FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

STEL1E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-1: Classical Apologetics

Classical apologetics argues first that God exists and then that the Christian God is revealed in Jesus, and its critics say logic is not the whole obstacle.

Christian Apologetics

12 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the two-step structure of classical apologetics and explain why its defenders think establishing theism first matters.
  • Name Aquinas as the method's historical representative and Craig and Geisler as contemporary ones, with one example of how each uses the two-step structure.
  • Explain the method's main internal critique: that a person's resistance to God is rarely a purely intellectual matter, so two logically careful steps can still fail to move someone who is not, at root, objecting on logical grounds.
  • Distinguish classical apologetics from the one-step, evidence-first method covered in 3-2.
The method

Two steps in order

Step one argues for theism: that a being exists who is the first cause of the universe, necessarily existent and supremely powerful. Step two argues for Christianity specifically: that this being is the God revealed in the Bible, that Jesus is his unique self-disclosure, and that the resurrection vindicates Jesus's claims. The method gets its name from this architecture, not from any single argument.

Key idea First the case for God, then the case for the Christian God.
The appeal

Why the order matters to its defenders

An atheist does not have to accept anything about the Bible, Jesus or the church to engage with step one. The case can in principle be built from philosophy, cosmology and moral experience, ground a skeptic and a Christian share. Defenders add that the resurrection needs a live possibility of a God who could act in history before it can count as evidence for anything.

Key idea Step one clears the ground that step two needs.
Aquinas

A two-tier structure in theology itself

Aquinas built this order into his theology. Natural theology is what reason can establish from the created order, and revealed theology is what is known only because God has spoken, chiefly the Trinity and the incarnation. His Five Ways belong to natural theology and offer proofs that a first cause or necessary being exists. He is explicit that they do not, by themselves, establish the triune God of Christian confession.

Key idea Aquinas separates what reason can show from what only revelation gives.
Today

Craig and Geisler

William Lane Craig's public debates typically open with several arguments for theism, chiefly the kalam cosmological argument, before turning more briefly to the resurrection as evidence for Christianity specifically. Norman Geisler's systematic apologetics follows the same two-stage shape at book length. Both establish theism as a philosophically defensible position before the specific historical and textual case.

Key idea The two-stage pattern continues in contemporary apologetics.
Acts 17

Paul in Athens

Paul's speech closely tracks the method's order. He begins where his hearers already stand, with their own altar and poets, and argues toward a Creator who is Lord of all. Only at the end does he turn to the specifically Christian claim of judgment and resurrection. Acts reports a mixed result: some mocked, some deferred, and some believed.

Key idea Even Paul's speech had a mixed reception.
Romans 1:20

Without excuse is not the same as converted

Romans 1:20 says something real about God's power and divinity is knowable through what has been made. The verse also carries a sober qualifier: this knowledge leaves people "without excuse," not automatically converted. On Paul's own terms, step one can succeed at establishing accountability without succeeding at producing faith.

Key idea Knowing about God and coming to faith are different outcomes.
At a glance

The critique and the replies

The internal critique

Unbelief is rarely purely intellectual. Resistance is often bound up with pain, pride, a bad experience of the church or a settled unwillingness to reconsider, and a sound argument can leave a hearer persuaded but personally unmoved.

Defenders of the order

Careful step-by-step argument remains indispensable, because reason clears real obstacles even where it cannot produce faith, which Scripture also treats as a work of the Spirit.

Other methods

Evidentialists and presuppositionalists conclude that the two-step order itself is the problem and argue for starting somewhere else.

Think about it

Measuring success

Acts 17:34 reports mockery, polite deferral and some who believed.

What does this ending suggest about how success should be measured in apologetics?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Classical apologetics argues first for a God who exists, then for the Christian God revealed in Jesus. Its main internal critique is that two sound steps can leave a person persuaded but unmoved. The lecture does not decide whether the order is right, so pray as you reason, since faith is also the Spirit's work.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12