FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

STEL1E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-1: What Is Truth?

The course defines truth as correspondence to reality, because every later argument assumes true and false are real categories.

Christian Apologetics

12 cards 17 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the correspondence theory of truth in one sentence and give an example of a true and a false statement under it.
  • Explain, briefly and fairly, what the coherence and pragmatic theories of truth claim, and name one limitation of each.
  • Explain the literary and historical significance of Pilate's question in John 18:38 - what it reveals about Pilate, and what John's Gospel leaves unresolved at that moment.
  • State why John 14:6 answers Pilate's question, without yet developing the full argument for that claim (reserved for chapter 6).
Why start here

Truth before arguments

Every later argument in the course takes the form "claim X is true, and here is why." If "true" is not a stable, meaningful category to begin with, every one of those arguments collapses before it starts, however carefully its premises are defended. The reason for starting here is structural, not stalling.

Key idea Without a clear meaning of "true," later arguments have no footing.
Working definition

Truth matches reality

A statement is true if it corresponds to, matches or describes accurately, the way reality actually is, and false if it does not. "It is raining outside" is true exactly when it is in fact raining, whether or not anyone believes it or finds it useful. Aristotle stated an early version in the Metaphysics: to say of what is that it is, and of what is not that it is not, is true.

Key idea Truth is a relationship between a statement and the world.
Three features

Objective, bivalent, discoverable

First, truth is objective: it does not depend on the speaker's sincerity, culture or conviction. Second, a factual claim is either true or false, not both and not something in between. Third, truth is discoverable through evidence, so examining reality historically, textually, philosophically or scientifically is a legitimate way to find it out. Every later chapter depends on that last assumption.

Key idea Evidence is a legitimate route to truth, not a distraction from faith.
At a glance

Three theories of truth

Correspondence

A statement is true if it matches reality. This is the course's working definition.

Coherence

A belief is true if it fits consistently with one's other beliefs. It is a good test, but a perfectly consistent conspiracy theory or work of fiction can still be false.

Pragmatic

A belief is true if it works in practice. But usefulness and truth can come apart, as with a comforting lie.

A fair note

The debate is not closed

Philosophers continue to debate whether the three accounts can be partly reconciled, and some contemporary theories, such as deflationary and pluralist accounts, try to do exactly that. The course does not need to resolve that specialist debate. It adopts correspondence as its working definition, because the task is showing that historical and theological claims match what actually happened and what actually is.

Key idea The course adopts correspondence without settling every philosophical question.
John 18:38

Pilate's question, held open

Pilate asks "What is truth?" just after Jesus says he came "to testify to the truth," and then he walks out. Commentators read his tone as anything from curiosity to cynicism. John lets neither Pilate nor Jesus answer in this scene, which is deliberate craft. A reader who has followed the Gospel already has the answer in John 14:6, which chapter 6 develops.

Key idea Pilate asks the right question and does not wait for the answer.
In practice

Where conversations go wrong

Most real conversations about faith go wrong at the level of what "true" means, before either party notices. A partner who has absorbed a coherence or pragmatic notion, such as "that might be true for you," is not disagreeing about the evidence for the resurrection. They are working with a different concept of truth, and historical evidence will not land until that is named and addressed.

Key idea Name the disagreement about "true" before arguing about evidence.
Think about it

True for you

The lecture suggests that when someone says "true for you," the real disagreement may be about the meaning of the word.

In what situations might "that belief works well for me" be a poor guide to whether the belief is actually true?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

A statement is true when it matches reality, whatever anyone believes or finds useful. Coherence and usefulness are good signs of truth but are not the same thing as truth. When someone says "true for you," first ask what they mean by "true."

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12