FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST3E · Chapter 4

Lecture 4-6: Contemporary Gender Discourse and Queer Theology

The debate is about the scope of what Paul condemns, not about whether Scripture is authoritative.

Systematic Theology III: Anthropology

12 cards 22 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the affirming/revisionist theological case in its own terms, including at least two named theologians and their central arguments.
  • State the classical position's case in its own terms, including how it reads Romans 1:26-27 and responds to the affirming reading of that text.
  • Identify what specifically is contested about Romans 1:26-27's meaning and scope, rather than treating the disagreement as simply about whether Scripture is authoritative.
  • Describe what pastoral resources this lecture argues the classical position needs to offer, and why offering the theological argument alone, without those resources, fails the pastoral half of this course's stated discipline.
The approach

Fair statements first

The lecture states the affirming case first. Justin Lee and Megan DeFranza appeal to created diversity. The pastoral argument cites documented harm to gay and lesbian youth in conservative churches.

Key idea The affirming case is heard before the classical one.
Scripture

Why Romans 1:26-27?

The lecture uses this passage as the central text in the debate. It sits inside Paul's larger argument in Romans 1:18-32 about exchanging the truth about God for idolatry, and Romans 2:1 turns the argument on the reader. Any reading, on either side, has to reckon with that context.

For this reason, God gave them up to vile passions. For their women changed the natural function into that which is against nature. Likewise also the men, leaving the natural function of the woman, burned in their lust toward one another, men doing what is inappropriate with men, and receiving in themselves the due penalty of their error." Romans 1:26-27 · World English Bible
Affirming reading

Specific ancient patterns

James V. Brownson and Matthew Vines read Romans 1:26-27 as aimed at specific ancient patterns, such as exploitation, idolatry or acts against one's own orientation. They do not think it addresses committed same-sex unions.

Key idea The affirming reading limits the verse to certain patterns.
Classical reading

The created order

Robert Gagnon, for the classical position, says Paul draws on the created order of Genesis 1-2. The classical view has been the teaching of Catholic, Orthodox and most Protestant churches.

Key idea The classical reading rests on creation.
At a glance

Two readings

Affirming

Romans 1:26-27 aims at specific ancient patterns, not committed same-sex unions.

Classical

Paul draws on the created order of Genesis 1-2, so the verse reaches further.

Common ground

What is disputed

Both sides agree Romans 1:26-27 condemns something. The dispute is about its scope. The lecture judges the classical exegesis stronger, while saying readers will not agree. Both sides intend to obey what they think Paul means.

Key idea The dispute is about scope.
Pastoral duty

Belonging for celibate believers

Wesley Hill and Preston Sprinkle argue that the classical view requires real community and belonging for celibate believers. Churches that did not build this share the blame for the harm.

Key idea Teaching needs real community behind it.
Think about it

The person in front of you

The lecture says not to let the argument be your last word to the person in front of you.

What would real community and belonging look like in your church?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The real dispute is the scope of what Paul condemns, not whether Scripture is authoritative. A reader can hold the classical exegesis and still say churches have failed the pastoral half of their own teaching.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12