Lecture 1-2: Faith and Reason Across Church History
Augustine, Aquinas and Calvin give three real answers to how far reason can go before revelation is needed.
Christian Apologetics
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Augustine, Aquinas and Calvin give three real answers to how far reason can go before revelation is needed.
Christian Apologetics
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
It is tempting to read faith and reason as one question with one traditional answer, refined from Augustine to Aquinas to Calvin. That is not what the sources show. These are not three stages of one growing insight. They are three real answers, each still alive in some part of the church today, to how far reason can travel before it needs revelation.
Augustine tried for years as a young man to reason his way to truth before committing himself to faith, and found that approach did not work. His mature position is credo ut intelligam, "I believe in order to understand." Faith is not the last step after reason has done all it can. It is a necessary first step that makes real understanding possible.
Augustine read Isaiah 7:9 in an Old Latin text, which rendered the line closer to "unless you believe, you will not understand." The World English Bible is more literal to the Hebrew wordplay, in which "believe" and "be established" share one root. The two differ because they come from different textual traditions and translation choices, not because either is in error.
Aquinas distinguishes natural theology, truths about God that unaided reason can in principle discover, from revealed theology, truths reason cannot reach without God's self-disclosure. His Five Ways start from motion, causation, contingency, degrees of perfection and apparent purpose in nature. Each, on its own terms, establishes a first cause or necessary being, not yet the full biblical God. That further identification belongs to revealed theology.
Calvin affirms the sensus divinitatis, a "sense of divinity" implanted in every person simply by being human. He adds the noetic effects of sin, meaning sin's effects on the mind's capacity to reason rightly. In his view, fallen reason does not merely lack information. It actively distorts and suppresses the knowledge of God it does have.
Faith enables right reasoning, not the reverse. Truths about God are not reliably reached by a mind working independently of trust.
Natural theology and revealed theology are two architecturally separate projects. Reason can establish some truths about God before revelation is needed.
The sensus divinitatis is real, but without the Spirit's work, fallen reason is reliably distorted rather than reliably available.
All three affirm that God is genuinely knowable, that reason is a real gift rather than an obstacle to faith, and that Romans 1:19-20 is true and not a rhetorical flourish. None treats reason as worthless, and none treats it as sufficient on its own to reach saving knowledge of God. The disagreement is about degree and sequence, within a shared conviction that faith and reason belong together.
The lecture notes that the Five Ways establish a first cause, not yet the specific biblical God.
Why might overstating what an argument proves actually weaken an apologetic conversation?
Augustine, Aquinas and Calvin all affirm that God is knowable and that reason is a real gift. They differ on how far reason reaches and how reliable fallen reason is, and the lecture picks no winner. Use reason gladly, and be honest about what an argument can and cannot show.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.