FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST5E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-3: Prevenient Grace

Prevenient grace is the view that God gives every hearer of the gospel a grace that comes before faith and makes a real response possible.

Systematic Theology V: Soteriology

13 cards 17 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Define prevenient grace and state why it is compatible with, not a denial of, total depravity as ST4 defined it.
  • State the Wesleyan case for prevenient grace from Titus 2:11 and John 12:32, and the Catholic doctrine of "actual grace" as a related but not identical concept.
  • State the Reformed objection that any grace sufficient to enable a genuinely free response is functionally indistinguishable from effectual calling itself, and explain what would have to be true for that objection to fail.
  • Identify what, specifically, the Arminian and Wesleyan positions claim the human will needs before it can respond to the gospel, and how this differs from what the Reformed position (2-2) claims it needs.
The idea

What is prevenient grace?

Prevenient grace (Latin gratia praeveniens, "grace that comes before") is the conviction that God gives a real grace to every person who hears the gospel. It comes prior to and apart from regeneration. It is sufficient to restore enough freedom of will that a genuine, uncoerced response of faith or unbelief becomes possible. Arminians, Wesleyans, Roman Catholics and, in its own idiom, the Eastern Orthodox have held a position of this kind.

Key idea Grace comes first, and it reaches everyone who hears.
The problem

The problem it is built to solve

Total depravity means sin has corrupted every part of the sinner, including the will. Arminian and Wesleyan theology affirms this as strongly as Reformed theology does. If a sinner cannot respond unaided, yet Scripture commands every hearer to respond, something must explain how that command is a real command and not mockery. The Reformed answer is the effectual call given to the elect, and the Arminian and Wesleyan answer is a grace given to every hearer.

Key idea The two sides agree on the depth of the fall and differ on what happens next.
Scripture

Why Titus 2:11-12?

The lecture uses this verse because its language is universal: the grace that has appeared brings salvation to all people. Wesleyan and Arminian readers take it as evidence that grace's saving appearance is genuinely universal in its reach.

For the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation to all men, instructing us to the intent that, denying ungodliness and worldly lusts, we would live soberly, righteously, and godly in this present world." Titus 2:11-12 · World English Bible
Wesleyan case

Wesley's light for every person

John Wesley grounds prevenient grace in the light that "enlightens every man that comes into the world," his allusion to John 1:9. Some measure of grace reaches every human conscience, producing the first wish to please God and the beginning of a deliverance from a hard heart. Wesley is explicit that none of this is the sinner's own achievement. It is grace from first to last, given more widely and before regeneration. He is joined by readings of John 12:32 and Romans 2:4.

Key idea For Wesley, the early stirrings toward God are already grace.
Catholic doctrine

Actual grace is related, not identical

Catholic theology, following the Second Council of Orange and Trent, holds that fallen humanity cannot take even the first step toward salvation by its own natural powers. What Trent calls actual grace is God's own prior movement and assistance, given before justification. The key difference from the Reformed position is not whether this grace is necessary and prior, but whether it is resistible. Trent holds that the will, though moved by grace, remains free to reject it.

Key idea The two positions are structurally similar but should not be flattened into one.
Reformed objection

Does this quietly bring back human merit?

If this grace really restores the ability to believe, then it is doing the work the Reformed attribute to the effectual call. Calling it resistible only relocates the moment at which grace becomes sufficient to the sinner's own later choice. If two sinners receive the same grace and only one believes, the Reformed ask what accounts for the difference if not something grace did not supply. The Canons of Dort argue that this reintroduces a self-originating human contribution to salvation.

Key idea The objection presses on what explains the difference between two believers and non-believers.
The reply

The Arminian and Wesleyan reply

The reply, from Roger Olson and from Arminius's own writings, is that the objection assumes what it needs to prove. It assumes the only way to account for one sinner believing and another not is a further prior cause, either wholly in God or partly in the sinner. A truly free created will can be the actual, non-arbitrary explanation of its own choice. Whether such a choice is coherent is a live philosophical question the lecture does not resolve.

Key idea The lecture leaves the free-will question open.
At a glance

Three accounts of grace before faith

Reformed

The effectual call is given only to the elect. It does not merely enable a response but secures the actual result.

Arminian and Wesleyan

Prevenient grace is given to every hearer. It restores the ability to respond without guaranteeing it, and the freed will decides yes or no.

Catholic

Actual grace comes before justification and is necessary for any movement toward faith, but it is resistible. It is framed within the sacramental economy.

Think about it

What is left to disagree about?

All the traditions in this lecture agree that grace is necessary and comes first.

Given that much agreement, what is actually left to disagree about? State it in your own words, without either side's technical vocabulary.

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Prevenient grace is grace that comes before: God gives every hearer enough grace for a real yes or no, alongside full total depravity. The Reformed objection is that such grace does the work of effectual calling, and the Arminian and Wesleyan reply is that a free will can account for its own choice. Every tradition here says grace is necessary and first, and they differ on whether grace alone explains why a sinner believes.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13