Valerie Saiving argued in 1960 that describing sin as pride, and the remedy as self-sacrifice, fits someone already secure in identity and standing. For people taught to distrust their own judgment, the temptation runs the other way: diffuseness, timidity, dependence on others for self-definition, and underdevelopment of the self. Judith Plaskow extended the argument, warning that a pride-only account can hand such people one more call to self-sacrifice.
Key idea The critique rests on social and pastoral observation.