FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST2E · Chapter 8

Lecture 8-1: The Quest for the Historical Jesus and Neo-Orthodoxy's Reply

The quest for the historical Jesus rested on a philosophical assumption, and Karl Barth answered it by starting from God's self-revelation in Christ.

Systematic Theology II: Christology

11 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State what the nineteenth-century "quest for the historical Jesus" was attempting, and name Adolf von Harnack as a representative figure of its mature, popular form.
  • Explain the genuine historical-critical concern behind the quest (that not everything the Gospels report may be intended, or received, as literal historical narration in every genre) without conceding its naturalistic starting assumption.
  • State Karl Barth's central objection to liberal theology's method and summarize what a "christocentric" starting point means in his usage.
  • Identify at least one limitation of Barth's own approach from a classical evangelical perspective, without treating neo-orthodoxy as though it simply restored confessional orthodoxy.
The quest

Recovering the Jesus of history

By the mid-nineteenth century, scholars applied to the Gospels the tools used on other ancient texts, such as source analysis and attention to genre. Adolf von Harnack, whose 1900 lectures became the movement's best-known popular statement, argued that the Gospels are already theological documents. The task was to peel back that later layer and recover what Jesus said and did before the church's confession was formed.

Key idea The quest tried to recover Jesus from beneath later doctrine.
Harnack's Jesus

A moral teacher, not a divine claimant

Harnack's Jesus preached the fatherhood of God, the infinite value of the human soul and a this-worldly ethic of love. On this reading he did not claim deity for himself, institute the church's sacraments in their later form, or rise bodily from the dead. Those claims belonged to the church's later theologising.

Key idea The Jesus the quest found was shaped by what it allowed itself to find.
Fair hearing

The concern is genuine

The Gospels were written by believing communities, decades after the events, to produce faith, as John says of his own Gospel (John 20:31). Recognising that they are theologically interested documents is accurate description, not a liberal invention. A course that dismissed historical-critical method wholesale would be refusing to engage the question.

Key idea Honest historical questions deserve honest answers.
The overreach

A premise, not a finding

The quest overreaches at a step that looks methodological but is philosophical: assuming before any evidence that a miracle, a bodily resurrection or an explicit claim to deity could not have occurred. This comes from post-Enlightenment naturalism, not from the Gospel texts. Once it is granted, the quest cannot fail to find a merely human Jesus. Albert Schweitzer argued that liberal portraits mostly reproduced their authors' own ideals.

Key idea Ruling out the miraculous in advance is a philosophical move.
Scripture

Why Luke 24:27?

The lecture uses this verse because on the Emmaus road Jesus begins with a claim about reading. Rightly read, Moses and the prophets already spoke of him, which raises the question of whether the church's framework is a later addition or the Bible's own claim about its subject.

Beginning from Moses and from all the prophets, he explained to them in all the Scriptures the things concerning himself." Luke 24:27 · World English Bible
Karl Barth

A christocentric starting point

Barth was trained in the liberal tradition and broke with it in August 1914. He held that theology cannot begin from general religious experience or from a historical reconstruction judged by standards outside Scripture. Theology begins from God's self-disclosure in Jesus Christ as attested in Scripture. On this view a changed scholarly consensus cannot unmake the church's confession of Christ.

Key idea All theological knowledge answers to God's self-revelation in Christ.
At a glance

Two ways of starting

The liberal quest

Starts from historical method assumed to be naturalistic. Concern: the Gospels are theologically interested documents. Overreach: naturalism is assumed before the evidence.

Barth's reply

Starts from God's self-revelation in Christ. Corrects: theology is no longer founded on revisable history. Unresolved: his view of Scripture's status differs from this course's confessional doctrine.

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Ruling out the miraculous before examining the evidence is a philosophical move, not a historical result. The church's confession of Christ's deity does not depend on accepting that move. Barth corrects liberal method, but from an evangelical view he does not simply restore confessional orthodoxy.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11