FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT701E · Chapter 7

Lecture 7-5: Where Faithful Preachers Disagree, and What to Do About It

Faithful preachers disagree, and you can still preach well

Advanced Expository Preaching

12 cards 15 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State plainly, without resolving it, where confessionally Reformed preaching and a range of other faithful traditions diverge on this question, and why.
  • Explain how a lectionary structure changes what a single sermon needs to accomplish on its own.
  • Identify what is genuinely at stake in the disagreement (what each side is protecting) rather than treating it as a matter of preference.
  • State a working, personally examined position on this question that you can defend, including honestly naming what your own position risks getting wrong.
Not resolved

A point where readers will not agree

This lecture does not resolve the disagreement. Confessionally Reformed preachers, in the line of Vos, Clowney and Greidanus, tend to treat Christ-centered preaching as the standard for a sound sermon on any text. Other evangelical, Pentecostal and charismatic preachers, and many Catholic and Orthodox preachers, preach Old Testament figures more directly. Both positions are held by careful, orthodox, textually serious preachers.

Key idea The lecture's task is to equip you to preach responsibly in either setting.
Lectionary

Why a lectionary changes the task

A lectionary is a fixed cycle of readings tied to the church's calendar. In it the connection to Christ is supplied by the liturgy as a whole, not by each sermon alone. The church year, the pairing of an Old Testament reading with a Gospel reading, the creed and the eucharist all do theological work. So judging such a sermon by "did it, by itself, reach Christ" can misjudge what it was meant to do.

Key idea The text arrives already embedded in a service.
Scripture

Why Matthew 2:15?

This is the lecture's text. Matthew reads Hosea 11:1, which in its own setting speaks of Israel's exodus from Egypt, as fulfilled in the infant Jesus. The lecture uses it as a hard case that tests both positions.

and was there until the death of Herod; that it might be fulfilled which was spoken by the Lord through the prophet, saying, "Out of Egypt I called my son.
At a glance

What each side protects

Redemptive-historical tradition

Protects the New Testament's own repeated reading of the Old Testament as pointing to Christ, seen in Luke 24:27, John 3:14-15 and Matthew 2:15. Risk: a forced connection and a predictable shape.

Exemplary and lectionary traditions

Protect Scripture's own commending of its figures as examples, and the liturgy's Christ-centered structure. Risk: moralism, a sermon any moral teacher could give.

A hard case

Matthew 2:15 tests both positions

Hosea 11:1 reads, in its own context, as a statement about God's past deliverance of Israel from Egypt. Matthew applies it to the infant Jesus. A redemptive-historical preacher sees here the New Testament author himself linking Israel's story and Jesus's story. A critic notes that Matthew's move is bolder than the bronze serpent of lecture 7-3. A preacher without Matthew's apostolic authority who made an equally bold move elsewhere would take real risk.

Key idea Both observations are true at once.
Working position

Hold a position and name its risk

You may leave the chapter with a position, though not one this course dictates. A good position names its own risk. The redemptive-historical risk is a forced connection and a predictable shape. The exemplary or lectionary risk is moralism. Neither tradition has to be abandoned, but each should be practiced self-critically.

Key idea You can reduce your tradition's characteristic risk, though not remove it.
Practice

How each preacher guards the risk

A redemptive-historical preacher can apply Greidanus's criteria honestly, even to a text where no clean route to Christ exists. They can also vary the route instead of repeating one formula. An exemplary preacher can name what makes a call to imitate David's courage a Christian exhortation. That might be the grace that precedes and enables the imitation, or the fact that the same David later failed badly.

Key idea Each discipline asks for self-criticism, not a change of tradition.
Think about it

Your own position

The lecture says a working position should name the specific risk it carries.

What is your current working position on this chapter's debate? What risk does it carry, and what practice could guard against that risk in your preaching?

Recap

What to carry forward

Both positions are held by careful, orthodox preachers, and each protects something real. A lectionary changes what a single sermon must accomplish on its own. Matthew 2:15 supports the redemptive-historical method and also warns of the boldness involved. Practice your own tradition self-critically, and apply real tests to any claimed link to Christ.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12