Lecture 3-3: Immutability and Impassibility
God does not change in his being, and the heaviest challenge to that claim comes from the cross.
Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
God does not change in his being, and the heaviest challenge to that claim comes from the cross.
Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Classical theology has never claimed that nothing about God's relationship to the world changes, since creation, the exodus and the incarnation all happen in time. What immutability denies is that God's own being, character, knowledge or will changes. God does not learn something new or shift from one purpose to another. The change is located on the creaturely side: the world moves into new relations with an unchanging God.
The lecture uses this verse because immutability functions here as the ground of covenant reliability: Israel's unfaithfulness does not provoke Yahweh into abandoning the covenant, so his promises can be trusted.
For I, Yahweh, don't change; therefore you, sons of Jacob, are not consumed." Malachi 3:6 · World English Bible
The lecture uses this verse because its image of no variation or turning shadow says that the light and goodness from God do not flicker or dim the way created light sources do.
Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights, with whom can be no variation, nor turning shadow." James 1:17 · WEB
If God is simple, there is no substrate in God that could persist through a change while some accidental feature is altered. Aquinas's technical term is actus purus, pure actuality, which admits no unrealized potential. If God is a se, nothing external can act upon him to produce a change he did not already will. Immutability is a further unpacking of what simplicity and aseity already imply.
Impassibility narrows the focus to emotional or experiential change, especially suffering imposed on a subject by something outside its control. Classical theology denies this of God because nothing outside himself has that kind of power over him. The doctrine does not say God is indifferent. The tradition affirms that God loves, grieves over sin and delights in his creatures.
What impassibility denies is that God's loving and grieving are states he is passively caused to undergo, the way human grief is often inflicted by circumstance. On the classical reading, divine grief is a free, willed expression of God's unchanging character responding rightly to sin. It is not evidence that something external reached in and altered God's being.
The most serious contemporary challenge argues that if God the Son genuinely suffered and died, and the cross discloses who God is, then ruling out suffering in principle seems to deny the heart of the gospel. Jürgen Moltmann developed this at length after his experience as a prisoner of war. The lecture calls it a serious attempt to say that a God untouched by the cross is not a God worth trusting.
The person of the Son suffered, through the communication of properties, but the suffering is proper to Christ's assumed human nature. The divine nature did not acquire a capacity for suffering. Thomas Weinandy's Does God Suffer? is one full modern defense.
The distinction is an evasion, a way of saying God suffered while meaning only the human nature did. They propose a genuinely passible divine nature, which defenders of impassibility call a real revision of God's perfection.
Both positions are stated at their strongest and the lecture does not name a winner.
Which part of each position do you find most persuasive, and what would you want the other side to explain?
Immutability says God's own being, character and will do not change, which grounds trust in his promises. Impassibility says nothing outside him can make him suffer, without making him indifferent. The cross is the main challenge, and the lecture presents both answers without choosing.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.