FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST2E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-6: The Extra Calvinisticum

The Reformed doctrine says the Son's divine nature is not confined by his human nature; Lutherans raise a serious objection.

Systematic Theology II: Christology

10 cards 14 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the extra Calvinisticum precisely: the Son's divine nature is not exhaustively contained within the human nature, and continues its universal sustaining work even during the incarnation.
  • Explain the doctrine's connection to the Son's infinity as established in ST1's doctrine of God.
  • State the Lutheran objection (that this seems to compromise the fullness of the personal union) accurately and fairly.
  • State the Reformed reply and explain why Reformed theologians consider it a necessary consequence of divine infinity rather than an optional add-on.
  • Connect this lecture's doctrine forward to the "whereabouts of the humanity" question Chapter 6 raises about the ascension.
The doctrine

Extra carnem, beyond the flesh

Later Lutheran writers named this teaching the extra Calvinisticum, though the Reformed hold the claim is neither novel to Calvin nor exclusively his. The eternal Son, even during the incarnation, remains also beyond the flesh, sustaining and governing the whole universe in his divine nature. He is not exhaustively contained within the human nature he assumed. This is one person, not two Christs.

Key idea One person whose divine activity is not exhausted by his human location.
Scripture

Why Colossians 1:17?

The lecture uses this verse because Paul writes in the present tense about the same Christ who has already been incarnate, crucified and raised. "In him all things are held together" describes an ongoing sustaining work that a body confined to one place could not do on its own.

He is before all things, and in him all things are held together." Colossians 1:17 · World English Bible
Grounding

Colossians and John 3:13

Since Paul writes of the Christ who has already lived, died and risen, the sustaining work cannot be something the incarnation interrupted. Reformed theologians pair this with John 3:13, where the Son of Man "who is in heaven" speaks while standing on earth before Nicodemus. They read both as support for a Son whose divine presence is not exhausted by his human nature's location.

Key idea The incarnation did not halt his cosmic work.
Lutheran objection

Does "extra" make the union partial?

Lutheran theologians ask whether a divine nature that remains beyond the human nature compromises the fullness of the personal union. The concern is that "extra" language suggests some remainder of the Son stands apart from the human nature he assumed. The lecture ties this to the genus majestaticum: if the human nature shares divine majesty, there is no need for a remaining "extra."

Key idea The objection is serious, not dismissive.
Reformed reply

A consequence of infinity

The Reformed reply is that the doctrine is a necessary consequence of the Son's own infinity, already fixed in the doctrine of God, and not a sign of a deficient union. An infinite nature cannot be exhaustively contained by a finite one. On this reading the Lutheran view is under more strain, since it asks the human nature to acquire a property that Lecture 3-2's portrait of an ordinary human nature does not obviously support.

Key idea The union is complete without either nature acquiring what it is not.
What each fears

Two serious worries

Lutheran worry

That the extra Calvinisticum, whatever the Reformed intend, risks sounding as if something of the Son is held back from the incarnation.

Reformed worry

That denying it requires giving a genuinely human nature a capacity, ubiquity, that no human nature has on the biblical evidence of Lecture 3-2.

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The Reformed hold that Christ keeps his universal sustaining work in his divine nature while his human nature is finite and local, and that this does not mean two persons. Lutherans fear it holds something back, and the lecture says the question is not settled. State a tradition's doctrine with its strongest objection beside it.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 10