FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT702E · Chapter 9

Lecture 9-3: Mediating a Dispute as an Administrative Leader

A mediator does not announce who is right. A mediator helps two people find a resolution they can both live with.

Church Administration and Leadership

12 cards 12 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain why an administrative leader mediating a dispute is functioning differently from a judge issuing a ruling.
  • Describe the practice of hearing each party separately before bringing them together, and explain what it accomplishes that a joint meeting alone does not.
  • Distinguish a dispute's presenting issue from its underlying issue, with a concrete example.
  • Describe what makes a mediated resolution durable rather than merely a temporary truce.
The gap

Mediation is its own skill

A congregation may agree that internal resolution is better than litigation and still have no one equipped to do the resolving. Mediation is a distinct skill from preaching a resolution at people or presiding over a formal discipline process. A mediator's job is not to determine who is right and announce a verdict.

Key idea The goal is a resolution the two parties can actually live with.
Scripture

Why Philippians 4:2?

The lecture says Paul names two women and exhorts each of them directly. He repeats "I exhort" for each, treating them as equally responsible for the resolution rather than assigning blame to one.

I exhort Euodia, and I exhort Syntyche, to think the same way in the Lord.
Scripture

Why Philippians 4:3?

The lecture says Paul asks an unnamed "true partner" to help the two women reconcile. He does not resolve the dispute himself from a distance. The lecture reads this as a leader empowering a trusted person's present involvement.

Yes, I beg you also, true partner, help these women, for they labored with me in the Good News, with Clement also, and the rest of my fellow workers, whose names are in the book of life.
Step one

Hear each side separately first

Meeting each party separately lets each person state their concern fully, including emotion they might suppress in front of the other. It gives the mediator time to identify each side's actual concerns. It often shows that the two accounts differ so much that a joint meeting held too early would only relitigate facts. Ask not only what happened but what each person needs to move forward.

Key idea That question often surfaces something more specific and more solvable.
At a glance

Two kinds of issue

Presenting issue

The specific, immediate thing being argued about, such as which ministry gets a larger share of the budget.

Underlying issue

The actual source of the friction, such as a long-standing feeling that one ministry's contribution was never acknowledged.

Durable or not

A truce versus a resolution

A mediator who resolves only the presenting issue has usually purchased a short truce. The same tension will resurface in a new form. Naming the underlying issue does not always mean solving it in one conversation. A mediator should listen for grudging language such as "fine, whatever you want," which is a warning sign, not a resolution.

Key idea Slow the process down rather than closing with an agreement that will not hold.
A limit

What mediation is not for

A dispute over resources, roles or hurt feelings between two people acting in good faith suits mediation. An allegation of serious misconduct does not. It may call for the formal discipline process or an outside referral. Treating every conflict as a mediation risks pressuring a wronged party to meet in the middle with someone who should face a formal process.

Key idea Real power imbalance or a credible allegation of serious harm is not a mediation situation.
Think about it

A recent conflict

A conflict over a hymn may carry an unspoken disagreement about who has creative authority over worship.

Think of a recent disagreement in your church. What was the presenting issue, and what might the underlying issue have been?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

A mediator helps people move toward each other and does not issue a verdict. Hear each person separately, look for the underlying issue, and aim for a resolution both can genuinely live with. Mediation is not the right tool for credible allegations of serious misconduct.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12