FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

PT705E · Chapter 11

Lecture 11-2: Matthew 18 and the Discipline of Confrontation

Matthew 18 and conflict with a leader

Christian Leadership: Theology, Character, and Practice

11 cards 11 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the three (or four, counting the assembly's decision) stages of Matthew 18:15-17's procedure in order.
  • Explain why skipping the required private step (v. 15) is a misapplication, even when the offense feels serious enough to justify going straight to a group confrontation.
  • Explain why using verse 17's later stages to justify public shaming, rather than the specific, limited process the text describes, is also a misapplication.
  • Apply the procedure to a leadership-specific case: what changes, and what does not, when the person being confronted holds authority over the person confronting them.
The passage

Often used, often misapplied

Matthew 18:15-17 is cited often as a rule for biblical conflict resolution. This lecture says it is misapplied in two opposite directions: its first step is skipped, and its later stages are stretched into public exposure. It also applies the passage to conflict involving a leader.

Key idea Read it carefully before applying it.
The procedure

Four stages in order

Stage one is a private talk between two people. Stage two adds one or two witnesses, echoing Deuteronomy 19:15, so the truth is established fairly and not to gather allies. Stage three is the assembly. Stage four treats continued refusal as being like a Gentile or a tax collector. Each stage is entered only if the one before fails.

Key idea The escalation itself is the point.
Fourth stage

A change in standing, aimed at restoration

In Matthew, Jesus eats with tax collectors and reaches toward Gentiles, so this language does not mean contempt or no contact. It means a formal change in the person's standing until repentance. The goal named at the start is to gain back a brother, not to humiliate.

Key idea The aim is a brother regained.
Misuse one

Skipping the private step

A person hurt by someone in authority may think the offense is too serious, or the power gap too great, for a private talk. They go to a board or air it publicly. The text's ordering protects the accused from public exposure over something that may be resolved, misunderstood or false.

Key idea Going privately first is the text's normal first move.
Misuse two

Stretching into public shaming

Some use verse 17 to justify posting on social media or announcing from a pulpit without the earlier stages. But "the assembly" is the gathered church after a specific failed process, not any audience convenient to the accuser. Using the conclusion without the work before it is a misuse.

Key idea Do not use the last step without the first.
When a leader is confronted

The harder case

A leader approached privately has the same duty to listen as anyone. A leader who dismisses or retaliates makes stage one unsafe, and that pushes people toward premature escalation. A church where people fear approaching leaders privately shows stage one has already failed.

Key idea Make it safe to come to you.
Two misuses

Opposite errors

Skipping step one

Going straight to a board or the public because the offense feels serious.

Stretching step four

Using verse 17 as permission for public shaming that the text never describes.

Recap

Safe and orderly

The stages of Matthew 18:15-17 come in order, each depending on the failure of the last, and the aim is to regain a brother. Do not skip the private step and do not use later steps for public exposure. Make it safe for people to come to you privately, and listen when they do.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11