FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST5E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-2: The Effectual Call

This lecture states the Reformed case that God gives an effectual call that brings the elect to faith.

Systematic Theology V: Soteriology

12 cards 15 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Define the effectual call and distinguish it from the general call of 2-1.
  • State the Reformed exegetical case for reading John 6:44's "draws" as an effectual, ultimately successful work of the Spirit, including its connection to John 6:37's "all that the Father gives me will come."
  • Explain what "irresistible grace" does and does not claim — in particular, that it does not claim the sinner is dragged unwillingly against a still-resistant will, but that the will itself is changed so that it freely comes.
  • Name at least one Arminian objection to the Reformed reading of helkyo, stated in a form an Arminian theologian would recognize as their own argument (2-3 develops this fully).
The question

Why do some believe and not others?

The gospel is preached to everyone sincerely, but not everyone who hears it believes. One answer says the difference lies entirely in the hearer, with nothing further from God's side. The Reformed tradition finds this inadequate to Scripture's account of human inability: a sinner dead in sin needs to be made alive before any offer can be received. The effectual call is the Reformed name for the further, effective work of God that explains why anyone believes at all.

Key idea The effectual call is also called the internal call.
Scripture

Why John 6:44?

The lecture uses this verse because it is Jesus's own explanation for why some in a crowd that had just witnessed a miracle do not believe. It says "no one can come," not merely that no one does, and the lecture pairs it with John 6:37 as the textual center of the whole discussion.

No one can come to me unless the Father who sent me draws him, and I will raise him up in the last day." John 6:44 · World English Bible
The Reformed case

Inability plus an accomplished result

John 6:44 states an inability as flatly as the doctrine of total depravity requires: no one can come unless the Father draws. Verse 37 pairs a result with it: all that the Father gives will come. Put together, those the Father gives to the Son are drawn by the Father, and being drawn, they come. The drawing does not merely make coming possible, it results in actual coming among those given.

Key idea Verse 65 repeats the point about inability, which the Reformed tradition reads as deliberate emphasis.
The verb

What helkyo means elsewhere

The Greek verb behind "draws," helkyo, is used elsewhere in the New Testament for pulling with real, decisive force, such as hauling a net full of fish, drawing a sword, or dragging a person before a court. Reformed exegetes including D.A. Carson and John Piper argue that a verb used this way is a poor candidate for a merely gentle, easily resisted invitation.

Key idea The argument rests on how the verb is used across the New Testament.
Irresistible grace

What it does not claim

The claim is not that God drags an unwilling sinner into the kingdom against a will that remains opposed throughout. The Canons of Dort say the Spirit's work changes the will itself, penetrating the inmost being and softening a heart Scripture calls stony, so that the sinner, now willing, freely and gladly comes. The coming is genuinely the sinner's own free act, proceeding from an actual desire that was given rather than self-generated.

Key idea Grace acts from within the will, so the result is a new inclination, not coercion.
Pastoral stakes

Where faith rests

If this reading is correct, faith's ultimate ground is the Father's effective drawing, not the sinner's own decisive contribution. The Reformed tradition takes this to be good news, because a believer's faith rests on a work of God that, having begun, secures its own result. This connects forward to perseverance: if the same effectual grace that begins faith sustains it, the ground of security was never primarily the believer's own grip on God.

Key idea Assurance rests on the God who called, not on how steady one's choosing feels.
Two readings

How "draws" is read

Reformed reading (this lecture)

Draws means an effective pull. Paired with John 6:37, those drawn will come, because the Spirit changes the will from within. Defended by Carson, Piper and the Canons of Dort.

Arminian reading (lecture 2-3)

Draws means a strong, persuasive wooing that can in fact be resisted, given through prevenient grace to all who hear. Defended by Arminius, Olson and Marshall.

Think about it

A flat or a weakened "cannot"?

John 6:44 says "no one can come" without the Father's drawing.

What would it mean for this claim to be true only in a weakened sense, such as "coming is hard without it"? Does the surrounding discourse, especially verse 65, support the flat reading?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

In the Reformed view, grace does not force the will but renews it, so the sinner comes freely because God first changed the desire. The lecture gives only the Reformed side, and readers will not agree; the next lecture states the Arminian and Wesleyan case with equal seriousness. Rest your assurance on the God who called you, not on how steady your own choosing feels.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12