FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT701E · Chapter 7

Lecture 7-3: Sidney Greidanus and the Seven Ways to Christ

Name the route, then test it against the text

Advanced Expository Preaching

12 cards 15 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Name and briefly describe at least five of Greidanus's stated ways of moving from an Old Testament text to Christ.
  • Distinguish typology from allegory as Greidanus uses the terms, and explain why the distinction matters for whether a connection is textually warranted.
  • State Greidanus's own stated criteria for testing whether a given route to Christ is warranted by the text rather than imposed on it.
  • Apply at least one of Greidanus's routes to a specific Old Testament passage of your own choosing, and identify which of his criteria would need to be satisfied to defend the move.
The problem

Vagueness about the connection

A weakness in loose redemptive-historical preaching is vagueness about how an Old Testament text connects to Christ. "This points to Jesus" does not say whether the connection is a fulfilled prediction, a pattern, an analogy or a contrast. Sidney Greidanus, a professor of preaching at Calvin Theological Seminary, refused that vagueness in his book Preaching Christ from the Old Testament (1999). He named several kinds of legitimate connection, each with its own test.

Key idea The routes are not rivals. One text may be reached by more than one.
Routes 1-4

The first four routes

1. Redemptive-historical progression

The text is one stage in the single unfolding story that is completed in Christ's work.

2. Promise-fulfillment

A text states a promise that the New Testament identifies Christ as fulfilling.

3. Typology

An Old Testament person, event or institution is a divinely intended pattern that anticipates a greater reality in Christ.

4. Analogy

A theological principle in the text is more fully realized in Christ or the gospel.

Routes 5-7

The other three routes

5. Longitudinal themes

A theme is traced across the whole canon and arrives at Christ as its culmination.

6. New Testament references

A New Testament text quotes or applies an Old Testament passage to Christ, and the preacher follows it.

7. Contrast

The text shows an inadequate provision or a failed deliverer, and the gospel exceeds what it left wanting.

Key distinction

Typology is not allegory

Allegory treats the details of a text as symbols for spiritual truths by a code the interpreter supplies. The lecture's example is reading the two coins left by the Good Samaritan as two sacraments, a reading many careful interpreters reject. Typology keeps the original event's plain meaning fully intact. It adds a warranted claim that the event was divinely patterned to anticipate a greater fulfillment. That claim must come from the text's own indicators or an explicit New Testament warrant.

Key idea Greidanus insists that the difference matters.
The test

Four questions for any route

Naming a route is not enough, because any route could be applied to any text. Greidanus asks four questions. Does the connection arise from the text's own content, or is it supplied from outside? Is there a textual or canonical indicator that it was intended? Does it respect the text's genre and its original meaning for its first hearers? Would the same reasoning, forced onto an unrelated text, give an obviously illegitimate result?

Key idea A route to Christ has to be argued, not merely announced.
Scripture

Why John 3:14-15?

The lecture works through this text as a case that meets Greidanus's criteria cleanly. Jesus himself uses the verb "lifted up" for both the bronze serpent and his own coming crucifixion.

As Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of Man be lifted up, that whoever believes in him should not perish, but have eternal life.
Worked case

The bronze serpent as typology

The bronze serpent (Numbers 21:4-9) is a real historical provision with its own complete function. Israel did not need to understand Christ to be healed by looking at it. Its status as a type is not the preacher's inference, because Jesus states the connection with an explicit likeness. The lecture says it meets the first three criteria without strain.

Key idea This is the kind of case defenders cite to show the method is disciplined.
Think about it

Same criteria, different results

The criteria do not guarantee that two careful readers will agree.

Can you imagine two careful preachers applying these same criteria and reaching different conclusions about the same text? What would the disagreement actually be about?

Recap

What to carry forward

Greidanus names seven routes from an Old Testament text to Christ and gives criteria to test each one. Typology keeps the original meaning and adds a warranted claim, while allegory supplies a code. The criteria do not make careful readers always agree. When you say "this points to Jesus," be able to say which route you mean and what in Scripture itself warrants it.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12