Lecture 7-4: The Exemplary Tradition, Its Critics, and the Dutch Controversy
Two real traditions, each with a serious case
Advanced Expository Preaching
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Two real traditions, each with a serious case
Advanced Expository Preaching
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
For most of Christian history, Old Testament narrative was preached as example. David facing Goliath showed courageous trust in God. Joseph resisting Potiphar's wife showed resisting temptation. Daniel in the lions' den showed prayerful integrity. Such sermons did not need an explicit statement about Christ to be complete. This way of preaching has deep roots in patristic, medieval and Puritan preaching, and it is still common today.
Hebrews 11 lists Old Testament figures such as Abel, Noah, Abraham and Rahab, commended for their faith and presented as examples. No step through Christ is required first. James 5:17 holds up Elijah's prayer life directly as a pattern. A preacher in this tradition can ask why a way of reading that Scripture itself repeatedly uses should be called deficient.
This is the lecture's text. The reflection questions point out that David names "the name of Yahweh of Armies," not his own skill, as the ground of his confidence.
Then David said to the Philistine, "You come to me with a sword, and with a spear, and with a javelin: but I come to you in the name of Yahweh of Armies, the God of the armies of Israel, whom you have defied.
The critique is narrow. Finding examples in Scripture is not illegitimate, because Hebrews 11 shows that. The worry is about exemplary preaching used as the only or main mode. It risks moralism, a sermon that is bare moral exhortation, detached from grace. It can also be preached without needing Christ at all, so that any moral teacher of any religion could give it.
First, in the hands of a less careful preacher it can force a Christ-connection onto a text that does not invite one. Second, a rule that every sermon must reach Christ can produce a predictable shape: text, pivot, Christ. Third, it assumes free sermon-by-sermon preaching. Many Catholic and Orthodox traditions preach within a lectionary, where the liturgy already supplies a Christ-centered frame.
Old Testament figures preached directly as models. Rooted in Hebrews 11 and James 5:17. Risk named by critics: moralism.
Every sermon reaches a warranted connection to Christ. Rooted in Vos, Clowney and Greidanus. Risks named by critics: forced links and a formulaic shape.
The same argument was fought within Dutch Reformed church life under older labels. Exemplary preaching was opposed by church-historical preaching, the Dutch counterpart of the redemptive-historical approach. Defenders of the exemplary side replied that Scripture's own use of examples could not be set aside. They also said that a rigid church-historical rule risked its own flattening.
In 1 Samuel 17:45 David names the name of Yahweh as the ground of his confidence, not his own skill.
Does this detail strengthen or complicate a purely exemplary reading of the passage, "be brave like David"? Explain.
Both sides have real concerns. Scripture itself commends imitation of its figures, and the redemptive-historical tradition guards against a sermon that needs no gospel. The lecture does not say either side is a caricature or has won. Know what your own approach protects and what it risks, whether that is moralism or a forced Christ-connection.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.