FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST4E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-4: Sin's Legal and Ethical Dimension

Scripture also speaks of sin in the register of law, and this legal dimension complements the relational one rather than competing with it.

Systematic Theology IV: Hamartiology

12 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State what it means to call sin "transgression of God's law" and "missing the mark of his righteous standard," and show how both draw on vocabulary already studied in 2-1 and 2-2.
  • Name and briefly explain the classical Reformed threefold use of the law (civil, pedagogical, and normative/didactic uses), and identify which use this lecture previews for fuller treatment in 2-5.
  • State the Roman Catholic distinction between mortal and venial sin, including the three conditions traditionally required for mortal sin, and explain what pastoral and theological work this distinction is doing.
  • Explain why treating sin's legal dimension and its relational dimension (2-3) as competing accounts, rather than complementary ones, misreads both.
The companion

Sin and law

Lecture 2-3 argued sin's deepest shape is relational. That argument needs a companion, not a correction, because Scripture speaks of sin constantly in the register of law, standard and transgression. A hamartiology that talked only about ruptured relationship would lose something the biblical vocabulary insists on. The lecture reads 1 John 3:4 again, this time for what it says about law.

Key idea Two angles on one reality.
Scripture

Why Romans 7:7?

The lecture uses this verse because Paul's example is coveting, the one commandment that names an internal desire. This makes the law's function include exposing a condition of the heart, not only policing behavior.

What shall we say then? Is the law sin? May it never be! However, I wouldn't have known sin, except through the law. For I wouldn't have known coveting, unless the law had said, 'You shall not covet.'" Romans 7:7 · World English Bible
Transgression

Lawbreaking and rebelling are one act

Romans 3:20 says the knowledge of sin comes through the law, and James 2:10 treats the law as one unified standard. None of this cancels the Genesis 3 reading as usurpation. A law exists, on the classical account, because a personal Lawgiver has spoken. Transgressing the law and rebelling against the Lawgiver are two descriptions of a single act.

Key idea They are not competing theories of what sin is.
The mark

A standard outside the archer

A target implies a standard external to the archer, against which the shot is measured. This rules out a purely self-referential account of failure, since sin is not only failing one's own ideals. Romans 3:23 makes the glory of God the target every person has missed. The legal dimension is the claim that the ruptured relationship was governed by a real and specific standard.

Key idea It is not a cold juridical add-on.
Reformed view

The threefold use of the law

The civil use restrains sin in society, even among the unconverted. The pedagogical use exposes sin and, as Galatians 3:24 calls it, a tutor leading the sinner toward Christ. The normative use guides the life of someone already regenerate, as a grateful pattern rather than a way to earn standing. The lecture previews the second use for Lecture 2-5.

Key idea The formulation is often traced to Calvin, with a Lutheran parallel.
At a glance

Mortal and venial sin

Mortal sin

In Catholic moral theology it requires grave matter, full knowledge and deliberate consent together. It severs the soul's relationship with sanctifying grace and needs sacramental confession to be restored.

Venial sin

It is a real offense against God but wounds rather than severs the relationship of grace, because the matter is less grave or full knowledge or consent was lacking.

Two traditions

Stated fairly, not adjudicated

The lecture does not judge whether the mortal and venial framework or a Protestant framework better renders the biblical data. It notes the Catholic framework takes seriously that sins differ in weight while insisting that a lesser sin is still a real breach needing repentance. Both traditions have read James 2:10, and Catholic readers do not see it as refuting the distinction.

Key idea Venial sin must not be taken as harmless.
Think about it

Legal and relational together

The lecture shows 1 John 3:4 calling sin lawlessness, while 1 John 3:6 treats abiding in Christ as its opposite.

Do you tend to speak of sin only as broken law or only as broken relationship, and what does each emphasis leave out?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Sin as lawlessness and sin as rebellion against a person are not competing theories, because a law exists since a personal Lawgiver has spoken. The lecture states the Reformed threefold use of the law and the Catholic mortal and venial distinction without judging between them.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12