before harmonizing.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12