FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST1E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-4: Infinity, Eternity, and God's Relation to Time

Is God outside time or everlasting within it? Both positions are held by serious, Scripture-affirming theologians.

Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God

13 cards 15 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the classical (Boethian/Thomistic) doctrine of timeless eternity and explain the "eternal now" concept.
  • State the everlasting-God alternative and the philosophical concerns that motivate it.
  • Explain at least one argument on each side of this debate, and identify what would have to be true about the nature of time itself for each position to be coherent.
  • Explain why this question is not merely academic, by naming one further doctrine (elsewhere in this course) that depends on how it is answered.
The question

God and time

The classical answer is that God is infinite, unbounded by the limitations of finite, created reality. This lecture focuses that claim on eternity, where the classical view and a serious contemporary alternative diverge. The lecture argues the question is not an idle puzzle. The answer changes what can be said about God's knowledge of the future, his response to prayer, and how the incarnation relates to his eternal nature.

Key idea Two positions answer the question differently.
Scripture

Why Psalm 90:2?

The lecture uses this verse as the strongest Old Testament statement of God's priority to creation. It notes that both the timeless and the everlasting positions can read it as support.

Before the mountains were born, before you had formed the earth and the world, even from everlasting to everlasting, you are God." Psalm 90:2 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why 2 Peter 3:8?

The lecture notes that defenders of timeless eternity often cite this verse, though it can also be read simply as a statement about God's patience. The lecture treats both texts as underdetermining the philosophical debate.

But don't forget this one thing, beloved, that one day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day." 2 Peter 3:8 · WEB
Classical view

Timeless eternity

Boethius defined eternity as the whole, simultaneous and perfect possession of unending life. The key word is simultaneous: God does not live through a sequence of moments, and everything true of him is present to him at once. Aquinas develops this as a consequence of God being simple and immutable. He cannot pass through changing temporal states.

Key idea God exists outside time, in a single undivided now.
Eternal now

All moments present at once

On this view every moment of history, from Abraham's call to the crucifixion to the end of history, is equally present to God. The lecture compares this to an author's relation to the events of a novel. Boethius used the framework on foreknowledge and freedom. If God does not foreknow anything but knows all of history in one eternal act, the puzzle dissolves, because knowing is not the same as causing.

Key idea Boethius used the eternal now to address foreknowledge and freedom.
Contemporary alternative

Everlasting through time

Philosophers such as Nicholas Wolterstorff hold that God is everlasting: he exists at every time, genuinely experiencing succession, with neither beginning nor end. They argue that timeless eternity makes it hard to understand God doing one thing and then another, such as hearing a prayer and then answering it. Divine response risks becoming a manner of speaking. On this view eternity is limitless duration, not the absence of duration.

Key idea The motive is to take God's responsiveness to history seriously.
At a glance

Timeless or in time?

Timelessly eternal

God exists entirely outside time with no past, present or future, only a single undivided now. Boethius's solution on foreknowledge and freedom is available in something like its original form.

Everlasting

God exists at every time, without beginning or end, within a real temporal sequence. The Boethian solution is not available in the same way, so another account of foreknowledge is needed.

What is at stake

A live disagreement among conservatives

The lecture says advocates on both sides are conservative, Scripture-affirming theologians. It is not a dispute between orthodoxy and its critics, but a disagreement about how best to understand a biblical claim that Scripture asserts without spelling out its metaphysics. The course states both positions and does not name a winner.

Key idea Scripture asserts God's eternity without fixing its metaphysics.
Think about it

Prayer and time

The lecture notes that a timeless God's response to a prayer offered at noon can look like an eternal decree that lines up with events in time.

Does that description fit how you understand God answering prayer, or does it feel too distant?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The classical view says God is timelessly eternal, with everything present to him in one undivided now. The alternative says God is everlasting, living through time without beginning or end. Both are held by conservative theologians, and the choice affects foreknowledge, prayer and the incarnation.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13