FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT704E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-2: Why Young Adults Raised in the Church Disengage

Young adults who left church were asked why. Their own answers point to church culture and formation, not only a hostile world.

Ministry Across Generations: Theology and Practice

11 cards 13 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Summarize the purpose and method of Kinnaman's You Lost Me research.
  • Name and explain at least four of Kinnaman's reported reasons young adults raised in church disengage in their twenties.
  • Distinguish a diagnostic reading of this research from a dismissive one that treats disengagement as simple faithlessness.
  • Identify at least one named reason with direct implications for how a congregation ordinarily treats a young adult's doubts or questions.
The research

Asking the ones who left

David Kinnaman's book You Lost Me used Barna Group surveys of young adults who had attended a Protestant church regularly as teenagers. Church leaders, he said, had mostly diagnosed the problem from outside. They assumed a hostile culture, a lack of commitment, or moral failure. His aim was to ask the young adults who left to name their own reasons. The answers fell into six categories and were more specific than "the culture won."

Key idea The reasons came from the people who left, not from guesses about them.
At a glance

Three of the six reasons

Overprotective

The world was treated as a danger to shield from, not a place to prepare for. Young adults found the shielding had left them unready.

Shallow

Faith was emotionally engaging but thin, with too little biblical or theological substance to meet a hard question.

Anti-science

A perceived posture that science and faith are at odds, met for the first time as a real tension at university.

At a glance

The other three reasons

Repressive

A list of prohibitions, especially around sexuality, instead of a positive vision, so some felt they had to leave to deal with a struggle honestly.

Exclusive

A culture seen as unwelcoming to outsiders or to the young adult's friends of other faiths or none.

Doubtless

Doubt was treated as a danger sign, so a young adult had no safe place to bring a real question.

Scripture

Why 2 Timothy 1:5?

The lecture notes Paul writes "I am persuaded," a considered judgment about a living person, not a guaranteed outcome. A faith raised across two generations still had to become Timothy's own, and the language leaves room for the fact that it might not have.

having been reminded of the sincere faith that is in you; which lived first in your grandmother Lois, and your mother Eunice, and, I am persuaded, in you also.
How to read it

Diagnosis, not indictment

The lecture says it would be a misuse to treat the six reasons as an indictment of every congregation, or as proof that leaving is always the church's fault. They are the reasons respondents most often named, which makes them patterns a congregation can examine in itself. A young adult can also disengage for reasons the research does not capture, such as a change of conviction, a personal grievance, or drifting attention in a demanding season.

Key idea Use it to examine your own church, not to blame every church or every case.
What can change

Choices a congregation makes

The lecture says the comfortable alternative, that the world simply does this to young people, is ruled out. Shallow, anti-science and doubtless point at choices a church can change. These are how much substance is taught and not only experienced, whether questions about science and faith are engaged, and whether doubt is met with curiosity or alarm. The lecture links the doubtless finding to its earlier discussion of doubt as a possible passage toward an owned faith.

Key idea Several of the reasons point at formation choices, not at the outside world.
Think about it

Does it transfer?

Kinnaman's data came from American Protestant young adults. The lecture says the overall pattern transfers more easily than any one category, such as anti-science.

Which of the six reasons might look different in your own setting, and what might be your local flashpoint?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Young adults most often named church-culture reasons: overprotective, shallow, anti-science, repressive, exclusive and doubtless. These are a diagnosis to examine, not a complete account of every case. Before blaming the world outside, ask what your own teaching and culture have given young adults to face hard questions.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11