FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST4E · Chapter 1

Lecture 1-1: What Sin Is — A Working Definition

Sin has to be defined along three dimensions at once, relational, legal and moral, because dropping any one distorts both the offense and the remedy.

Systematic Theology IV: Hamartiology

13 cards 16 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State sin's three dimensions — relational, legal, and moral — with a biblical text anchoring each.
  • Explain what is lost, specifically, when a definition of sin is only relational or only legal.
  • Name Reinhold Niebuhr's account of sin as pride, and the feminist theological critique (Valerie Saiving, Judith Plaskow) that sin can also take the shape of sloth or self-negation, as two different diagnoses this course will not collapse into one.
  • State a working definition of sin that could organize the rest of this course's material.
The problem

Many sincere definitions, none complete

Ask Christians to define sin and you hear breaking God's law, rebelling against God, falling short of what we were made to be, hurting others, missing the mark. None is wrong. The problem is that each one, treated as the whole definition, quietly narrows a word Scripture uses more broadly. The lecture does not pick one and discard the rest.

Key idea Sin needs at least three dimensions held together.
Scripture

Why Romans 3:23?

The lecture calls this the verse the whole course keeps returning to. It notes that "sinned" names an act while "fall short of the glory of God" reads more like a condition, and the sentence holds both together.

For all have sinned, and fall short of the glory of God." Romans 3:23 · World English Bible
Dimension one

Relational: an offense against a person

In its most basic biblical shape sin is an offense against God. Isaiah speaks of iniquities that separate and sins that hide God's face, which is language of a rupture between persons. In Genesis 3 Adam and Eve do not first receive a legal verdict; they hide, because fellowship has broken. Sin costs a relationship, not merely a record.

Key idea Sin is done against someone.
Dimension two

Legal: transgression and guilt

Sin is also the crossing of a real line before a real Judge. John states it almost as a formal definition, that sin is lawlessness, and Paul says the wages of sin is death. The lecture reads this as insisting that God's moral law is not a metaphor. Guilt, liability and a debt are not something a purely relational account can absorb.

Key idea A wage is earned, not merely felt.
Dimension three

Moral: a corruption of the sinner's character

Jesus locates the source of sin inside the person, in the heart that produces evil thoughts, murders, deceit and pride. Jeremiah's diagnosis of a deceitful and corrupt heart agrees. This is neither relational language about an offended party nor strictly legal language about a violated statute. It describes a condition, a heart that generates evil the way a corrupted spring generates bad water.

Key idea Sin is not only an act committed or a law broken.
At a glance

What each reduction loses

Relational only

It keeps something true, that sin is personal. But it struggles to explain Paul's legal categories such as wrath, condemnation and a righteousness that must be credited. Something Scripture treats as forensic becomes merely emotional.

Legal only

It keeps something true, that guilt is real. But the relational and moral dimensions can look optional, as if a debt could be paid while the person still hides from God and still generates evil from within.

Live disagreement

Pride or self-negation?

Niebuhr: pride

Reinhold Niebuhr named pride, the self's assertion against God and others, as sin's paradigm case. The serpent's promise in Genesis 3:5, "you will be like God," fits this pattern.

Saiving and Plaskow: self-negation

They argued the more common sin for the diminished can be sloth and a failure to become a self. The parable of the talents fits this, where the servant is called wicked and slothful for burying what he was given.

Working definition

Putting the three together

Sin is rebellion against God, which is relational. It incurs real guilt before God's law, which is legal. It corrupts the sinner's own character, which is moral, whether that shows as self-assertion or self-negation. The lecture says this is not an elegant formula meant to resolve every tension. It is sturdy enough to organize Chapters 2 to 5.

Key idea A tidy definition is worth being suspicious of.
Think about it

Which dimension dominates?

The lecture asks you to describe a wrong you have done or witnessed.

Can you name its relational, legal and moral dimensions separately, or does one dominate your instinct, and which dimension has your own tradition emphasized?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Sin is an offense against God as a person, a breach of God's law, and a corruption of the sinner's character. Dropping any one dimension distorts the doctrine and the remedy. Pride and self-negation are both real patterns, and readers will not all agree on the balance.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13