FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST1E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-1: Can God's Existence Be Proved? Setting the Terms

Before any argument for God's existence, ask what a proof would be and whether Christians agree it is worth attempting.

Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God

13 cards 21 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Distinguish "proof" in the sense of deductive certainty from "proof" in the sense of a cumulative case built from reasonable premises, and explain why conflating the two produces both overconfident defenses of the arguments and dismissals that miss their actual claim.
  • State Aquinas's rationale for pursuing natural theology (arguments for God available to unaided reason) and locate it within his larger theological project.
  • State Kierkegaard's objection to natural theology as a category, distinguishing it from a claim that the arguments are merely logically flawed.
  • Explain Plantinga's "properly basic belief" alternative and why it changes what a critic of theism would need to show.
Setting the terms

What a proof of God would need to be

A mathematical proof is a sequence of statements each following necessarily from what came before. Almost no one who has seriously defended an argument for God's existence has claimed that kind of proof. They claim something closer to a good historical argument or strong scientific case: premises a reasonable inquirer could accept, producing a conclusion more reasonable to accept than to reject.

Key idea Expecting geometric certainty produces overconfidence and dismissal alike.
Scripture

Why Psalm 14:1?

The lecture uses this verse because it calls the denial of God folly, a moral and spiritual disorder, which makes the reader cautious about treating the chapter as a neutral philosophy seminar.

The fool has said in his heart, “There is no God.” They are corrupt. They have done abominable works. There is no one who does good." Psalm 14:1 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why Hebrews 11:6?

The lecture uses this verse because it says that whoever comes to God must believe that he exists, which uses the ordinary language of belief formed on reasons.

Without faith it is impossible to be well pleasing to him, for he who comes to God must believe that he exists, and that he is a rewarder of those who seek him." Hebrews 11:6 · WEB
Cumulative case

The right posture toward the arguments

The right posture toward each argument in Lectures 2-2 through 2-4 is neither "this proves God with mathematical certainty" nor "this proves nothing." It is closer to a cumulative case, where several independently reasonable arguments, none individually conclusive, together make theism more reasonable than its alternatives. Whether that case is enough, and for whom, remains contested.

Key idea An objection can lower an argument's force without refuting it.
Aquinas

Reason can go a considerable distance

Thomas Aquinas distinguished truths reason can establish, such as that God exists, is one, and is the first cause, from truths available only by revelation, chiefly the Trinity and the Incarnation. His five ways were offered to show that faith is not irrational, because God is the author of both nature and Scripture. Calvin also affirmed a real, if limited, natural knowledge of God, so this is not simply a Catholic versus Protestant dispute.

Key idea The dispute is how far natural knowledge can be pressed into a formal argument.
Kierkegaard

Proof as a way of avoiding the leap

Søren Kierkegaard's objection is not that the arguments contain logical errors. He says that seeking a proof treats God as an item in the world whose existence could be settled by enough evidence. Coming to faith is instead a decision, a leap made in the face of objective uncertainty, involving will and passion as well as intellect. A flawless argument would be answering the wrong kind of question.

Key idea A successful proof would short-circuit what faith requires.
Plantinga

Belief in God as properly basic

Alvin Plantinga argues that belief in God can be properly basic: formed directly by a properly functioning cognitive faculty, like belief in other minds or trust in one's memory. Following Calvin, he points to a sensus divinitatis, a God-given faculty producing awareness of God. If he is right, the atheist cannot simply demand an argument on pain of irrationality, but must show that theistic belief is not properly basic.

Key idea Proof was never required for belief in God to be rational.
Where readers differ

Four positions on natural theology

Aquinas

Unaided reason can establish significant truths about God, including his existence.

Kierkegaard

The project of proof misdescribes what faith is.

Plantinga

The project is not misguided, but it is unnecessary for rational belief.

Van Til (Lecture 2-5)

There is no religiously neutral standpoint from which such an argument could be assessed.

Think about it

What would count as enough?

The lecture says a cumulative case may be reasonable without being conclusive.

Which of the four positions best matches how you came to believe, or not believe, in God?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Arguments for God's existence are offered as cumulative cases, not mathematical proofs. Aquinas, Kierkegaard, Plantinga and Van Til give four serious Christian answers on whether and how to argue. This lecture does not choose among them; it helps you tell them apart.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13