FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST6E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-3: The Filioque Controversy

One added clause, "and the Son", separates East and West, and each side has serious reasons that the lecture states without choosing.

Systematic Theology VI: Pneumatology

11 cards 23 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State what the filioque clause actually adds to the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed, and locate it precisely within the Creed's third article.
  • Trace the outline of how the clause entered Western usage — its origin as a regional, anti-Arian addition and its gradual spread into the Roman rite — and distinguish that historical question from the theological question of whether the doctrine itself is true.
  • State the Eastern objection to the filioque on two separate grounds — theological (the Father's monarchy) and procedural (unilateral alteration of an ecumenical creed) — without collapsing the two into one complaint.
  • State the Western case for the filioque, including at least one argument from Augustine or Aquinas, in a form a Western theologian would recognize as fair.
  • Explain what is actually at stake in the dispute beyond wording, and identify at least one point of remaining disagreement even after twentieth-century ecumenical efforts to narrow it.
The clause

What the filioque adds

The creed of Constantinople says the Spirit "proceeds from the Father". Most of the Western church came to say "from the Father and the Son". The added Latin word filioque means "and the Son". The Greek East never made this addition. The dispute is over one clause in a text both sides share.

Key idea The dispute is about whether one clause belongs in the creed.
Scripture

Why John 15:26?

The lecture uses this verse because every party accepts it as authoritative and disagrees over what it settles. Jesus says the Spirit proceeds from the Father, and also that he will send the Spirit from the Father. The verse does not use "and" to join the Father and the Son as a joint source.

'When the Counselor has come, whom I will send to you from the Father, the Spirit of truth, who proceeds from the Father, he will testify about me.'" John 15:26 · World English Bible
History

How the clause entered the West

The clause is usually traced to the Third Council of Toledo in 589, a Spanish synod receiving Arian nobles into Nicene faith. It spread through Frankish lands. Pope Leo III agreed with the theology but declined to alter an ecumenical creed on his own authority. Rome's own liturgy did not include it until the early eleventh century. Its spread was gradual and regional, not a single act of aggression.

Key idea It began as a regional, anti-Arian addition.
At a glance

Two Eastern objections

Procedural

The Council of Ephesus (431) forbade composing a different faith. No single patriarchate, Rome included, may rewrite an ecumenical creed alone, and the manner of the change is a grievance apart from its content.

Theological

The Father alone is the source, the monarchy of the Father. Photius argued that two sources blur the Father's and the Son's distinct personal properties. This is not subordinationism, since Son and Spirit are fully God.

The Western case

Augustine and Aquinas

Augustine's mutual-love model makes the Spirit the bond of love between Father and Son, so the Spirit is not only the Father's gift. Aquinas argues the persons are distinguished by their relations of origin. If the Spirit proceeded from the Father exactly as the Son is generated, nothing would distinguish procession from generation except two words. Westerners also cite John 20:22 and Paul's phrases "Spirit of Christ" and "Spirit of his Son".

Key idea The West argues the Son shares in the Spirit's procession.
Dialogue

Where talks have landed

The filioque was named in the mutual excommunications of 1054, though the estrangement developed over centuries. A formula linked to Maximus the Confessor says the Spirit proceeds from the Father through the Son. The Vatican's 1995 clarification affirmed the Father as the sole "principle without principle". Vladimir Lossky still saw a deeper difference in theological method, so agreed wording does not settle it.

Key idea Dialogue has narrowed the gap but not closed it.
Think about it

Reciting the creed differently

Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant readers may recite the creed with different wording.

How could you state each side's reasons fairly, and name the history behind the wording, before judging?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The filioque dispute is about one clause, but it concerns how the persons of the Trinity relate and who may change an ecumenical creed. Each side has serious reasons, and the lecture does not choose between them. State each side's case fairly and name the history behind the wording.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11