Thomas Aquinas distinguished truths reason can establish, such as that God exists, is one, and is the first cause, from truths available only by revelation, chiefly the Trinity and the Incarnation. His five ways were offered to show that faith is not irrational, because God is the author of both nature and Scripture. Calvin also affirmed a real, if limited, natural knowledge of God, so this is not simply a Catholic versus Protestant dispute.
Key idea The dispute is how far natural knowledge can be pressed into a formal argument.