FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST1E · Chapter 1

Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Proper Comes First

Most of the tradition begins with the doctrine of God; Karl Barth argued it should begin with God's revelation in Christ.

Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God

13 cards 15 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State what "theology proper" means and how it differs from theology in the broad sense.
  • Explain the traditional rationale, shared by Aquinas and Calvin, for treating the doctrine of God as the foundation the rest of systematic theology is built on.
  • Summarize Karl Barth's central objection to that traditional ordering and why he proposed beginning with Christology instead.
  • Identify at least one cost each approach risks if taken to an extreme.
Definition

What "theology proper" names

"Theology," used broadly, names the whole enterprise of organized Christian doctrine. "Theology proper" is the traditional name for one locus within it: the doctrine of God himself, considered in his being, attributes, and triune life. Get this locus wrong, and Christology, soteriology, and ecclesiology inherit the error.

Key idea Every other doctrine is downstream of what is said here.
Scripture

Why Jeremiah 9:23-24?

The lecture uses this verse to say that knowing Yahweh is the one thing worth glorying in, and that the knowledge is of a God who acts with loving kindness, justice, and righteousness.

Thus says Yahweh, 'Don't let the wise man glory in his wisdom. Don't let the mighty man glory in his might. Don't let the rich man glory in his riches. But let him who glories glory in this, that he has understanding, and knows me, that I am Yahweh who exercises loving kindness, justice, and righteousness, in the earth, for I delight in these things,' says Yahweh." Jeremiah 9:23-24 · World English Bible
Traditional case

Aquinas starts with God

Thomas Aquinas's Summa Theologiae opens its systematic exposition with a sustained treatment of God before creation, humanity, or Christ enter the discussion. His rationale is architectural: sacred doctrine is a single science unified by its formal object, which is God himself. Everything else is studied as it relates to God.

Key idea God is first because he supplies the standard for everything else.
Traditional case

Calvin reaches a similar start

John Calvin opens the Institutes by arguing that true wisdom consists of the knowledge of God and the knowledge of ourselves, and that these cannot be pulled apart. His underlying conviction matches Aquinas's: no other doctrine can be rightly understood until this one is in view. A theology that pictures God as an exacting judge will describe sin, grace, and the cross differently than one that pictures God as a wounded lover seeking reconciliation.

Key idea A wrong picture of God distorts the picture of everything else.
Barth's objection

Begin with revelation in Christ

Karl Barth argued that a doctrine of God reached independently of God's self-revelation in Jesus Christ is built from human reason, religious feeling, or inferences from the created order. Such constructions have a documented history of producing gods who look like their makers' cultural assumptions. So theology must let God's self-disclosure in Christ set the terms from the beginning.

Key idea Barth wants Christ to govern the doctrine of God from its first sentence.
Precision

What Barth is not objecting to

Barth is not denying that theology should talk about God's being, attributes, or triune life; the Church Dogmatics does this at enormous length. He is objecting to the method by which the tradition arrived at that content. His proposal is not "skip the doctrine of God" but "let Christ govern the doctrine of God."

Key idea The dispute is about method, not about whether to discuss God's being.
Where readers differ

Two ways of ordering theology

Classical ordering

Aquinas, Calvin, and confessional Reformed and Catholic traditions hold that much can be established about God through reflection on general revelation and Scripture before a developed Christology.

Barthian ordering

Barth and those influenced by him worry that this order risks an idol: a God constructed by unaided reason that revelation is then asked to accommodate.

Risks

What each approach risks

The traditional ordering

It risks a doctrine of God that reads more like philosophical theism than like the God of Israel and the church.

Barth's ordering

Its critics say it risks making it harder to speak of God's eternal being and attributes apart from the economy of salvation.

Think about it

Culture or revelation?

Barth worries that a doctrine of God can become a human projection.

Can you think of an example, from any tradition including your own, where a doctrine of God seems shaped more by cultural assumptions than by revelation?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Where theology starts shapes everything after it. Aquinas and Calvin start with God; Barth lets God's revelation in Christ govern the doctrine of God from the beginning. The course follows the traditional order but does not call it beyond dispute.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13