FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST9E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-4: Public Theology and Faithful Presence

Hunter says cultural change comes through patient presence in institutions, not mainly through political power, and he calls this faithful presence.

Systematic Theology IX: Christian Ethics

12 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Hunter's critique of "defensive against," "relevance to," and "purity from" as three standard postures of Christian cultural engagement, in a form each posture's own proponents would recognize as fair, before stating Hunter's objection to each.
  • State Hunter's proposed alternative of "faithful presence," and explain what distinguishes it from a strategy oriented primarily toward acquiring political power.
  • Explain how a religiously plural, increasingly post-Christian society changes the manner of Christian ethical witness while this lecture argues it does not change the content of that witness, and state one text (Jeremiah 29:7 or 1 Peter 2:11-12) that supports this distinction.
  • Connect faithful presence back to Lecture 4-5's Niebuhr typology, explaining why Hunter's proposal resists being placed neatly within any one of Niebuhr's five types.
The question

How should Christians engage a changed society?

Chapter 5 covered specific contested issues. This lecture steps back to ask how Christians should engage a society that no longer assumes their convictions, and how cultural influence actually works. It draws on James Davison Hunter's To Change the World, which critiques standard models and proposes faithful presence. The lecture states each model fairly before engaging Hunter's objection.

Key idea The question is how to engage, before asking what to say.
At a glance

Three standard postures

Defensive against

Associated with the politically engaged religious right. Proponents hold that public life has moved in a direction the church cannot treat as negotiable, so convictions must be contested through politics and law.

Relevance to

Associated with the politically engaged religious left. Proponents hold that the church's credibility depends on caring about concerns the culture already sees as urgent, such as poverty, racial justice and the environment.

Purity from

Associated with a neo-Anabaptist tradition including Stanley Hauerwas. Proponents hold that the church's chief witness is being a distinct, visible community, largely apart from worldly power.

Hunter's critique

A shared assumption

Hunter does not call any of the three insincere. He argues they share a mistaken view of how culture changes, that it comes chiefly through political power or the moral example of one community. His historical argument is that culture changes through sustained work of networks of elites in culture-forming institutions over long periods. These include universities, publishing, law, the arts and technology.

Key idea Confidence in national politics as the lever of change is misplaced.
The alternative

Faithful presence

Faithful presence asks Christians to embody their convictions with integrity within the spheres they already occupy. It has three dimensions: presence within one's calling, presence to others in genuine relationship, and presence for the good of others and of institutions. It is not political disengagement, since Hunter does not tell Christians to avoid voting or office. It relocates primary confidence from the next election to patient, relational presence.

Key idea Within, to and for: present where you are, for others' good.
Scripture

Why Jeremiah 29:7?

The lecture uses this verse as faithful presence's closest biblical antecedent. Exiles with no power in Babylon are told to seek its peace and pray for it.

Seek the peace of the city where I have caused you to be carried away captive, and pray to Yahweh for it; for in its peace you shall have peace." Jeremiah 29:7 · World English Bible
Manner, not content

What changes in a plural society

The lecture draws on 1 Peter 2:11-12, where believers scattered as foreigners and pilgrims are to keep good conduct among the nations. It says the content of Christian conviction does not change when the culture no longer shares it. What changes is the manner: patient persuasion, humility about the church's own failures, and relationships of trust built over time. It rejects both softening the content and assuming automatic cultural authority.

Key idea Hold the content steady and change the manner.
Niebuhr

Not a sixth type

Hunter does not add faithful presence as a sixth type beside Niebuhr's five. He argues that even Christ transforming culture has often been practiced with the same mistaken confidence in political power. So faithful presence is a correction to how any posture is lived out. The lecture states Hunter's claim and leaves open whether he is right that transformationist Christians have made this mistake as often as others.

Key idea Faithful presence corrects how a posture is lived, not which one is chosen.
Think about it

Your own sphere

The lecture asks what faithful presence would look like concretely in a vocation or institution you belong to.

In a specific workplace, neighborhood or institution of yours, what would presence within, to and for others actually involve?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Put confidence in patient, relationship-based presence within your own spheres of influence, not mainly in winning elections. Faithful presence is not political withdrawal. Keep your convictions unchanged, but hold them out with patience, humility and real care for your neighbors.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12