Lecture 2-3: The Postmodern Challenge to Truth
Strong relativism about truth undermines itself, but a sound argument often fails unless the hurt behind the doubt is heard.
Christian Apologetics
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Strong relativism about truth undermines itself, but a sound argument often fails unless the hurt behind the doubt is heard.
Christian Apologetics
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
In its serious forms, the postmodern challenge is not the crude slogan "everything is relative." It begins with a defensible observation: every truth-claim is made by someone, somewhere, shaped by a particular language, history and set of interests. Claims that present themselves as neutral descriptions of reality often turn out to reinforce the position of whoever is making them.
His studies of prisons, clinics and the history of sexuality argue that what a society calls "true" in a given era is bound up with institutional power.
He defines the postmodern condition as "incredulity toward metanarratives," skepticism toward any single totalizing story that claims to explain and legitimate everything.
Institutions have used claims to objective truth to justify domination, and Christian institutions have not been innocent of this. An apologist who dismisses these observations has engaged a caricature, not the thinkers.
The difficulty is not the specific historical and institutional observations, which can largely be granted. It is the further claim that because truth-claims are entangled with power and culture, there is no truth that transcends them. On that view "true" reduces, without remainder, to what a power structure has succeeded in getting accepted. Stated this strongly, the position runs into a well-known problem.
The claim "there is no objective truth" is itself offered as an objective truth. If the speaker means it as only their own culturally conditioned opinion, it threatens no one who does not share it. If they mean it as a description of how truth works for everyone, it has made an exception of itself. Strong relativism cannot be held consistently by the person asserting it.
The argument does not prove that Christianity is true, that any specific religious claim is correct, or that Foucault's and Lyotard's specific observations are wrong. What it shows is narrower. The sweeping claim that all truth is relative to power or culture cannot coherently be asserted as a universal truth, so the door has not been closed.
Pointing out the self-referential problem rarely produces the reaction a philosophy classroom would predict. Many people reach relativism after real disappointment with a church, a political system or a family that claimed objective authority and abused it. The rebuttal can even confirm the suspicion that Christian argument is a trick for winning. Answering the logic without acknowledging the wound treats a whole person as only an argument.
The Preacher's refrain, "vanity of vanities," takes seriously the sense that life under the sun can feel repetitive and opaque. The book does not settle for that conclusion, since its final chapter turns back toward reverence for God. It earns that resolution by first sitting honestly with the same disorientation a postmodern critique names.
The lecture says a logically sound rebuttal often fails to persuade in an actual conversation.
What would you do differently in a real conversation compared to a philosophy exam?
Strong relativism cannot be asserted as universally true without exempting itself from its own rule. That shows the door to truth is open, but it does not prove Christianity. Before you answer the logic, listen for the hurt behind a person's doubt about truth.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.