FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST9E · Chapter 4

Lecture 4-2: Reformation Ethics — Law, Gospel, and the Third Use

Luther taught two uses of the law and Calvin added a third, and both agree that the law cannot justify.

Systematic Theology IX: Christian Ethics

11 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Luther's civil and theological uses of the law and explain what distinct function each performs.
  • State Calvin's third, didactic use and explain what it adds that the first two uses, on their own, do not supply.
  • Explain why the debate over a third use is not merely a historical curiosity but bears directly on how a Christian today should read Old Testament law — connecting this to 2-1's threefold-division discussion.
  • Identify at least one reason a Lutheran and a Reformed reader might, in practice, apply the same Old Testament text differently because of this disagreement.
  • State a pastoral or practical danger each side of this debate is especially alert to guarding against.
The question

What is the law for?

Lecture 2-1 asked which parts of Old Testament law remain binding. This lecture asks an older question: what function the law is supposed to serve in a believer's life at all. The lecture says the answer shapes how a Christian today reads the whole Old Testament law, either as a document that only exposes sin or as one that also teaches what a transformed life looks like.

Key idea The debate is about the law's function, not only its scope.
Luther

Two uses: civil and theological

The civil use is the law's function in ordinary society, restraining outward sin among believers and unbelievers alike. The theological use is, for Luther, the primary one. It exposes sin, strips away self-righteousness and drives the sinner to Christ, as in Galatians 3:24. Once a person has faith, the law mainly remains diagnostic, exposing remaining sin in one who is simul iustus et peccator, simultaneously righteous and a sinner.

Key idea For Luther the law restrains society and drives sinners to Christ.
Calvin

A third use for the regenerate

John Calvin affirmed both of Luther's uses and added a third, the didactic or normative use. In the Institutes (1559, Book II, chapter 7) he called it the principal use for believers. The law continues to guide the regenerate believer, whose will the Spirit is renewing, by showing what a life pleasing to God looks like. Calvin's argument is that a forgiven believer still needs positive instruction.

Key idea The law keeps teaching after faith.
Scripture

Why Psalm 19:7-11?

The lecture uses this psalm as Calvin's favored text for the third use. The lecture says its verbs are positive and present-tense: the law restores the soul, rejoices the heart and is sweeter than honey to one who already belongs to God.

Yahweh's law is perfect, restoring the soul. Yahweh's testimony is sure, making wise the simple. Yahweh's precepts are right, rejoicing the heart. Yahweh's commandment is pure, enlightening the eyes. The fear of Yahweh is clean, enduring forever. Yahweh's ordinances are true, and righteous altogether. More to be desired are they than gold, yes, than much fine gold; sweeter also than honey and the extract of the honeycomb. Moreover by them is your servant warned. In keeping them there is great reward." Psalm 19:7-11 · World English Bible
At a glance

How each reader approaches an Old Testament text

Luther's two uses

The reader asks first how a text exposes sin and points to Christ, alert to a righteousness-by-works logic returning. The lecture says pressed too far this risks leaving a believer without positive instruction, a practical antinomianism.

Calvin's three uses

The reader moves more directly to positive, present-tense instruction. The lecture says pressed carelessly this risks a drift toward treating law-keeping as the substance of maturity, the legalism of 3-1.

Shared ground

A narrower dispute than it sounds

Neither side denies that the moral law's substance remains binding, and neither wants lawless or self-righteous obedience. Both share the indicative-imperative pattern in Paul from 2-3, which grounds command in a prior accomplished reality. The lecture says the dispute is whether, once united to Christ, the law's positive teaching role is to be leaned into directly or approached cautiously.

Key idea Both traditions try to avoid the same two errors.
Think about it

Which danger is more common?

The lecture names a danger each side guards against.

In churches you know, is practical antinomianism or a drift toward legalism the more common danger, and why?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Luther taught the civil and theological uses of the law, and Calvin added a third, didactic use. Both traditions agree the law cannot justify, and the lecture names no winner. Teach the law's commands in a way that keeps the gospel's priority clear, so obedience never becomes a way to earn acceptance.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11